3 ms·
As a member of both communities I can tell you that I perceive a genuine difference in attitudes. The crypto community says, "Don't write your own crypto." Th
by lisper 9y ago
As a member of both communities I can tell you that I perceive a genuine difference in attitudes. The crypto community says, "Don't write your own crypto." The aviation community says something more analogous to, "Absolutely, write your own crypto! Just don't use the results of your first effort for anything mission-critical until it has been checked out by someone who knows what they are doing. And oh by the way, here's a list of people you can contact who will be more than happy to help you." (In fact, the aviation community literally encourages people to build their own airplanes!)
- tptacek 9y agoSure! Now replace flying planes with building your own planes.
- lisper 9y agoHuh? Did you not read the last sentence? "In fact, the aviation community literally encourages people to build their own airplanes!" https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=build+your+own+airplane https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=build+y... http://www.kitplanes.com/homebuilders-portal/firsttimebuilders.html http://www.kitplanes.com/homebuilders-portal/firsttimebuilde...
- tptacek 9y agoI missed the last sentence. But I think this is also misleading. General aviation is obviously far more dangerous than commercial aviation, and home-built planes are, by a factor of 2-3x, more dangerous than the rest of general aviation. If you're telling me that there's a mainstream part of general aviation advocating that random people build planes to take strangers for rides in (or, to complete the analogy to crypto, to give to random strangers to themselves fly), I'm going to push back on that.
- lisper 9y agoNo, not random people. Just anyone who wants to.
- tptacek 9y agoYou're telling me that the general aviation community is, in the mainstream, of the mind that "anyone who wants to" build airplanes to sell to other people should be doing so? With no additional qualifiers?
- lisper 9y agoNot to sell. But for their own use, yes, absolutely. Anybody who wants to. It turns out not very many people want to, particularly when they find out how much work it is. But almost certainly the same is true of crypto.
- tptacek 9y agoNot only is that not true, it's demonstrably not true: when people write code, they actively want other people to use it. By way of example, the author of the library we're discussing here, "Monocypher", has declared it "ready for production" and has a web page selling its virtues versus libsodium and NaCl. People who write crypto code as a rule are not doing it for their own edification, which is why so many more people spend time writing libraries and encryption tools and so few people spend time writing the code to exploit crypto vulnerabilities.
- lisper 9y ago> Not only is that not true, What is the antecedent of "that"? I think you read something into what I wrote that I didn't intend.
- tptacek 9y agoYou said that it's almost certainly the case that people building their own crypto are doing it solely for their own purposes and that people won't even bother to complete their work. Obviously: no.
- taneq 9y agoIt doesn't encourage people to try and build commercial jet airliners in their back sheds. You can follow a tutorial and build a KitFox or whatever, which is the equivalent of coding, I dunno, a virtual Enigma machine or something. You can't follow a tutorial to learn how to design an Airbus A380.
- TylerE 9y agoYes, but home-built airplanes come with all kinds of limitations that are, to continue the analogy, more like "can't use commercially ever, and any use for non-commercial purposes requires a big disclaimer on every message sent. http://www.odtug.com/media/tvzzjjck.jpg http://www.odtug.com/media/tvzzjjck.jpg My use of commercial aviation in the GP was quite intentional, btw.
- lisper 9y agoYes, but 1) those are government regulations, not a community policy. As a community aviation is much more welcoming of newcomers than crypto, and in the case of crypto this attitude is entirely community-driven, since crypto is not regulated the way aviation is. And 2) homebrew is often a stepping stone towards professionalism in many fields. But the crypto community actively discourages homebrew with its "Don't build your own crypto, period, end of story" message. The message should be, "Sure, build your own, just don't rely on your first efforts for anything mission critical."
- avar 9y agoYou can't view community policy and government regulation as two unrelated things. The aviation community has a more welcoming attitude because of government regulation. They know that someone's backyard airplane isn't ever going to be used commercially without certification, and even if it were the entire world's aviation fleet isn't going to start using that model overnight, as might happen with some homebrew crypto and a popular new app. So the situation is entirely unanalogous.
- lisper 9y agoNo, that's not true. The aviation community's welcoming attitude goes way back before the government started to regulate it. I'd say it's because aviation began as a homebrew activity whereas cryptography was born in the military and academia.