4 ms·
> People should not form opinions based on who other people work for, when they aren't speaking for their companies. This is precisely a type of bias we should
by rifung 9y ago
> People should not form opinions based on who other people work for, when they aren't speaking for their companies. This is precisely a type of bias we should be seeking to prevent. It adds no value to an intellectual discussion. It just gives a mechanism for smug self satisfaction by saying "hey, i don't have to care if he has a good point, he works for X so i can just pretend it's not a real argument"
The irony is that by not disclosing the company you work for, you actually make it worse. If you disclose any conflicts of interest, then people will be less likely to accuse you of having an ulterior motive. I suppose it's a philosophical choice of living like how you want the world to be or how it is now and who am I to tell you how to live your life!
- true_religion 9y agoIt's not as if he didn't disclose. He did so in his profile which is the canonical place on HN to put off-topic information about a poster. If he put "I work at Google", on every post that touches Google then we might as well go back to having signatures on every post like a web-forum.