4 ms·
The important difference is that paper "hacking" scales as O(n) while computer hacking scales as O(1). If you hack election software, you can change thousands
by BurningFrog 9y ago
The important difference is that paper "hacking" scales as O(n) while computer hacking scales as O(1).
If you hack election software, you can change thousands or millions of votes as easily as one. The physical nature of paper means you have to work for each ballot.
- hfourm 9y agoYea but to his previous point, the auditability of a digital system could be much more sophisticated then paper
- BinaryIdiot 9y agoThat difference may not be accurate, though. It's assuming there is a way of networking between the machines and that code will be portable enough to affect N number of machines. I don't think either is necessarily true. Even for the paper side. Most paper ballets are counted by machine so they could easily be tampered with at the count or when they're printed having a similar scale.
- gandarojin 9y ago> Most paper ballets are counted by machine so they could easily be tampered with at the count […] Do you have a source for that statement? In Germany, ballots are counted by people making tally marks on paper.
- BinaryIdiot 9y agoHmm, not off hand. I'll see what I can find. It was my understanding from the hanging chad situation in Florida years ago that, at least in the states, most are initially counted by machine. Edit: Here you go. I couldn't find research or a study regarding it but this is probably good enough and was always my experience when I voted by paper: https://www.wired.com/2016/11/vote-counts-ballot-get-counted/ https://www.wired.com/2016/11/vote-counts-ballot-get-counted...
- jpfed 9y ago>Most paper ballets are counted by machine And recount-able by hand in case there is doubt.
- jeltz 9y agoWe count them twice by hand here in Sweden and we get the preliminary result just a few hours after the polls close, so I do not see why one has to use a machine.
- BurningFrog 9y ago> I do not see why one has to use a machine. One reason is that Americans vote a lot more than Swedes. Here in California I have probably ~100 elections to vote in for each I had in Sweden.
- nialv7 9y ago> while computer hacking scales as O(1). Not necessarily. I'm not cryptography expert, but I suspect some kind of proof-of-work system can be used for ballots.
- drhodes 9y agoPerhaps, but they have bulk insertion. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3796116/Putin-s-party-sweeps-victory-Russian-elections-amid-evidence-vote-rigging-CCTV-catching-one-woman-stuffing-multiple-vote-slips-ballot-box.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3796116/Putin-s-part...
- afarrell 9y agoAnd as you add more manpower to your attempt to defraud a paper-ballot election, you increase the number of co-conspirators. As you add co-conspirators, the likelihood of being undetected drops dramatically.
- smileysteve 9y ago> paper "hacking" scales as O(n) It's quite common to drop handfuls of paper. And really, the grouping comes down to transportation issues as well; when you move ballots in boxes and trucks, 0(n) becomes less accurate. There were numerous issues with the security, packing, and handfuls of paper in 2000.