5 ms·
I see a lot of anti-expert pro-speech comments. That’s great and all at the theoretical government law side of things, but YouTube is a private organization tha
by azinman2 9y ago
I see a lot of anti-expert pro-speech comments. That’s great and all at the theoretical government law side of things, but YouTube is a private organization that _is_ being used as a platform by organizations like ISIS to radicalize random individuals who then go out and kill innocent people. Should Google allow these videos to be on equal footing with funny cat videos?
- bmmayer1 9y agoWhat do you mean by 'equal footing.' The footing that videos like these stand on is only as strong as the support that they have from viewers. We live in a marketplace of ideas. People who support ISIS are not going to stop because Google takes the videos down, but it does start a dangerous precedent to censor any content Google doesn't like.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoRadicalization is real. It's why terrorism works. If a private service wants to restrict videos of torture killings and beheadings followed by propaganda, why not? Those shouldn't be tolerated any more than videos that show torture of animals or abuse of children. Seems like a reasonable standard and not necessarilya slippery slope?
- reitanqild 9y agoRadicalization is real. It's why terrorism works. If a private service wants to restrict videos of torture killings and beheadings followed by propaganda, why not? If this was all that was censored then we'd likely be more agreeable. Unfortunately there is cases like this which seems to be from today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14903834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14903834
- falcolas 9y agoSo, where would something like the Saddam Hussain capture/execution videos fall? Or the movies depicting the same? How about the movie Hannibal? Does it being fictional make the over-the-top torture and violence OK?
- azinman2 9y agoSaddam Hussain falls under the category of 'news' -- he was an official leader of an entire country so what happens to him is relevant in history and should be documented. Fiction is an entirely separate category.. we can watch Game of Thrones which is massively violent and understand that it's different from reality and propaganda. If we have no limits, then should YouTube also allow pro-child rape videos showing how awesome a 3-year old gang bang is with a crowd of guys cheering that on? At some point you have to draw the line. I admit this is a very hard and nuanced thing to do, I generally support free speech, but I think that ISIS deserves a platform on YouTube. I'm not sure I'd support outlawing it from the government level, but that doesn't mean we can't do things to curb its influence online.
- azinman2 9y ago*i _dont_ that ISIS deserves a platform on YouTube
- tribby 9y ago> but YouTube is a private organization that _is_ being used as a platform by organizations like ISIS to radicalize random individuals who then go out and kill innocent people by that logic they shouldn't allow US military recruitment videos either
- CryptoFascist 9y agoOne of these things is not like the other.
- CaptSpify 9y agowhats the difference? that one of them is the "good" guys?
- reitanqild 9y agoYep. In this case one is really in another league than the other. We are not talking about the Russian. We are not talking about the Arabs. We are talking about the Anders Bering Breiviks, the Timothy McVeighs, the real nazis of 2017 and of course ISIS.
- tribby 9y agomcveigh was a decorated product of the US military, I'm not quite sure he's the example you're looking for
- reitanqild 9y agoDoesn't change the fact that he acted alone and not because the US military told him to. Or am I missing the really juicy part here?
- tribby 9y agoI'm not disputing that the US didn't ask him to commit an act of terror against itself. but it did ask him to do terrible things. in the context of the post we are replying to ("YouTube is a private organization that _is_ being used as a platform by organizations like ISIS to radicalize random individuals who then go out and kill innocent people"), I think it's a bit reductionist to put too much value in military vs. paramilitary or "the military told him to do X." all I mean is that in the quoted post, "ISIS" can be replaced with a number of military and paramilitary forces throughout the world and the statement will still ring true in different populations. youtube shouldn't target specific organizations that they think are bad. they should apply more general rules that also apply to organizations that they think are good. and no, mcveigh did not act alone. he conspired with terry nichols and michael fortier, who also served and met in the military. according to his biography, mcveigh took joy in being ordered to slaughter surrendered prisoners. did the military radicalize him? further: did it train him in the skills he needed to successfully carry out such an atrocious act? was he provided adequate care when he returned home from iraq and kuwait, broken? to what extent is the military responsible? should youtube ban anti-US videos in general? does an organization need to be on a particular US government-sanctioned list to be considered a terrorist organization by youtube? the list of questions goes on. overall, what I'm trying to express is that it is bad for youtube to make decisions based on politics. if they want to make decisions on morals, that's fine, but apply it to everyone, not just ISIS. either that, or allow them all.
- dilap 9y agoTo me YouTube being a private organization is beside the point; I would like the dominant mediums of communication of our era to be open and free, not restricted and censored. It makes very little practical difference if the censorship comes from a large company or a government if at the end of the day you can't say what you want. And yes: I do believe in the basic free speech bargain. I do think it's better to have ISIS recruitment videos (and anti-ISIS videos, and everything else) up freely than to have some organization sitting in judgement of what's "acceptable" and not. Of course it's a trade-off. There is a cost to social harmony from free speech (& democracy!). China seems to be doing pretty well with a very different approach; they value social harmony highly. But I was raised like a good little patriotic American boy, so I value free speech pretty damn highly, and I find this policy misguide and scary. Also, let's not kid ourselves -- ISIS is just an excuse. I guaran-fucking-tee this policy will be used to stifle all kinds of objectionable, non-politcally-correct videos.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoDo you believe that videos of 3-year olds executing prisoners is really worth broadcasting? Old men getting their head stabbed with a bayonet until they die? Pilots burned alive? I'm all for free speech, but why should Google distribute that for free so we can have more lone wolf terrorist attacks?
- snerbles 9y agoSuch videos are already against Google's terms of service. This new policy and the tech that backs it are little more than a political cudgel.
- dilap 9y agoIf those things are happening in the world, then I do think it's valuable to be able to see them. Recent example: Trump decided to end the CIA program arming rebel groups in Syria after watching a video of one such group behead a young boy.
- euyyn 9y ago
- snerbles 9y agoIt's effectively a privately-owned public space, due to the network effects. Simply presenting the ISIS vs cat videos dichotomy is intellectually dishonest - it ignores the subtler effects of a politically motivated private entity becoming an arbiter of speech. For instance, Jordan Peterson's Google account was suspended today for "violations of terms of service", with no other reason given and no official channel for recourse. It was only reinstated after news of the ban began gaining traction on twitter and other outlets. What will happen to smaller entities caught in the net, with less social clout to defend themselves? https://twitter.com/jordanbpeterson/status/892449098950991872 https://twitter.com/jordanbpeterson/status/89244909895099187...
- reitanqild 9y agoThats pretty scary. This is almost drumhead court martial for peoples online personas. :-/
- Camillo 9y agoThe mention of ISIS is a smokescreen. Even though terrorism was used as an early justification of it, in practice the "hate speech" label is almost always used for far less violent ideas and people. In fact, it is more likely to be used against liberal Muslims than against Islamic terrorists! (See [0]) In fact, from an anti-terrorism perspective, it may be more effective to leave ISIS's videos up (and keep tabs on their most frequent watchers, if anything). It can even have direct benefits in terms of intelligence gathering (e.g. the locations shown can be identified). [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14903754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14903754
- matthewmacleod 9y agoIn fact, it is more likely to be used against liberal Muslims than against Islamic terrorists! (See [0]) That is not a reference that supports your claim.