4 ms·
Private prisons also need constant influx of inmates to keep profits high, therefore the system has no incentives to lower the crime rate. If there are not enou
by squarefoot 9y ago
Private prisons also need constant influx of inmates to keep profits high, therefore the system has no incentives to lower the crime rate. If there are not enough new criminals, they must be created, and planting evidence is one way of achieving that goal.
- dmix 9y agoHow are private prisons incentivizing politicians to write new laws or stop other laws? Are you saying there are people who have invested in prisons who are lobbying for tough on crime policies in order to fill their prisons with people? Do you have examples of this? Can you even get wealthy enough running prisons to have much influence in congress? As far as I'm concerned this doesn't have to be the case for me to be critical of private prisons and I'm otherwise generally libertarian for most issues. One of the things government should be doing is handling criminal justice and running prisons should be a part of that IMO. I don't see much utility in letting private organizations run them, there's no real competition and 'success' seems merely a matter of a) political connections or b) offering the lowest price. Prisons should be focused on reforming criminals and treat them well, so a low budget hyper price-conscious system sounds like a negative incentive to me. The cost of criminals on society is high so giving appropriate resources for handling them should be a priority. If the US want's to reduce their massive prison bills they should reduce their massive number of criminals.
- brianpgordon 9y ago> Are you saying there are people who have invested in prisons who are lobbying for tough on crime policies in order to fill their prisons with people? Do you have examples of this? This is not exactly what you describe, but it shows that this kind of corruption is out there- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kids_for_cash_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kids_for_cash_scandal
- maxfurman 9y agoYou said it yourself, those who profit from running private prisons lobby lawmakers to support their business - and private prisons are in fact massively profitable. Here is a Washington Post article about the influence of the prison industry on Congress - https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/04/28/how-for-profit-prisons-have-become-the-biggest-lobby-no-one-is-talking-about/?utm_term=.3cc68ea5ee08 https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/04/28/...
- dmix 9y agoI wasn't entirely dismissing that it was happening. I just assume it's more hyperbole than reality that the 'private prison industry' has much influence of criminal justice laws. But I see that that there are a few occasions where this too is also being realized as a negative incentive. This just further adds to the larger, more potent, argument against them. That the typical benefits of privatizaton are largely non-existant in this scenario. I really don't see the value of privatizing such a sensitive and serious government responsibility. Simply because it's far from a true marketplace. I doubt many libertarians are pushing for these prisons either. Even the Koch brothers were awarded by Obama for their justice reform work to reduce incarceration rates. Removing people from being able to work, taking away kids fathers, hurting their long term employability, and sending them to a 'con-college' doesn't help society at all from a purely economic perspective. It should be the absolute last resort for the worst criminals instead of the standard practice even for non-violent crimes. It sounds like it's more of the domain of big government republicans who love defence industry style privatization like the countless companies getting rich off of NSA contracts with marginal ROI and limited oversight. The real underlying problem here is a tough-on-crime prison culture in the US. This should never be a potential 'growth' industry. This can only happen in the US due to their high incarceration rate which far outpaces other countries. If you kill this obsession with harsh prison sentencing and yearly flood of new laws you'd also stop this industry from being an attractive space for investors to back lobbyists. Likewise killing private prisons seems like it would also help reduce this culture.
- zimpenfish 9y agoThis isn't direct lobbying for new laws, etc., but it's certainly a private company going "we need you to lock up more people or we're going to screw your town" and politicians scrambling to help them out. http://www.santafenewmexican.com/news/local_news/company-plans-to-close-private-estancia-prison-lay-off/article_1ecd4d0e-caa1-5a05-bab2-1a7270729271.html http://www.santafenewmexican.com/news/local_news/company-pla...