5 ms·
Didn't they say not a few months ago that "the reason Firefox has fallen behind is that we focused on stuff that wasn't browser-related like MozillaOS etc."? L
by dmitriid 9y ago
Didn't they say not a few months ago that "the reason Firefox has fallen behind is that we focused on stuff that wasn't browser-related like MozillaOS etc."?
Learning from own mistakes anyone?
- newscracker 9y agoQuoting from the article: "These are obviously experimental tools and there’s no guarantee they will ever make it into a release version of Firefox. Indeed, the idea behind Test Pilot is to allow the Firefox team to test new concepts." The efforts on making Firefox faster and more responsive have been going on for a few years (e10s/electrolysis being one of them) and are appearing in the releases as fast as the team can develop, test and deliver them. I personally believe Mozilla has a highly capable core team on this, and to insinuate otherwise, to me, seems like accepting commercial interests of other browser makers as higher than FLOSS interests. I don't disagree on quality of the product being a huge aspect in value judgments, but it cannot and should not be the only one.
- dmitriid 9y agoIt doesn't matter if they are experimental or not. It doesn't matter if they will make it into the release or not. There is one very certain thing: these experiments divert resources and people. "Fast and more responsive" is just one aspect. Because "we're getting faster" and "these are just experiments" lead to a situation when "Browse against the machine" [1] uses FF for work and Chrome for play, and pretends it's ok. [1] https://medium.com/the-official-unofficial-firefox-blog/browse-against-the-machine-e793c0fee917 https://medium.com/the-official-unofficial-firefox-blog/brow...
- j_s 9y agoMore people won't necessarily help solve any problems though. (Insert obligatory Mythical Man Month mumble mumble, hand-waving, etc. here.) Perhaps additional resources could help. In general I agree that Mozilla has lost its way with its current head count; successfully funding a company with advertising revenue tends to do that.
- addicted 9y agoThis is how they are adding features to the browser. This is a smart way of doing it. Make it experimental, gauge the feedback, and integrate it if the feedback makes it seem useful. As an example, they tried vertical tabs, and it appears it didn't work as well as they needed it to be so it has been left out. On the flip side, the empty tab page was also an experiment, and that worked well and made it to the default browser. These experiments are work on the browser. But instead of adding them as features, introducing them as experiments and then adding the polished, stable, feedback adjusted version as a true feature that can be marketed effectively.
- dingo_bat 9y agoVertical tabs used to work so well on Firefox that I held on for just that, even when everybody had already left for Chrome. Then they killed it. Now you're saying they dropped it because they couldn't get it to work again. Kind of sad.
- coldtea 9y ago>I personally believe Mozilla has a highly capable core team on this, and to insinuate otherwise, to me, seems like accepting commercial interests of other browser makers as higher than FLOSS interests. There's only one interest in the browser wars: prevail or perish. If Firefox cannot secure a large enough market share, it will be insignificant, lose funding, and die off.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoExactly. I've been waiting for working and full printing support something like https://www.smashingmagazine.com/2015/01/designing-for-print-with-css/ https://www.smashingmagazine.com/2015/01/designing-for-print... for years now. Printing articles from the browser is the same pain as 10 years ago. But yes this is not as fancy as voice search or file sharing (or their single sign on, identity and all the other failed stuff). Mozilla has been a vehicle for people who play out their tech and political dreams and then move on. And FF is crumbling all the way. But this misery is soon over, we're in the end game of Firefox. https://www.w3counter.com/globalstats.php https://www.w3counter.com/globalstats.php (Written from FF - a browser I've used since Mosaic)
- Tactic 9y agoThe linked page seems to indicate Chrome is leading because people are browsing on their Android phones. So it would seem if Mozilla should concentrate on anything it would be improving the mobile experience.
- yAnonymous 9y agoThat is actually the one area where Firefox is already better for me, because of extension support. Having an ad blocker on mobile devices is priceless.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoI use FF only because of extensions right now.
- toweringgoat 9y agoSadly Mozilla seem to be trying to kill off development of Firefox on Android...
- yAnonymous 9y agoSeriously. They're behind in speed, security, quality of the developer tools etc. and introduce new useless toy features and one re-design after the other. I appreciate a lot of stuff Mozilla do outside the browser for the open internet, but the development of Firefox is pretty bad and it looks like the project leaders are incompetent. Firefox is a sad example of how a successful software can be overtaken by a new competitor within only a few years due to a lack of focus.
- syrrim 9y ago>due to a lack of focus. And due to their competitors ability to advertise on the majority of people's home page. For most people, chrome wasn't a firefox alternative, it was an internet explorer alternative.
- yAnonymous 9y agoI'd like to know how much of an impact that had, but nonetheless Chrome is technically in many areas the best browser today and Mozilla, being the clear market leader at one point, could have done a lot more to prevent that. Firefox was in need of technical improvements for some time, but they only started acting when Chrome already had a noticeable market share and that's not how you stay at the top.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoI would buy that if FF would be technically the best or most secure browser. But for a very long it hasn't been.
- alex_duf 9y agoFor every 100 experiment maybe one will be fruitful. No one is criticising Mozilla for coming up with Rust, yet if they didn't take the time to experiment Rust wouldn't be around. So yeah, good on them, I'm happy for them to try voice recognition and other endeavours, who knows what they might discover?
- dmitriid 9y ago