10 ms·
The next wave of programming languages
- rdtsc 16y agoInteresting languages not on the list: * io : http://www.iolanguage.com http://www.iolanguage.com Clean, minimalistic, prototype based OO. * Reia : http://wiki.reia-lang.org http://wiki.reia-lang.org Ruby-like syntax on Erlang's VM * Curry : http://www-ps.informatik.uni-kiel.de/currywiki http://www-ps.informatik.uni-kiel.de/currywiki Functional logic language : Prolog+Haskell. * Oz/Mozart : http://www.mozart-oz.org http://www.mozart-oz.org Multi-multi paradigm language, includes constraint based programming. Some of them are not necessarily up-and-coming but rather out-and-going. Oz is interesting, but it seems to be dying. Some like Reia are making slow progress. Curry is more of an academic language. io is probably the most up-and-coming so to speak.
- vdoma 16y agoFalcon (http://www.falconpl.org/ http://www.falconpl.org/) seems interesting too.
- Scriptor 16y agoI'm curious, what interesting features does it have?
- dublinclontarf 16y agoReia is currently my wet dream language, similar to Ruby, and does concurrency(buit on top of BEAM for Christs sakes). And then you read the small print and learn that it's not available as a download. :< Can't wait until it's ready though.
- Scriptor 16y agoThe repo is available at http://github.com/tarcieri/reia http://github.com/tarcieri/reia Is it just too unusable right now?
- dublinclontarf 16y agoActually I havn't tried, I'm busy with work that does not in any way require Reia so I don't have time. There's plenty of things I'd love to do with it when I've got time though.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoGoogle Go looks interesting too. http://code.google.com/p/go/ http://code.google.com/p/go/ "Go is an expressive, concurrent, garbage-collected systems programming language." Already in production on some internal projects.
- torial 16y agoCobra (http://cobra-language.com/ http://cobra-language.com/), a python derivative that also an up and coming language. Love the syntax refinements, the built in unit-testing, contracts, etc... all around a great language.
- gtani 16y agohttp://emerginglangs.com/speakers/ http://emerginglangs.com/speakers/ Wish i could go.
- j_baker 16y agoProgramming language authors really need to learn how to make a website. Look at Ruby's: http://www.ruby-lang.org/en/ http://www.ruby-lang.org/en/ No long explanations about what it means for Ruby to be a dynamic, object-oriented language. I don't have to read its author's paper or book to get it. Just a short code snippet to show me what it looks like and several links so I can learn more.
- Calamitous 16y agoVery much so. I don't get the (apparent) belief that code samples must be hidden at all costs. If I'm looking at a language, I want to see what it looks like...
- Scriptor 16y agoOnly a small number of the language websites listed on the emerging langs camp site have any code on them, and that includes those with maybe just a couple of lines for an edge case scenario. I guess a bunch of those languages are highly academic and the meat is in the implementation as opposed to the syntax. But language developers need to start putting some effort into the non-code parts of their projects. I'm not going to get inspired to pick up a new language by bullet points. At the same time, I'm working on my own language project so I know it can be challenging to use just the right code to give the best first impression.
- AndrejM 16y agoAlthough true, many of those authors are too busy with improving/fixing their compilers. E.g. the D language doesn't have a very modern looking website atm., but someone has took the task to update it recently. It's not up yet since the community is trying it out.
- Scriptor 16y agoThe D language actually is an example of a good site, in that there's a large chunk of code on the front page.
- warfangle 16y agoNewspeak looks really fascinating. Relavent paper: http://bracha.org/newspeak.pdf http://bracha.org/newspeak.pdf
- zephyrfalcon 16y agoYeah, but that picture on the website doesn't really make me want to try it, benefits of the language nothwithstanding... :-( (http://bracha.org/Site/Newspeak.html http://bracha.org/Site/Newspeak.html)
- warfangle 16y agoThat's why I linked to the whitepaper, instead of the author's site's entry on the language. Other responses have linked to the project's main page. Wondering why I got downvoted? Should I have vacuumed it into scribd?
