3 ms·
I'm sure they could find the money somewhere. I can only hope that no politician has read this and is thinking "I know, let's loan them the money at no cost".
by nerdponx 9y ago
I'm sure they could find the money somewhere. I can only hope that no politician has read this and is thinking "I know, let's loan them the money at no cost".
This is a great opportunity for right-wing politicians to put their money where their mouth is. They claim to support free markets, so this is what they should do: allow banks to reduce or end business in the UK, and then allow the willingness to pay for banking in the UK to rise to the point where it comes profitable again to operate there. Banks are run by, well, bankers. Surely they can figure out the accounting on their own without government assistance.
- lmm 9y agoThat's a little disengenous when we talk about banks, which are creatures of governmental regulation from top to bottom. How much of this capital is "needed" solely because of regulatory requirements? (Of course governments are quite right to impose requirements on those organizations they're providing backstop funding for. But you can't talk about a "free market" in one aspect of banking in isolation; it isn't and can't be a free market unless you change myriad other aspects of how the banking system works)
- nerdponx 9y agoI'm not sure I buy that. Regulation on "how to run your business" is somewhat different from "where to run your business" and "how much to charge for your business", or for that matter "here's some free money to help you keep profits higher than they would be otherwise". There is plenty of regulation in computer monitor design and construction by way of FCC requirements, emissions standards, and e-waste recycling rules. Would you argue that the computer monitor market is not free as a result? Without regulation on fractional-reserve banking, you would have a serious principal-agent problem that, if anything, would make the market for banking less free if left uncontrolled. I see no analogous argument for the government using taxpayer money to buffer major banks' operating expenses.
- lmm 9y ago> There is plenty of regulation in computer monitor design and construction by way of FCC requirements, emissions standards, and e-waste recycling rules. Would you argue that the computer monitor market is not free as a result? The computer monitor market is notoriously unfree for various reasons, but I suspect that's an accidentally bad example and will assume we were talking about something else. I'd say it's a matter of degree. A simple, objective regulation doesn't interfere with a free market; a government directly instructing a business to make particular decisions distorts it greatly. Banking isn't quite at the latter level but it comes close. > Without regulation on fractional-reserve banking, you would have a serious principal-agent problem that, if anything, would make the market for banking less free if left uncontrolled. The risk of economic collapse is an enormous externality. I see no analogous argument for the government using taxpayer money to buffer major banks' operating expenses. It's never as simple as that. Obviously the government should not be handing bags of cash to banks or any other businesses. But we generally regard doing regulation as something the government should bear its own costs for rather than passing on to the regulatee.
- freeflight 9y ago> But we generally regard doing regulation as something the government should bear its own costs for rather than passing on to the regulatee. How so? If the government regulates that you shouldn't dispose your chemical waste into the river because that's bad for everybody, then it's still your problem to figure out what to do with that chemical waste, after all, it's your waste and not theirs. The government has no responsibility for bearing any costs which result from you merely following the rule of law.
- lmm 9y ago> How so? If the government regulates that you shouldn't dispose your chemical waste into the river because that's bad for everybody, then it's still your problem to figure out what to do with that chemical waste, after all, it's your waste and not theirs. It's your problem to figure out how to dispose it safely, sure. But if they want to e.g. audit where the waste is going, that would be widely seen as something the government should do/pay for themselves. And that's how it is with a lot of banking regulation: complying isn't the expensive part, measuring and demonstrating that you're complying is.
- justforFranz 9y agoGovernment doesn't regulate banks so much as banks regulate government.