3 ms·
This dissonance seems to come from the fact that citing has two purposes 1. Assigning credit to where you heard about something. 2. Giving a claim (the
by im3w1l 9y ago
This dissonance seems to come from the fact that citing has two purposes
1. Assigning credit to where you heard about something.
2. Giving a claim (the best possible, and sufficiently strong) support.
From the credit perspective you should cite wherever you heard something, even if it was alleyway graffiti. From the support perspective, you should take the idea you read on the wall look it up to see if someone credible has said the same thing, and then cite them, and if not maybe not mention it all.
- sddfd 9y agoWhen publishing a paper/book with a certain publisher there is an interaction between the prestige of the publisher and the prestige of the author: An author publishing with prestigious publishers is considered prestigous; a publisher that publishes prestigous authors is considered prestigous. Since publishers are commercial entities, their prestige is an asset they want to protect. So there are other incentives at play when it comes why citing ArXiv is currently not en vogue. I always find it refreshing to see how pre-print driven reserach communities like physics operate in comparison.
- TylerH 9y agoAKA why the academic journal industry is bullshit.
- wizardforhire 9y agoThis is the general opion I've encountered. "If you haven't climbed the ivory tower you don't get to speak in the ivory tower... Also, we in the ivory tower don't listen to those not in the ivory tower. Less we ourselves are cast down from our perched position."
- bo1024 9y agoYes, I think this is a very important insight.
- petters 9y agoI would add a third purpose: 3. Show what is novel in your work. Novelty is important in many academic situations.