- zephyrfalcon 16y agoDownvote me all you want, but if I go to a web page and the first thing I see is dead chicken plastered onto a wall, I close that page.
- zupatol 16y agoYou just made me look at that page. I was about to email it to a friend when I realized that newspeak's real home page doesn't have any dead chicken pictures: http://newspeaklanguage.org/ http://newspeaklanguage.org/
- technomancy 16y agoBetter, (ok, so _much_ better) but it's still a barely-modified default wordpress template.
- acangiano 16y agoDon't downvote him. He is absolutely right. The picture on that page is a major WTF and it doesn't offer a great first impression to the visitor interested in the language.
- euroclydon 16y agoI found Kodu very interesting. It's a graphical programming language by Microsoft Labs, that allows kids to create games. It runs on the XBox and uses only the XBox controller. The XBox part turned me off right away, because that's the last thing I need in my house while we're homeschooling our children, however, I found a free academic version that runs on the PC: http://fuse.microsoft.com/projects-kodu.html http://fuse.microsoft.com/projects-kodu.html
- vollmond 16y agoOut of curiosity, why would having an XBox in your home be a problem? I was homeschooled (though only in high school) with several consoles in our house, and it doesn't seem to have been a problem. I wasn't allowed to goof off school time on video games any more than I could have played my Game Boy in a public school classroom. edit: I suppose a more clear question would be: What is it specific to homeschooling that you don't like about the XBox? Or am I reading too much into your comment?
- euroclydon 16y agoI have a suspicion that "screen time" whether it be TV, videos or games, has a detrimental affect on: attention span, tranquility and susceptibility to advertisements and psychological mass-manipulation in general.
- timwiseman 16y agoI suspect it matters very much what is on that screen. Music videos and action movies are practically designed for people with ADHD. Many video games are the same way. On the other hand, there are some high quality documentaries and prerecorded college lecturers will not hav ethe issues you describe and as an avid (though very bad) GO player I personally feel that there is very little difference between playing on a screen and playing in front of a board.
- euroclydon 16y ago
- acangiano 16y agoIn that list, Clojure is the language that excites me the most. It's a modern, pragmatic Lisp ready for the multiprocessor world. You can do a lot worse than trying it out if you haven't already.
- colonelxc 16y agoI was playing with Clojure this last weekend, and so far have enjoyed it. I ran through a dozen or so project euler problems, but am now looking for something that takes longer than 10 lines of code to complete. HN, what other projects do you do to familiarize yourself with a new language?
- joubert 16y agoRead some of the Clojure code, both in main and in contrib.
- DavidMcLaughlin 16y agoI found going through "Introduction to Algorithms" and porting the algorithms in the book to <new language> a great way to get used to a new language.
- silentbicycle 16y agoOkasaki's _Purely Functional Data Structures_ can be a good choice, too - depends on the language.
- WilliamLP 16y agoWrite a game. ASCII Tetris or Pac Man or Space Invaders would be fine. Whether that is a simple afternoon activity or a somewhat epic undertaking might tell you something about the language.
- ShardPhoenix 16y agoI've been writing a couple of small games with Clojure + Swing as a way of learning Clojure, and it's been very smooth so far. I haven't even touched concurrency or macros yet but the basic language feels even more consistent and logical than Ruby.
- RyanMcGreal 16y agoI'm genuinely curious: what advantage accrues to a programming language designed for concurrency that you can't get with a good concurrency library for an existing language?
- technomancy 16y agoImmutable data structures are several times more useful if they're built-in to the language because all libraries assume you're using them. There's no technical reason they couldn't be added on with a 3rd-party library, but it's really a cultural thing.
- lukev 16y agoSyntactic support, immutability semantics, and compile-time limitations on side-effects. Of course, it's POSSIBLE to do everything with a library + discipline. For example, I can import the Clojure jar and use Clojure's data structures and STM in a Java program. But it is _very_ verbose, and you have to know that certain variables are immutable, or that certain operations are illegal in certain places, etc, rather than having that information encoded into the language.
