3 ms·
> Well, the problem is that this means exchanges need to actually implement support for every chain No, read my comment again, carefully. If they are providin
by colordrops 9y ago
> Well, the problem is that this means exchanges need to actually implement support for every chain
No, read my comment again, carefully. If they are providing IOUs for BTC, that means there is no private key associated with the debt. If say for instance they owe a user 10 BTC, they could give them any 10 BTC. if a new chain pops up, it doesn't matter, because the contract is explicitly an IOU for 10 BTC, not BCH or BCC.
the problem arises when the exchange implies they are holding "your coins" for you like a safe deposit box, which means there's a private key associated with the coins, and thus that key would work with any chain splits, including BCH/BCC.
just curious, do you understand how blockchains work? i.e. private keys and the transaction protocol? if you weren't familiar with it, then that would explain why you are having a hard time understanding my comment.
- bdonlan 9y agoI think I misread your comment - I had interpreted it as suggesting that exchanges should be required to issue IOUs for new forked assets, which has serious practical issues. Of course, saying that coinbase balances are IOUs for bitcoins is basically what happened here, and apparently people aren't happy about it. While you could change the marketing material, I don't think it would do much to change the outrage in this case; I very much doubt people will pay attention to such a nuance when they apparently couldn't be bothered to temporarily withdraw their coins.
- colordrops 9y ago> I very much doubt people will pay attention to such a nuance when they apparently couldn't be bothered to temporarily withdraw their coins. That's a very good point. It would avoid any legal ambiguity and save face with the more technical minded though.