3 ms·
[random advice from the internet] Based on what I've read, the big advantage of a SAFE is that it facilitates transfer of capital from outside investors to the
by brudgers 9y ago
[random advice from the internet]
Based on what I've read, the big advantage of a SAFE is that it facilitates transfer of capital from outside investors to the corporate account quickly by putting off valuation until later. If the money is already in the company, then speed is not an issue.
Parsing your lawyer's comment, there may be something there in that SAFE probably makes less sense the further one gets from Silicon Valley style investment strategies and Silicon Valley's connotation for "startup". On the other hand, if you don't like your lawyers advice or don't think it reflects applicable experience, find another lawyer.
If the money is already in the company, there's probably a bit of a legal mess regarding assigning value to that investment after the fact. Personally, I'd be more in favor of considering a sunk cost and simplifying the cap table on paper. The future preferred equity that would come from conversion later can be provided to the founder as common options now. A founder with preferred stock immediately has interests that are less aligned with those of employees and future cofounders in regard to structuring a liquidation event. In the case of a typical outcome where the startup is worth $0.00 there's no benefit for the additional cap table complexity. In the case of a great outcome, there's no benefit to the either, it's just a matter of which of the founder's pockets the money flows to.
Making the investment a loan seems like a simple solution. In the event of liquidation where there is some but not much cash, a loan would be a liability on the company's books that gets repaid before preferred investors divide the rest. It also avoids a potential problem terms that provide early investors with options to follow on their initial investment...the ways in which a founder would tend to get the capital for follow up investment don't seem aligned with company success...at the very least it is an additional distraction.
Finally, worrying about this is the sort of distraction SAFE's were intended to solve. But the applicable context is sophisticated investors operating with a mindset similar to that in Silicon Valley and not to address founder cash infusions.
Good luck.