4 ms·
To sit in your pile of cash and profit from margins, you need to make money and have positive margins. You make it sound as if they could have chosen that path.
by kgwgk 9y ago
To sit in your pile of cash and profit from margins, you need to make money and have positive margins. You make it sound as if they could have chosen that path...
- bryanlarsen 9y agoThe gross margin on the Model S is over 25%.
- dkrich 9y agoFor a luxury car, that's not really good. As you move down-market, margins only get lower, so you have to rely on volume to make significant amounts of money. If people don't buy Model 3's by the hundreds of thousands every quarter, they are going to have problems squeezing profits from this car.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoLegacy luxury margins. BMW: 8% Mercedes: 11% Audi: 7%
- kgwgk 9y agoGross margins are significantly higher than that (maybe below Tesla's 25%, but they sell many cars cheaper than the model S).
- dkrich 9y agoSo a company that has widening losses claims a 25% margin on its cars. Sounds like some interesting accounting is at work. Ask Bob Lutz whether margins are greater on a Chevy Camaro or a Cadillac ATS (exact same platform, one sells for about $10k more than the other).
- toomuchtodo 9y agoGM: 8.4% Sad!
- dkrich 9y agoSeems like you're missing the point. If a set of parts costs you X, and you can sell it as one product for 2X and as a different product for 3X, which one yields better profits?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoWe're not talking past each other. A Cadillac and a Chevy are much closer to parity than a Model 3 and a Model S/X (considering both parts and manufacturing techniques). I don't know what the Model 3 margins are yet, but I'm confident they're going to be above 15%.
- kgwgk 9y agoGross margin doesn't give you the full picture. SG&A (20% of sales) eats most of that margin and R&D is 12% of sales. I'm not sure how profitable Tesla could be cutting this additional costs without going too far (to avoid compromising the viability of the company).
- erikpukinskis 9y agoIf they were just going to churn out Model S and X, they wouldn't need to do much R&D. They could have a handful of people sit around and draw new headlight designs like the other car companies.