8 ms·
Coin Dance – Bitcoin Cash Hard Fork
- gigatexal 9y agoCan someone explain to a distant *coin observer what this means? What it might mean for the price of Bitcoin etc?
- olegkikin 9y agoIt means there will be 2 different bitcoins: 1) SegWit Bitcoin and 2) Bitcoin Cash. The split happened because people have very different ideas on how Bitcoin should scale (transactions per second). SegWit supporters think that most transactions should happen off the blockchain (in something like Lightning network), which then settle on the chain. They also talk about increasing the block to 2MB (SegWit2X), but I'm not sure that will happen. Bitcoin Cash instead extends the block size from 1MB to 8MB (and probably more in the future), allowing all of the transactions to exist on the chain. What it means for the price is not clear, and if someone tells you they know where the price will go, they are just guessing. As we are speaking, Bitcoin price is crashing a bit (currently at $2695). Bitcoin Cash is valued at around $293. One thing we know for a fact is, if you owned bitcoins prior to the fork, you will get the same amount of SegWit and Cash varieties.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> One thing we know for a fact is, if you owned bitcoins prior to the fork, you will get the same amount of SegWit and Cash varieties. So am I dumb for not having bought some Bitcoins prior to the split, and getting free "money"?
- lowpro 9y agoIf one or either of them drops below the value of BTC pre-split, then no. No one knows what will happen, and assuming they'd not drop by the difference of pre-split is definitely not guaranteed, especially if you consider the pre-split price highly inflated. Note I follow CC a little bit more than casually, no expert and I'm not sure what the GP means exactly by this statement.
- pja 9y agoIf the number of BTC suddenly doubled, you'd expect the value of each one to halve given rational expectations and perfect knowledge of BTC holders. Of course a) the two BTC variants won't have equal worth and b) participants in the BTC economy have neither perfect knowledge nor total rationality (the level of rationality in the BTC ecosystem has been much debated over recent years as we all know) so the actual outcome may differ from the 'perfect' one, but the likelihood is that values will converge over time to the outcome that the value of BTC1+BTC2 post split is equal to the value of BTC pre-split, plus or minus any gains/losses along the way (which may include a reputational loss or gain based on how well the split goes).
- elif 9y agoDepends on how many people did that and what their intentions are. Also to sell 8mb bitcoins, a >1MB mined block will have to be accepted by the network which may not happen for hours or days. There is a schedule for difficulty changes but there's no telling how long it will be before they are actually tradable.
- olegkikin 9y ago[I was definitely wrong here] UAHF specs that the fork happens after the 1st >=1MB block is mined. https://github.com/Bitcoin-UAHF/spec/blob/master/uahf-technical-spec.md https://github.com/Bitcoin-UAHF/spec/blob/master/uahf-techni... But it looks like the "fork" is already happening, because Bitcoin Cash network rejected block 478559, and now has to mine one of its own. 2017-08-01 13:23:46 ERROR: ContextualCheckBlock: BUIP055 fork block (00000000000000000019f112ec0a9982926f1258cdcc558dd7c3b7e5dc7fa148, height 478559) must exceed 1000000, but this block is 272502 bytes 2017-08-01 13:23:46 ERROR: ProcessNewBlock: AcceptBlock FAILED 2017-08-01 13:23:46 Invalid block due to bad-blk-too-small 2017-08-01 13:23:53 ERROR: AcceptBlockHeader: block 00000000000000000019f112ec0a9982926f1258cdcc558dd7c3b7e5dc7fa148 height 478559 is marked invalid
- debaserx 9y ago// If UAHF is enabled for the curent block, but not for the previous block, we must check that the block is larger than 1MB. https://github.com/Bitcoin-ABC/bitcoin-abc/blob/174846aaaf564e64b6bd06d679996b52ba86ad53/src/validation.cpp#L3397 https://github.com/Bitcoin-ABC/bitcoin-abc/blob/174846aaaf56...
- olegkikin 9y agoNot necessarily. The real total value may be constant, and will simply be split between the branches. That, of course, would not happen instantly, so there's probably a way to time it perfectly. As in, buy right before the split, and sell right after. But don't forget there are fees involved, and also the spread between buy and sell.
- 33W 9y agoYes & no, consider this like a stock split. But instead of an even split, where your 1 share of GOOG becomes 2, both with the same price, you get 1 (or fraction of) BTC and BCC, where BTC = ~$2700 and BCC = ~$230. The overall value may go up, but you may also see the cost of BTC drop by the value of BCC (like when a dividend is paid on a stock). BCC could also lose adoption, and lose value significantly.
- sktrdie 9y agoOne important point to be careful about are replay attacks. If you decide to spend your coins on the Bitcoin Cash, you're essentially broadcasting a transaction signed with your private key, which could be used to move your coins on the other Bitcoin SegWith chain. So if you spend coins on one chain, it may automatically occur also on the other chain.
