4 ms·
> StartCom hired PwC for doing a full webtrust audit. Is PwC any good for real security audits? > StartCom hired Cure53 as suggested by Mozilla Does that mea
by baby 9y ago
> StartCom hired PwC for doing a full webtrust audit.
Is PwC any good for real security audits?
> StartCom hired Cure53 as suggested by Mozilla
Does that mean the report will be public? That's what Cure53 tend to do.
> c.- StartCom acquired EJBCA PKI software from Primekey (CA, VA and TSA). There´s no in-house development for PKI
After acquisition it is now in-house...
> e.- StartCom has developed a new CMS system and website, using a new language, PHP, from scratch.
This sounds like they're in need of a real webapp audit
Another question: are there any real reasons why we don't have critical name constraints to countries' TLDs?
- xori 9y agoThe Cure53 report is public. Their final statement is positive. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/attachment.cgi?id=8886970 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/attachment.cgi?id=8886970
- michaelt 9y agoare there any real reasons why we don't have critical name constraints to countries' TLDs? The reasoning I've heard is that .cn users' security requirements aren't any lower than .com users' security requirements. i.e. if startcom/Qihoo360 aren't good enough to issue .com, they're not good enough to issue .cn
- ameliaquining 9y agoYeah, but reducing the number of CAs that are trusted for any given domain is likely positive. I'm also curious as to how the Chinese government plays into all this. Do they have a track record of making trusted CAs misissue certificates?
- Ajedi32 9y ago> Do they have a track record of making trusted CAs misissue certificates? Probably not. Any CA missisuing certs intentionally (whether by government coercion or not) probably wouldn't remain trusted for long. So if the Chinese government is doing something like that, the public is certainly not aware of it, else there wouldn't be any Chinese CAs left that are still trusted.
- baby 9y agoThat's the beauty of the trust store. The PKI might be a fucked up solution to our trust problem on the internet, but it puts enough pressure against governments to throw them away.
- baby 9y agoI've heard that some countries' CA tend to misbehave more than others, that would help.
- mmalone 9y ago> Is PwC any good for real security audits? It depends on what you mean by "real security audits." If you want someone to audit your new crypto protocol, probably not. PwC is more about internal control / governance audits. They're making sure financial reporting is done correctly, segregation of duties are enforced within the organization, record retention policies are documented and enforced. Less technical, more organizational / meatspace. PwC is the sort of auditor that would find out that a company has a beneficial owner that's connected to a high ranking political figure in China... stuff like that. And I think they're pretty good at it.
- baby 9y agoI see. It looks like the security/crypto audit has gone to Cure53, which definitely looks like a serious consultancy.
- phonon 9y agoIt's a webtrust audit, not a security audit per se. http://www.webtrust.org/licensed-webtrust-practitioners-international/item64419.aspx http://www.webtrust.org/licensed-webtrust-practitioners-inte...
- baby 9y agocan you explain the difference?
- phonon 9y agoThey are not checking if your systems are, say, vulnerable to a SQL injection attack. Take a look at http://www.webtrust.org/homepage-documents/item54279.pdf http://www.webtrust.org/homepage-documents/item54279.pdf and say, a typical CPS https://www.digicert.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/DigiCert_CPS_v4112.pdf https://www.digicert.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/DigiCert... They do an audit to check if all practices and procedures follow these guidelines.
- baby 9y agoAh, a checklist audit.
- Ded7xSEoPKYNsDd 9y ago> After acquisition it is now in-house... I first parsed this differently, too, but I think they just bought some software for PKI services, not the software company.