4 ms·
Not at all. If I don't know how to sign up for med school, I can find out by searching for "How do I sign up for med school?" or even "How do I become a doctor
by lisper 9y ago
Not at all.
If I don't know how to sign up for med school, I can find out by searching for "How do I sign up for med school?" or even "How do I become a doctor?"
If I search for "How do I sign up for crypto school" the results are far less helpful.
- tptacek 9y agoI think you are arguing yourself into an absurd corner here, because I know for a fact that you can name off the top of your head five university crypto programs, and I'm sure you realize that for each of the ones you can name, there are 10 more that others can name. And: for what it's worth, I don't think going to school is the only way to learn this stuff. I just don't think putting end-users at risk, especially since they can't possibly be expected to tell the difference between Dan Boneh and some guy who assembled a broken ECDH out of random npm libraries.
- lisper 9y agoI re-read your GP comment, and I think I misread it the first time. Let me try this again. > If someone posted a message on HN about doing DIY appendectomies with Arduino-controlled robots and I pointed out that you need to go to med school to do surgeries, you would not in fact be harping on me for not having explained why. Actually, I might well harp on you for saying that, but that's a different topic. My complaint is not that you're pointing out that crypto is hard. It absolutely is. My complaint is much narrower than that. It is specifically a complaint about making statements of the form, "You just have to know what X is" when X is not something that is easy to look up. "Carry-propagation bug" is such an X. "Appendectomy" is not. And all I'm asking for is that you (not just you, but anyone who writes about things like this) add something like, "If you don't know what a carry propagation bug is, here's a pointer..." or "... it's when you're doing bignum math, you have a carry from one digit to the next, and you mess that up. These bugs are particularly nasty because they only manifest themselves very rarely and so are easy to miss in testing." Or something like that.
- Kalium 9y agohttps://www.google.com/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=+%22Carry-propagation+bug%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8 https://www.google.com/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=+%2... I submit that "carry-propagation bug" is easily looked up. You're asking for people to provide footnotes and extra information so that you can learn what they're talking about when they delve into jargon. I get it. It makes it so much easier to follow along. Then you can learn! Two points come to mind. First, the bit of jargon you've picked on is in fact easily investigated with tools you are already familiar with. Second, you're asking people writing for an audience of their choice to redefine it to include arbitrarily lay people. Which may not be maximally reasonable - there's a reason Watson and Crick's paper didn't include a primer on what X-rays are.
- kelnos 9y agoI clicked your link, and the results weren't useful. They were mostly links to reports about fixes for carry-propagation bugs in various pieces of software (which did not explain what a carry-propagation bug is). Ironically, the fourth result was a link to a different HN discussion about someone trying to figure out what a carry-propagation bug is, and failing to find any good resources through Google. (Although, to be fair, if you dig into that link a bit more, someone does attempt to explain.) So I wouldn't say it's impossible to find on one's own, but saying it's "easy" is a bit of a stretch.
- tptacek 9y agoIt's not especially easy! That's what worries me about laypeople writing crypto libraries. If you know to look, you stand a reasonable chance of learning enough about error oracle side channels to avoid writing something that recapitulates Bleichenbacher's RSA attack. But even if you remember someone telling you to look out for carry propagation bugs, I'm not sure you have a good chance of figuring how how to test for (or exploit) a carry propagation bug. And there are other bugs like this.
- lisper 9y ago> I submit that "carry-propagation bug" is easily looked up. Well, obviously anything is easily looked up. The problem is that in this case the results aren't very helpful if you don't already know what it is. I even said this in my OP: " if you go search for "carry propagation bug" you will find lots of examples of carry propagation bugs being found and fixed, but no explanation of what one is."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]