- silverlake 16y agoSafety. You can do anything in C, but the language/compiler can't help you at all. So languages with support for a feature can help you perform that task more easily and catch some errors for you. That applies to GC, concurrency, distribution, failure handling, and on and on.
- billmcneale 16y agoNot much, really, the benefits of intrinsic support for concurrency in languages are very overhyped. Java is a great illustration: it has syntactically close to no support for concurrency (synchronized, pretty much) but it has been able to keep up with today's concurrency challenges by the simple virtue of its libraries (java.util.concurrent is very, very powerful) and ingenuity of its developers. The amount of concurrent Java that powers major web sites and other places that we don't even know of is simply staggering.
- WalterBright 16y agoI'll be there to talk about the D programming language.
- tomjen3 16y agoInteresting, I kinda liked D, but I heard about it years ago and assumed it had died in the meantime. Good to hear it hasn't. Edit: I seem to be unable to find the actual license of the digital mars compiler - does anybody know where it is?
- joubert 16y agoI wonder why to Go guys aren't there.
- Scriptor 16y agoThey are: http://emerginglangs.com/speakers/ http://emerginglangs.com/speakers/ First one in the list :)
- stcredzero 16y agoThe dynamic/compiled distinction needs to go away. Combine a simple syntax with very rapid compilation with LLVM, Type Inference, and very advanced emulator-based debugging, and there would be no need to have anything like Smalltalk/Perl/Python/Ruby any more. Instead of dynamic Duck Typing, you'd have Go's version, with auto-magic help from type inference. The emulator-based debugger could subsume many of the capabilities granted by a VM and enable the freewheeling runtime monkey-patching that can be leveraged for the same jaw-dropping ingenious debugging available in many current dynamic langs. This last component would be the hardest to implement. (Cue the Haskell guys so they can point out how they're most of the way there already.)
- joubert 16y agoThe dynamic/compiled distinction needs to go away dynamic / compiled are orthogonal. CL is dynamic and gets compiled as you enter in the REPL.
- stcredzero 16y agoPretty much the same with Smalltalk, but people still make this distinction in their minds. That's part of my point. The distinction no longer even has so much basis in the actual organization of code and runtimes!
- pbiggar 16y agoDynamic/compiled should be orthogonal, but rarely have been in practice. Witness PHP, Perl, Ruby, Lua, Python.
- stcredzero 16y agoIt's time for it to be so in practice. The technology is way ahead of our cultural expectations.
- shadowfox 16y agoCan you expand on this a bit?
- motters 16y agoConcurrency should really be the number one issue for any new programming language. To my knowledge, none of the popular languages out there today are really able to handle concurrency in a seamless way which doesn't generate headaches for the developer. Distributing computation over threads and machines needs to be easier.
- jashkenas 16y agoThe full list of speakers and languages: Rob Pike and Robert Griesemer – Go Steve Dekorte – Io Charles Nutter – Duby Matt MacLaurin – Kodu Gilad Bracha – Newspeak Jeremy Ashkenas – CoffeeScript Adam Chlipala – Ur Francisco Tolmasky – Objective-J Jonathan Shapiro – BitC Luke Hoban – F# Tav – PyPy Rich Hickey – Clojure Christopher Bertels – Fancy Jonathan Edwards – Coherence/Subtext Alex Eagle – Noop Slava Pestov – Factor Erik Meijer – C# Mark S Miller – E, Caja Brian Rice – Slate Walter Bright – D Wolfgang De Meuter and Tom Van Cutsem – AmbientTalk Phil Mercurio – Thyrd Melvin Smith – Cola Carson Gross – Gosu Alexander Fritze – Stratified JavaScript Alan Eliasen – Frink Dan Bornstein – Dalvik Steve Folta – Trylon Ola Bini – Ioke Amos Wenger - ooc
- WalterBright 16y agoI think I'll stop reading HN and go do something useful!
- mkramlich 16y agoClojure and D are the two languages of the newer wave that I'm most likely to end up using. They each have a combination of elegance and practicality which are pretty rare among new languages I think.