6 ms·
> muscle in and eat Tesla's lunch This would largely depend on whether Tesla would strive to become a mainstream car maker or would choose to retain its focus
by huhtenberg 16y ago
> muscle in and eat Tesla's lunch
This would largely depend on whether Tesla would strive to become a mainstream car maker or would choose to retain its focus on building luxury/exotic cars. Think Aston Martin kind of company.
Though they have already announced an average-priced sedan version that was scheduled for mass production in 2012, so I guess they are going after the behemoths.
- keltex 16y agoYou mean the Aston Martin that was part of Ford until 2007? Ford still own a portion of and to which they contribute the parts and engineering know how.
- sbov 16y agoLast I heard the model S was going to start at 49k. That definitely is in the luxury car price range, and not competition with toyota/nissan/etc.
- hugh3 16y agoLuxury and exotic cars is a terrible business to be in. Small-volume supercar manufacturers pop in and out of existence every few years, leaving behind tiny production runs of awesome-looking machines and no spare parts. The only luxury/exotic car manufacturers which have survived are the ones which managed to pick up enough of a history to be bought out by a much larger mass-market brand as a halo. afaik they mostly operate at a loss. Bentley, Lamborghini and Bugatti belong to VW. Ferrari is Fiat. Lotus is Proton, and Rolls-Royce gets passed around like a cheap hooker. Only Aston Martin is currently owned by someone other than another car company, but that may not last.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- shin_lao 16y agoWhat about Porsche, BMW and Mercedes? Any business is good to be in - provided you're good enough. There's no such thing as easy money.
- eru 16y agoPorsche was recently pulled into VW, though Porsche nearly succeeded in buying VW earlier. Mercedes and BMW (but especially Mercedes) are more upper middle class than truly luxury.
- brc 16y agoPorsche was the most profitable car company in the world prior to the VW takeover debacle. Ironically, though, it was mostly from selling SUVs instead of sports cars. Which just shows that selling overpriced oversized ego vehicles is the best way to make money in the car business.
- hugh3 16y agoLow-end luxury seems to be very profitable, as those three companies demonstrate. They're comfortably away from the cost-cutting at the bottom of the market, but still accessible to a large number of customers. It was the really high-end cars ($100K+) I was talking about as apparently being unprofitable.
- shin_lao 16y agoMercedes and BMW manufacture and sell cars in the price range you are talking about.
- huhtenberg 16y ago> afaik they mostly operate at a loss As much as I trust your "afaik", I find it very hard to believe. For example, the "cheap hooker" raked £593m of profit in 2008 according to http://www.rolls-royce.com/investors/news/2009/300709_2009_half_year_results.jsp http://www.rolls-royce.com/investors/news/2009/300709_2009_h...
- hugh3 16y agoThat's Rolls-Royce plc, the publicly-listed company that mostly makes aircraft engines, not Rolls-Royce Motor Cars, the completely unrelated subsidiary of BMW that makes... well, motor cars. The history of the two is awfully complicated, but I gather that they've been separate entities since 1973.