6 ms·
I was pondering this a few weeks back, and after some thought I realized it's even later than I thought. The logic that an alien civilization should smash its n
by jerf 16y ago
I was pondering this a few weeks back, and after some thought I realized it's even later than I thought. The logic that an alien civilization should smash its neighbors before it can be smashed doesn't just hold for intelligence, it holds for life; if we can go from metaphorically crawling in the mud in the early 20th century (before radio) to potentially firing our own relativistic projectiles by, say, 2200, in 300 years, who's to say there isn't a species that could pull that trick in 30 years instead of 300? (Maybe somebody who can work together even better than we can, living with a faster biochemistry on a hotter planet? Something like Eliezer's "Maximum Fun-Fun Ultra Super Happy People"? Who knows? It's hard to imagine the human experience has been truly optimal on the technological development speed front.) In which case you may literally have no time at all to try to pick up the "intelligence". You need to smash all life, before you think it might have "intelligence".
And Earth has been broadcasting "I'm alive!" for at least 2.4 billion years, since the Great Oxygenation Event: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event Ever since then, any intelligence within the area of probably several hundred light years or more has had the ability to take a simple spectrograph of our planet, observe free O2 in the atmosphere, decide that's too likely to be the result of life for comfort, and obliterate the planet.
Nobody has. (Unless you believe the official Current Earth Destruction Status: http://qntm.org/board http://qntm.org/board However, it appears to simply be instrument failure. Somebody really ought to fix that.)
Even on the galactic timescale, 2.4 billion years is not chump change.
Either the game theoretic optimum is not to smash your neighbors immediately (for instance, widespread orbital colonization is indeed practical and is what happens, which as people have observed changes the balance away from "smash"), or we are effectively alone. Either way I think we can discard the relatavistic-projectile-death scenario, except as a major, unplannable fluke.
- hugh3 16y agoHeck, screw oxygen. Rationally, defense-oriented civilizations should smash all habitable-zone planets just to be on the safe side. But you're right: the fact that our suspiciously life-supporting planet has been sitting here for billions of years unmolested does appear to indicate that there aren't any planet-destroying game theorists in our neighbourhood. Alternative scenario: instead of a relativistic projectile, they sent a starship, which will leave us alone unless we develop enough technology to be a threat to its home planet. If we think that's a likely scenario we should all be sitting around worrying about how to not piss off the starship. On the other hand, since knowing about the starship is a threat to the starship, we should try to avoid even thinking about whether there might be a starship.
- younata 16y agoYour alternative scenario boils down to "who cares if other people are watching, let's go develop warp drive so they will feel right talking to us." As the Prime Directive of Star Fleet tells us.
- jerf 16y agoThe Prime Directive is a way of writing exciting television shows that allows you to put characters that ought to be far too powerful to actually be in a dramatic bind into a dramatic bind, not a model for actual interstellar behavior. For that to actually "exist" would require that every species in the galaxy not only has a "human-like" mind, but one of a very particular and unusual bent, most of which probably comes from watching a particular show. This seems unlikely. (Far, far more likely in my mind would be the uplift scenario, that helping these civilizations would be seen as a moral duty once that was actually a real possibility. And it also sort of requires Star-Trek-like limits on technology as well; the Federation lacks the capability to rewrite a primitive civilization from the gene level up, but that seems an unrealistic limitation in real life. And that's not even what I consider the "most likely" scenario; I'm just saying that anyone who tried to instantiate the Prime Directive would probably break down into this moral duty idea pretty quickly. Why sit and wait for them to develop when you can just make it happen? Artificiality of development is a small concern next to potentially billions of unnecessary deaths. Whoever is out there, watching us war and burn and die and doing nothing, is not being an upstanding moral citizen.)
- hugh3 16y agoWhoever is out there, watching us war and burn and die and doing nothing, is not being an upstanding moral citizen.) Really? Do you go out of your way to stop fish and insects from killing each other? edit: I admit this was a badly phrased example. Fish and insects rarely kill each other.
- chc 16y agoHuman history has shown that just dropping technological advancement on human cultures leads to trouble. If their culture is one of tribal warfare rather than modern civilization, there's a very good chance that all your aid will just be used to support their efforts to kill the other guy. It could be that to aliens, our planet's shared culture is still too close to tribal warfare for them to be comfortable raising us to their level. It wouldn't be quite the same as the Prime Directive as a motive, but it would have the same effect in a lot of situations.
- Groxx 16y agoThis implies to me that the ideal method for a more advanced civilization is to build a "honey pot" planet, sending out prime numbers or something, with redonkulous power. Advanced-enough-aliens-to-be-friends-or-enemies are attracted to such a signal, while you merely observe and decide what to do based on their reaction. Nuked the planet? Find out where they came from. Tried to contact, and eventually left, after some vague friendly gesture? Might not try to kill you.