4 ms·
That's actually one way in which I think Derrida did somewhat of a disservice to himself. Someone once asked him to explain what deconstruction was, and he answ
by _delirium 16y ago
That's actually one way in which I think Derrida did somewhat of a disservice to himself. Someone once asked him to explain what deconstruction was, and he answered something like: all of my books are an attempt to answer that formidable question. Okay, I can even buy the point that there may be some inherent complexity not reducible to a one-paragraph answer, but saying "sorry, the answer is all my books, taken together" is not too useful of an answer. Surely there is an admittedly oversimplified answer that can give people some vague idea of the general gist of it? I mean, when people do pop-sci writups of astrophysics, they aren't exactly explaining astrophysics, but a simplified version of it (sometimes very simplified), which hopes only to give people an idea of the kind of thing that happens, not to actually teach them how to do it in all its complexity.
I think Derrida would've been much better off, in terms of intellectual legacy, if he had a student who took him somewhat less seriously on that point, perhaps even against his wishes. Say, someone who was willing to write even a fairly difficult and technical book, but in straightforward, fairly clear prose, attempting to explain at least a version of the main ideas Derrida's works dealt with. Instead, he got people who sort of pushed him in the opposite direction, Derrideans whose prose was somehow even "more Derridean" than his own, and who didn't really do much as far as explaining his ideas to anyone who didn't already buy them. Put differently, what difficult but possibly brilliant thinkers need are clear and convincing expositors, not also-difficult-yet-mediocre imitators.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoI think Derrida would've been much better off, in terms of intellectual legacy, if he had a student who took him somewhat less seriously on that point, perhaps even against his wishes. Say, someone who was willing to write even a fairly difficult and technical book, but in straightforward, fairly clear prose, attempting to explain at least a version of the main ideas Derrida's works dealt with You want to know the funny thing? He did exactly that. One of Derrida's most prominent students, Geoff Bennington, wrote a book (with Derrida's approval and authorization) which attempted to summarize Derrida's work for the general reader. To make the game more interesting, he attempted to do so without directly quoting Derrida a single time. And, just to put a nice bow on it all, Derrida read the manuscript, and wrote a piece (which is published in the same volume) outlining briefly the parts of his philosophy he thought were excluded by Bennington's summary.
- _delirium 16y agoInteresting, perhaps that would be a better place to start. I've attempted to read some Derridean secondary literature, and it has not been very enlightening at all; much harder to read than Derrida himself, actually. Two random entry points I've attempted, besides some miscellaneous journal articles, are through Paul de Man and Michael Marder (the latter because the idea of a realist reading of Derrida interests me), and both had such annoying prose that it was hard to get anywhere. It was like someone was parodying Derrida while writing about him or something.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoThere is one factor which counts above all others in trying to understand Derrida: you need to have an intimate understanding of the work he is commenting upon. Trying to read Derrida on, say, Condillac, is absolutely pointless if you haven't read the Condillac. Fortunately, in the course of his career, Derrida read through a large swath of the philosophical corpus, so it should be pretty easy to find a work of his which comments on something you already know well.
- Robin_Message 16y agoOn page 8 of that book Geoff Bennington says "It is, of course, impossible to write a book of this sort about Derrida." (Unfortunately the conclusion of that thought is on the next page, which Amazon isn't showing me, but I'm assuming he means what he says here.) If you can't explain something, you don't understand it. If no-one can explain it, no-one understands it and it doesn't mean anything. A theory with no predictive power is useless. (As an aside, I had a look at some of Geoff Bennington's other freely accessible work and came across the gem "The end of communication is the end of communication." That's a clever pun, but was it really the best way to explain an obtuse philosophy that others regard as simply an edifice of clever puns and tricks, void of thought? Ballsy, but surely not the best way. Has anyone explained Derrida using words of four letters or less, without a single pun?) I am wasting too much of my time, and yours, so my parting shot shall be this: Is there any point attempting to understand this philosophy? Will it make me a better person? Will it enable me to organise society better? Will it help me understand the universe more fully? Or will it simply mean I can count myself part of an in-group that has no discernible external beliefs?