3 ms·
Totally agree with you, I do not understand this need to go digital. Voting has worked and works really well with paper, it's a process anyone can audit, even n
by baby 9y ago
Totally agree with you, I do not understand this need to go digital. Voting has worked and works really well with paper, it's a process anyone can audit, even non-technical people. Sure it might take a day, and a bunch of money, but so what? Our democracy heavily relies on this process.
- KGIII 9y agoIn theory, I don't mind digital voting. I do mind network connectivity and closed source machines.
- simias 9y agoEven if the machines were open source you'd have to personally inspect it to make sure it's actually running what it's supposed to be running. Unless you're reading to bring an electron microscope to the polling booth it doesn't seem particularly practical. It would make more sense to check whether your vote was counted post-facto but it's hard to especially if you still want to make it difficult to figure out who voted for whom. There are a few mathematical possibilities but they don't seem particularly practical to me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYRTvoZ3Rho https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYRTvoZ3Rho So for the time being paper ballots are probably the way to go.
- KGIII 9y agoGives you a paper result that you can verify, and leave there for manual recounts as needed. Checksums and verified hardware. This is not insurmountable. You vote, confirm the receipt says the right thing, and stuff it in a box. Verified hardware is a solved problem. Given that it'd have no idea of the candidates, there's no way to program it ahead of time to favor a candidate without being caught. We already have election officials watching each other. This needn't be more complicated than a late 70s calculator. It can even be so simple it doesn't know the candidates names or party affiliations. Well, in theory... In reality, it will be a black box, connected to any open wireless, and made by the company who donated the most. But, in theory, it'd not be too hard to make a fairly dumb device that provides verification. It only has to count and print.
- CydeWeys 9y agoYou haven't solved the problem that being able to prove to anyone else who you voted for should not be possible.
- KGIII 9y agoIf there's a discrepancy, you count the paper receipts. You can order a million simple chips for like $0.03. They chip vendor isn't going to know who is running for dog catcher in 2018. You test a random sample to ensure they can count. You use simple code that is open source and write it to the memory exactly once and blow the fuse to prevent tampering. We can put people in space. Verified hardware and software is a solved problem. Well, assuming you don't make it absurdly complicated. All it needs to do is eliminate manual counting - while providing a paper printout should someone need a recount. You don't even need special tokens to make sure the person in the booth is only voting once. You can be as simple as making it flash an LED to be monitored by the election officials. They have volunteers from the various parties already there watching. Watching a light may even be easier. It doesn't need to be complicated. It need only be a glorified abacus.
- CydeWeys 9y agoDid you reply to the wrong person? My comment was about one simple thing: It should NOT be possible to prove to anyone else who you voted for. Your reply doesn't seem to address that. Separate from that, what does using millions of one-use physically collected chips buy you that just writing to a paper ballot doesn't?
- KGIII 9y agoYou put your printout in the box, as I said above. It prints it out, you put it into the box after confirming it says you voted for who you said you voted for. You buy millions of chips so that we never have to go through this again. This way, the validated code and hardware don't have to be worried about, for a long time. The chips go in the machine, they run it. You'll have spares for a very long time. What does this do? When the polls close, they don't have to count them. They need only count if there's a demand to do so, like a recount today. That's it. Problem solved.