4 ms·
It would be pretty exciting to duplicate keys (especially proprietary and "do not duplicate" institutional keys) from the privacy of home. Might even hasten the
by closeparen 9y ago
It would be pretty exciting to duplicate keys (especially proprietary and "do not duplicate" institutional keys) from the privacy of home. Might even hasten the end of the mechanical lock as a security device.
Sure, you can do that now with Shapeways or a crooked locksmith, but it would be fun to do independently.
- debatem1 9y agoWhy not use plastic?
- tyingq 9y agoFor occasional or one time use, that's actually fine. Just need a tension wrench to turn the cylinder so the plastic doesn't bend/break.
- majormajor 9y agoIt'd work for a few times, at least. In the 90s, BMW gave out plastic wallet-sized cards with flip-out emergency keys with at least some of their cars. Not super durable for repeated use, but handy to have. Looks like something similar continued into the 2000s for a while, at least: http://www.bimmerboard.com/members/q/original/BMW%20Transponders%20Keys.jpg http://www.bimmerboard.com/members/q/original/BMW%20Transpon...
- coredog64 9y agoMy '96 Chevy Cavalier came with one of those.
- mhb 9y agoYou can do that with a file and a jeweler's saw or hacksaw. Certainly with a milling machine.
- BurningFrog 9y agoBut how do I find a "blank" key to start from?
- sigstoat 9y agoi'd start by plugging "key blank" into your favorite search engine. if that fails you horribly, you can buy brass all over the internet: http://www.onlinemetals.com/ http://www.onlinemetals.com/ https://www.metalsdepot.com/ https://www.metalsdepot.com/ mcmaster-carr, or amazon. i suggest a pair of calipers, too.
- closeparen 9y agoThe point of these proprietary institutional key systems is that you can't. The blank is patented, and the authorized manufacturer will only sell it to authorized representatives of an institution which has a contract to use that key system. It will further guarantee that only one institution gets to use that system per geographical region. It's "security through the inordinate difficulty of acquiring an object with a particular shape." Cheap 3D printing of metal might put an end to that strategy.
- mcphage 9y agoIf you can carve the teeth of the key, you can certainly carve the blank.
- RobGR 9y agoThere is an image processing script, that will take a picture of the key and deduce the key number, or bitting code, or "key cut code", which is an expression of the heights for each pin. [1] [2] Then you can plug that bitting code into a script which will generate an STL model for the key. [3] I did this, except I measured the key with calibers and back-calculated the key number. I printed the key on a cheap Prusa I3 in ABS, it was not impressive in terms of resolution or strength, but it did work in my house. I carefully tested it because I thought it might break off in the lock, and it felt weak, but worked -- definitely good enough for a single covert access, or even use as an emergency backup key to hide somewhere. No fancy metal printer needed, and you could write a script to pull pictures of keys out of twitter or whatever and automate the process. [1] http://hackaday.com/2009/09/22/photographic-key-duplication/ http://hackaday.com/2009/09/22/photographic-key-duplication/ [2] http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:kxuH9jRqwjsJ:vision.ucsd.edu/~blaxton/sneakey.html+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:kxuH9jR... [3] https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:52761/ https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:52761/
- schoen 9y agoIt's certainly possible, but this kind of reminds me of discussions here on HN and elsewhere about way that the 3D printing of guns can create a crisis for gun control regimes. People in discussion threads reasonably pointed out that it's been possible to manufacture guns in home workshops for hundreds of years and that, for some kinds of weapons, it's not even toward the high end of challenging metalworking projects, and that indeed many people regularly do it either as a hobby or profession without 3D printing or even without CNC of any kind. But this is kind of shocking for software-oriented people who might think that "manufacturing" "hardware" is a super-tough black art that can only be done by professionals in factories. And indeed that's pretty much my intuition as a software person who hasn't done woodworking since middle school shop class and never learned any of the other manufacturing skills that humanity has been working on for the last while. (Reading Bunnie's new book about manufacturing in China has been fascinating for me, because it's like "oh yeah, so all of these objects just come from people doing different tasks to fabricate them"!) So people said about gun manufacturing that there was this funny intuition that 3D printing somehow allows people to casually manufacture complex objects at home which they otherwise simply couldn't do. But in fact, if people were moderately motivated, they could easily learn some of the other techniques that let them manufacture and/or duplicate objects. So we may tend to exaggerate the impact by thinking that other methods represent a huge, hard barrier while 3D printing represents true "push-button manufacturing". Neither side of this intuition is necessarily the reality. For the problem of duplicating proprietary keys, it seems like anyone could already do this at home without especially expensive equipment and without especially extensive training. I remember reading a Mickey Mouse cartoon from many decades ago where a key was supposed to be duplicated from a negative impression taken in some clay (or something), and this was presented as a basic skill of a generalist mechanic! On the other hand, maybe this intuition is partly right if some significant population of would-be home gunsmiths or key-copiers is intimidated enough by hardware and manufacturing that they're sort of waiting around for the pushbutton solution. Edit: looks like other people in this thread have said this a lot more concisely. :-)
- Taniwha 9y agothe thing is that there are laws about some of these sorts of things, they applied before 3D printing came along, and they usually apply to 3D printing too. I help run a Makerspace, a couple of times a year I get a teenage boy (and it is always a boy) come thru the door wanting to print a gun .... after I've given him the lecture about how stupidly dangerous that is, I then remind him that a) here in NZ hand guns are illegal, and b) he would still need to be police vetted and obtain a firearms license - the law doesn't change because you used a 3D printer
- incompatible 9y agoI have a key that claims "copyright" and "do not copy". I've always assumed the copyright claim was bogus, on the grounds that functional items like keys aren't within the scope of copyright law.
- dmix 9y agoI figured that "do not copy" label was for the key cutting people to see and deter them from copying it. But I'm not sure if anyone really follows those labels. I get my keys cut at a convenience store down the street. Key cutting is not exactly a sophisticated service market run by specialists. So I doubt there is much stringent ethical procedures or industry reputations to lean on. Meanwhile someone copying fobs in Toronto for people was publically shamed, which is silly because anyone can buy an RFID copier on Amazon for $30. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/condo-key-fob-copy-1.4151490 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/condo-key-fob-copy-1.4... Amazingly the building I live in charges $100 for replacement fobs.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIf you're important enough you can get the lock makers to make you your own custom blank that they don't sell to anyone else. I ran into this at college when trying to issue a bunch of keys to club members. "Laser cut" keys have a second set of teeth inside one of the low spots in the blank that normal machines can't copy. Luckily, the locks that have the bar to fit the inner teeth are expensive and only important things get them so the hardest part of copying the key was convincing the guy at the hardware store that I just needed copies with the same profile and not the inner teeth.
- michaelt 9y agoI'm not sure if anyone really follows those labels. You're probably right. When people's security needs are great enough to justify paying $150+ per lock, high-end locks offer: (a) Patented keys that the manufacturer only sells to authorized distributors (who are contractually obligated not to cut keys without a key duplication card) (b) have complex designs that can't be cut on standard key-cutting machines and (c) have special 'key control' pins that mean different locksmiths get incompatible locks and key blanks. Needless to say, a sufficiently good 3D scanner & printer (or indeed a sufficiently patient person with a file and a pair of calipers) could bypass these protections.
- ineedasername 9y agoKeys are pretty easy even with "under the kitchen sink" home materials, even easier with a little alginate powder for the mold and craft-store quality binary epoxy to cast. It's not going to do much good with mid/high sec locks that utilize floating pin keys, but then neither would the 3d printed route.