5 ms·
MD's are by and large incredibly non-curious about hard-to-diagnose chronic conditions
by tomcam 9y ago
MD's are by and large incredibly non-curious about hard-to-diagnose chronic conditions
- o_____________o 9y agoWhat incentive do they have besides being a heroic, indefatigable person? If anything, they're increasing their attack surface for being blamed or sued.
- komali2 9y agoCurious about this. I often find engineers motivated purely by the desire to solve the problem. Was just at defcon - witnessed many people vaguely wandering around the tables of teams trying to hack devices, then getting sucked in as they offered solutions and inevitably got involved with trying to solve the problem. Did it myself a couple times, even though I had planned on attending more talks.
- koube 9y agoThey hate solving problems when someone comes up to them with a strange and incomplete description and says "can you fix my problem"? The made a whole show about this called the IT Crowd where they play a tape that says "Have you tried turning it on and off again" instead of legitimately answering phones. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_IT_Crowd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_IT_Crowd Here's a subreddit where people complain about the problems that people bring them: https://www.reddit.com/r/talesfromtechsupport/ https://www.reddit.com/r/talesfromtechsupport/ Here's a subreddit for which the tagline starts with "Tired of stupid customers?": https://www.reddit.com/r/iiiiiiitttttttttttt/ https://www.reddit.com/r/iiiiiiitttttttttttt/ There are many problems in the tech field which are exceedingly difficult yet uninteresting. There are many problems that people bring that are vague descriptions that eventually turn out to be user error. It would not be surprising for the same phenomenon to exist in the medical field as well.
- FLUX-YOU 9y agoThe human body apparently has pretty terrible UI/UX.
- taneq 9y agoIt's not bad for something we found in a cave.
- komali2 9y agoHuh, I had never thought of that - the daily issues that patients bring a doctor I can see as a parallel to an engineer being presented with "can you fix my email?" - complete with user stupidity - "My heart don't feel good" "Did you quit smoking and start exercising like I told you to?" "No."
- noshbrinken 9y agoI've wondered the same thing myself pretty much every time I've come into contact with a doctor. The fundamental lack of curiosity for someone in a field related to science (seemingly based on science) is astonishing.
- inopinatus 9y agoThat has never been my experience with any doctor, and I have met many doctors of many different specialties. Perhaps the problem here is not doctors, but the way you are communicating (or not) with them. Your sotto-voce "seemingly based on science" is exceedingly derisive; perhaps that is carrying across. I too tend to minimise the length of conversations with people that treat me with contempt.
- Tobani 9y agoYes, you could potentially "solve the problem." Unless there is a test or a treatment that is easy and effictive enough to use empirically it is much harder to diagnose that person. Physicians have to balance quality of life improvement for patients along with treatment. There may be a trade-off between efficacy rate of treatments and the likelihood of adequate compliance. People may not change their diets or take their meds appropriately to improve their health for example. If you can't rely on the patient you might never find the solution. You may just be better off at improving their quality of life even if it doesn't ultimately solve their underlying condition.
- gozur88 9y agoBecause as a society we can't spend ten million dollars on every patient with a hard-to-diagnose chronic condition that may just be stress. It just isn't practical.
- narrator 9y agoStress can show up as chronic cortisol elevation which is not an expensive test. Instead we get the cheapest cure of all: gaslighting.
- gozur88 9y agoThat's just false, and pretty insulting to the medical establishment.
- jacobolus 9y agoIt’s false that cortisol can be easily tested? Or it’s false that many doctors tell patients that their unexplained symptoms are probably just psychosomatic and they should try to reduce stress, as a way of getting them to go away and stop asking for diagnostic efforts beyond the doctor’s current level of expertise? I’ve experienced the latter first hand, and know many other people who have also, none of whom were chronically stressed in any kind of unusual way, as far as I could tell. Maybe “gaslighting” is a slightly unfair name. I would describe it more along the lines of “patronizing indifference”.
- alphaoverlord 9y agoNot op but cortisol is elevated in "just stress" as well as critical illness. An elevated cortisol is not a diagnostic test that can deferentiate between a serious medical problem and stress.
- gozur88 9y agoAlso, cortisol isn't always elevated when stress is the problem. So a negative test result doesn't really tell you anything, and a positive test result tells you something, but you don't know what that something is without a lot more testing, which may or may not tell you anything.
- emodendroket 9y agoI found seeking treatment for RSI pretty frustrating until I went to an occupational therapist.
- hycaria 9y agoSo are programmers by and large incredibly non-curious about learning completely new stuff they will probably not even use so much, and for which they could make solutions with the tools they have. It's a job like any other. Some people don't want to go the extra mile because they have other priorities in life.