3 ms·
Your QA teams are looking up every entry in your package.json files, your Maven poms, your Gemfiles, your requirements.txt files? They're making sure that somet
by eropple 9y ago
Your QA teams are looking up every entry in your package.json files, your Maven poms, your Gemfiles, your requirements.txt files? They're making sure that something that builds completely cleanly and shows no external errors doesn't have a typo in it?
Of course they're not.
- infinity0 9y agoThat's a pretty big straw man you wrote there, to imply that getting rid of not-all errors is no better than not getting rid of any errors at all. In fact, GNU/Linux distros with even minimal QA will disallow network access during builds. Also we do in fact manually audit quite a lot of stuff to make sure this sort of bullshit doesn't get uploaded to the archives.
- tedunangst 9y agoMy QA team, upon a request to add a package called "crossenv" to the npm repo, would say "this is suspiciously similar to the existing cross-env package. Request denied." Alas, npm has no such team.
- Chyzwar 9y agonpm host half a million packages. It is impossible to manually QA anything. People also rename and re-publish unmaintained packages pretty often. The problem is JS that lack sensible standard library. Node is at fault.
- tedunangst 9y agoA problem that exists because there was no QA to start... Instead we get "awesome" lists of "curated" packages on github, which does nothing to solve the problem.
- Jach 9y agoHalf a million, is that all? Levels of QA exist. As pointed out by https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14905660 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14905660 it would take very little to require something like a bug report that's then had various levels signed off on.