5 ms·
Snopes.com prevails in tentative court ruling over finances, ownership
- Animats 9y agoOh, it's a divorce-related issue. Ex-wife sold half ownership.
- dqv 9y agoHaha. Is there a joke on HN about this? I swear every thread discussing Snopes has someone say the exact phrase "oh, it's a divorce-related issue". It gets me every time.
- jonny_eh 9y agoYa, I made that comment when the gofundme was first posted. In business disputes I always wonder "how did it go wrong", especially with smart people like the Mikkelsons.
- jacquesm 9y ago> In business disputes I always wonder "how did it go wrong", especially with smart people like the Mikkelsons. It's a complex problem though. Even after 30 years or so of carefully nothing 'how things go wrong' there still appears to be an infinite supply of new reasons how things go wrong.
- Danihan 9y agoThis is a good start though, http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4042194/Facebook-fact-checker-arbitrate-fake-news-accused-defrauding-website-pay-prostitutes-staff-includes-escort-porn-star-Vice-Vixen-domme.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4042194/Facebook-fac...
- jonny_eh 9y ago> still appears to be an infinite supply of new reasons how things go wrong Very true, but then there's divorce, that perennial cause of problems.
- folli 9y agoSearching HN for comments containing "divorce-related issue" yields just your comment and grandparent.
- cperciva 9y agoIs there some standard mechanism in silicon valley for avoiding divorce-related ownership problems? I imagine that VCs wouldn't be happy if a founder's ex-spouse (who had no direct participation in the startup) ended up with a significant stake in a company, for example. EDIT: To clarify, I'm not saying this is the scenario here (AFAIK there are no VCs involved either); as matthewmacleod put it, "this made me think about divorce generally" -- or more precisely, this is something I've wondered about for a while and this seemed like an opportune time to satisfy my curiosity.
- true_religion 9y agoThere isn't. In practice, courts will try to leave the business owner with 100% of the business and grant a larger share of other assets to the non-business owning partner. For example, you get the business and the condo, then your husband gets the house and the yacht.
- matt4077 9y ago> a founder's ex-spouse (who had no direct participation in the startup) Since both you and another comment so quickly zero in on the divorce aspect in this story, it's worth pointing out that Barbara Mikkelson was, in fact, a proper co-founder when snopes.com started, and worked alongside her husband for 20 years. This situation is no different than any other founder leaving the company and selling his stakes. HN will have to find another way to blame this on women. And, yes, there are mechanisms to prevent such problems. First among them would be the right-of-last-refusal: Before you sell, you have to offer the stock to the other co-founder(s), at the exact same terms you're offered. But that's not automatic, and has to be established early on.
- ClassyJacket 9y agoThe comment you are replying to literally did not mention women or sex or gender at all. You brought that into it. It seems like you're the one assuming it'd be a given that the woman didn't contribute. Nobody else said anything about them.
- chmars 9y agoIt's complicated: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170731/11351837890/fact-checking-snopes-own-claims-being-held-hostage-vendor-well-complicated.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170731/11351837890/fact-...
- fyrstenberg 9y agoWait... am I missing something, cause those two signatures (https://imgur.com/Zk3oRmf https://imgur.com/Zk3oRmf) are written by the same person. Just look at the first D and the writing in general, or was that suppose to be like that (TL;DR).
- uiri 9y agoThe biggest oops here is that Snopes/Bardav is an S Corp and neither Barbara's nor Proper Media's lawyers structured the deal well (or they're just totally unfamiliar with S Corps and/or tax law in general). S Corps are treated as partnerships for tax purposes. Proper Media, an LLC, wanted to buy out Barbara's stake. LLCs are not permitted to be shareholders in an S Corp so instead of selling her stake to Proper Media, Barbara split it up among the members (i.e. the owners) of Proper Media. If a competent lawyer had done this deal, they would have created a trust to re-consolidate Barbara's stake with the owners of Proper Media as beneficiaries and Schoentrup alone or Schoentrup and Richmond as the trustees. I know this because I am not a lawyer, I'm not even American, and it took me only a few minutes to figure out that: (a) trusts may own shares in an S Corp so long as the beneficiaries meet the requirements to be an S Corp shareholder (b) trusts are permitted to own shares in an S Corp for the purpose of consolidating a stake in the corporation (i.e. voting rights) I'm not really sure that anyone can own shares in an S Corp for the benefit of an LLC since that would create a trust whose beneficiary does not meet the requirements to be a shareholder in an S Corp. So Proper Media really has no standing to sue Bardav nor Mikkelson. This should be a minority shareholders vs majority shareholders lawsuit and rather easily resolved that way.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cable2600 9y agoIt sounds like it could be a future story for Silicon Valley on HBO. I'm sure this sort of thing happened before, both spouses contribute to the startup and then they divorce and fight over ownership/control. Most people have prenups to handle this sort of situation. Kind of strange how up until 2016 they just did urban legends, myths, chain letters, scams, etc. Then took on political fact checking in 2016 and by 2017 they divorce after Snoops is picked by Facebook as one of the offical fact checkers. I was given a link by one of my friends and posted it on my brothers timeline as it was about vaping and side effects, but a day or two later it was flagged as fake news and censored and I was not given a link for explination. I kind of hoped for a link to an article as to why it was fake news and how they debunked it.