- olegkikin 9y agoReplay protection is no longer opt-in, and is now mandatory. > How is transaction replay being handled between the new and the old blockchain? Bitcoin Cash transactions use a new flag SIGHASH_FORKID, which is non standard to the legacy blockchain. This prevents Bitcoin Cash transactions from being replayed on the Bitcoin blockchain and vice versa.
- gst 9y agoNon-standard transactions aren't usually included by miners, but as far as I understand Bitcoin miners are still free to include those transactions if they want to. Wouldn't this mean that a malicious miner would be able to replay transactions from Bitcoin to bcash?
- olegkikin 9y agoNo, because the signatures will not match. That's the whole point of replay protection (or at least my understanding of it).
- flashdance 9y agoIIRC, if a miner includes an invalid sighash into a block it will be rejected by regular bitcoin nodes. Ya gotta follow the spec.
- flyingfences 9y agoBitcoin price is not "crashing"; it's fluctuating well within its normal variation.
- astrodust 9y agoBetween ridiculous and ridiculously insane, as always.
- gigatexal 9y agoThank you! I hadn’t heard of this fork until now and your write up was clear and makes sense.
- wslh 9y ago> The split happened because people have very different ideas on how Bitcoin should scale (transactions per second). I would say that the split will happen because the Bitcoin Cash have enough firepower (e.g. marketing, business) to diverse the attention to them since these forks could have been possible for long time. It is not a coincidence that these days are important for the SegWit2x and UASF projects too.
- simias 9y ago>One thing we know for a fact is, if you owned bitcoins prior to the fork, you will get the same amount of SegWit and Cash varieties. I want to point out that here "owning" means actually having the coins on one of your personal addresses whose private key you own. If your coins are hosted on an exchange or any kind of 3rd party wallet nothing is guaranteed (unless said exchange explicitly announced that they would let you trade your BCC).
- ensignavenger 9y agoWhich is why I moved my small BTC holdings out of coinbase yesterday to a private wallet address :)
- codingmyway 9y agoThe outcome will likely depend of how many miners switch to the b-cash chain. I can see both sides dumping to try and convince the market that theirs is the real bitcoin and that the other will be worth(-)less. Likely to be a lot of volatility but b-cash proponents who favor growing the blocksize are big enough in number that I think both will survive, at least until that chain hits real scaling problems.
- rebuilder 9y agoThat kind of economic warfare seems very risky to me. Miners, at least, are ultimately businesspeople, and the risk/reward for dumping either coin doesn't seem all that attractive to me. Why not just keep mining whatever they've chosen to mine, and switch to the other chain if it looks like they made the wrong choice? Or just mine whichever coin is most profitable at any given time?
- jernejzen 9y agoWhat does that mean for "normal" user? Say, one that buys some things online and cares a bit about investment?
- taysic 9y agoIt might impact a normal user if one chain is seen to be more effective at handling larger load. There were long delays previously in bitcoin that caused transactions to not go through for hours from my understanding.
- nicpottier 9y agoThis is the best writeup I've seen on the topic: https://blog.bridge21.io/before-and-after-the-great-bitcoin-fork-17d2aad5d512 https://blog.bridge21.io/before-and-after-the-great-bitcoin-...
- elmar 9y agoI really agree with the author that Bitcoin is quickly becoming the “MySpace” of crypto-currenc, when you see options like Monero you wonder why you would use Bitcoin in the future.
- elif 9y agoIf it is anything like the ether split, 8mb btc + SW BTC > old BTC Logically SW BTC should go down (and it has) and 8MB BTC should have value cut out of it, but with ethereum and now it seems the sum of both parts is greater than the whole before the fork. BCC futures market up about $100 since this morning on more than double yesterday's volume. SW BTC down a couple hundred but added together they are at $3,168 at time of this comment.
- nnx 9y agoCan easily monitor status of each competing/potential split at https://www.btcforkmonitor.info https://www.btcforkmonitor.info
- provost 9y agoThanks for linking to this. FYI -- It's not immediately clear, but the details of how this works and the status checks are provided at the bottom of the webpage.
- nnx 9y agohttps://bitnodes.21.co/nodes/ https://bitnodes.21.co/nodes/ is also useful to follow what's happening. It looks like 25% of the nodes in the Bitcoin network are suddenly running "Bitcoin ABC" (the implementation supporting bigger block sizes) on AWS... someone somewhere has started a bunch of (spot?) instances it seems.
- simias 9y agoWhich is a "PR" move and nothing much, I want to point out. I think the metric everybody is watching for at the moment is the hashrate on the BCC fork. It'll show what portion of miners actually commit to the fork. Spawning nodes is cheap and doesn't really mean much.
