2 ms·
Interesting analogy! Compare to the one I gave [1]. As you've described it here, I would agree that they don't have an obligation to mail the DVDs out. However
by SilasX 9y ago
Interesting analogy! Compare to the one I gave [1]. As you've described it here, I would agree that they don't have an obligation to mail the DVDs out. However, if:
A) The marina owner had entered into a fiduciary relationship with you regarding the possession of your boat to your benefit, and
B) The DVDs were sent to the fiduciary with instructions to be given to the boat owners, and
C) A reasonable person would believe that the boat owner would regard the DVD to have enough value to care about,
Then the marina owner would be obligated to at least ensure that the boat owners can access their DVD, if they wish to, for some reasonable period (say, 60 days). For example, by leaving it with the boat or dropping it in the boat owners' locker at the harbor office, or informing them of their property with the next scheduled communication (in a way that leaves them 60 days etc).
[1] I know "comparing a comparison", but here ya go: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14913261 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14913261