- reefoctopus 9y agoThere are reports that the new AWS nodes aren't playing nicely with existing nodes. It may be an attack.
- nnx 9y agoany link to share about this?
- reefoctopus 9y agoHere's the thread I'm following. https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/6qvofq/someone_just_launched_over_500_bucash_nodes_on_aws/ https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/6qvofq/someone_just_la...
- eof 9y agoAnyone know how to / where to get an idea of hashrate distribution? It seems it can really only be estimated by the number of blocks that come out; which means (if I understand correctly) it could be days before the next BCC block if BCC has some minuscule amount of hash power.
- runeks 9y agoHashrate distribution can indeed only be inferred from the rate of block production and their difficulties. And you need quite a few samples to get a clear picture (Poisson distribution). EDIT: It would probably be faster to determine the speed of the Cash fork by noticing the reduction in hash rate on the main Bitcoin network.
- flashdance 9y agoI've heard that it's roughly 1%. It probably isn't too high because: 1) The main chain's rate of block generation has not dropped substantially. Of course, it's hard to tell in such a short timeframe, but at least according to https://bitcoinwisdom.com/bitcoin/difficulty https://bitcoinwisdom.com/bitcoin/difficulty not much is happening. 2) No BCH blocks have been mined in the past 2.5 hours. This could be variance (even with 100% of the hashrate this sort of gap is plausible), but I suspect not.
- jswny 9y agoI think I have enough understanding of the different types of Bitcoin between SegWit and Bitcoin Cash and what they do differently. However, I'm not very invested in the Bitcoin community. Could someone explain which of the significant parties (developers, users, miners, exchanges, etc.) are supporting which type of Bitcoin and why?
- Renaud 9y agoWas wondering the same recently and found this presentation fairly balanced: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H7B3z-l8bJ8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H7B3z-l8bJ8
- Taek 9y agoThe people responsible for writing 90%+ of the code changes to Bitcoin since 2013 are all heavily in favor of SegWit, and heavily against Bitcoin Cash and also against SegWit2x. These guys are the researchers and engineers with the deepest understanding of decentralization, game theory, and adversarial blockchain design. The most politically active exchanges, miners, and payment processors are all in favor of SegWit2x, and against the bitcoin-core developers. These are the people who are most familiar with business, who are closest to the userbase, and have to deal with the practical problems associated with running Bitcoin businesses in ways that the core developers do not. At the same time, they often miss significant security and stability risks in the changes that they propose. A small faction of highly passionate users with relatively deep pockets and effective social media skills favor Bitcoin Cash. This group passionately distrusts the bitcoin-core developers, has a strange vendetta with the EFF-commended company Blockstream, and is the source of a large number of conspiracy theories. This is the same group that passionately backed the failed Bitcoin-XT project, the failed Bitcoin-Classic project, and the failed Bitcoin-Unlimited project. Their following I think was largest during the Bitcoin-Classic days, but at this point I think they've disenfranchised a lot of their early community members with their stubborn anti-bitcoin-core rhetoric.
- Jabanga 9y ago>These guys are the researchers and engineers with the deepest understanding of decentralization, game theory, and adversarial blockchain design. These guys don't have the deepest understanding of any of those things. The minutia of the protocol, and the source code that implements it, is extremely important, but knowledge of it does not impart one with any insights into game theory, the political implications of different decentralisation tradeoffs, and adversarial blockchain design as it pertains to political/economic attacks.
- Taek 9y agoThis is a misleading headline I feel. It makes it seem like Bitcoin Cash is the new Bitcoin, and that the old Bitcoin is no longer going to be usable. The old Bitcoin is very clearly favored in the markets, and has the most active userbase. A better title might be 'Bitcoin Cash creates their own version of the Bitcoin network with a shared history and bigger blocks.'
- dang 9y agoOk, we'll revert it to the title on the page. Submitted title was "Bitcoin forking to Bitcoin Cash with a higher block size". That breaks the HN guidelines, which ask "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sauronlord 9y agoI'm confused. Is this a Hard Fork of BCC into something else. Or is it a Hard Fork of BTC into BCC? It's not clear if this is a gag (ie a Hard Fork of BCC into CoinDanceBCC)
- xeromal 9y agoDo people get double money from the split? So if I had 100 bitcoins do I also get 100 bit coin cashes?
- antocv 9y agoYes. You get free segwit bitcoins. The bitcoin cash resembles the original bitcoin as described in whitepaper the most. If you sell your bitcoin segwit today for bitcoin cash at an exchange, the rates are around 0.08-0.12, it is like inflation.
- taysic 9y agoYea you get 100 BCC but you only get double the money if the value of BCC will be equal to BTC prior to the fork. More realistically they will both drop so that the two chains will be equivalent in value before the fork. However, no one really knows what will happen to the value.