5 ms·
But don't the postmodernists claim only to be 'playing games'? Isn't it the whole point of their philosophy that anything goes, there is no absolute truth, anyt
by ThomPete 16y ago
But don't the postmodernists claim only to be 'playing games'? Isn't it the whole point of their philosophy that anything goes, there is no absolute truth, anything written has the same status as anything else, no point of view is privileged?
And in one paragraph Dawkins shows that he has no understanding of postmodernism what so ever.
The point of postmodernism is not that everything goes, but that we have no absolute frame of reference to judge the trueness of a statement on.
It's not "hey you can do everything you want" but "hey just know that whatever we find out, ultimately we don't know if that is the correct conclusion, as we have no absolute metrics to judge it by.
- barrkel 16y agoWe might have difficulty with truth, but we can evaluate the falsity of a statement about the world. To the degree that statements cannot be falsified, they are arguably without meaning.
- ThomPete 16y agoYou can evaluate the falsity of a statement about our interpretation of the world. But that is quite different than claiming that our way to interpret reality is the right now.
- barrkel 16y agoFor sure, but I don't think you can go beyond truth as correspondence. In so far as our brains are physical, and changes are wired up through physical causality with our senses, you can't break through to some notional Platonic ideal, where Truths are Relations on Forms in a mathematical way, and still have those truths apply directly to the way things "really are". Truths about e.g. mathematics, on the other hand, I would say are analytic in the Kantian sense. They are a different kind of truth, and in many ways are like self-contained games. Useful as formalisms for theories about the world, etc.
- hugh3 16y agoThe point of postmodernism is not that everything goes, but that we have no absolute frame of reference to judge the trueness of a statement on. If postmodernism had "a point" which could be so readily expressed in comprehensible terms, would it have ever have gotten so far as it did?
- ThomPete 16y agoThat is how it got so far. It shows that there are multiple ways to interpret reality. The way that we are using the internet right now is in many ways supportive of postmodernism.
- einarvollset 16y agoEhum. How so?
- ugh 16y agoI think that’s a misreading. “We have no absolute metrics to judge [our findings] by” to me seems to imply that no statement is better than any other statement, that the concept of “truth” is useless; i.e. anything goes (as long as statements about the universe are concerned). And that’s all Dawkins says, not “you can do everything you want”. Rather “you can say everything you want, everything is equally true because nothing is true”. That, to me, is obviously rubbish and rightly attacked. There surly is no such thing as absolute certainty or absolute truth but we can get damn close and find out what’s more likely and what’s less likely. I don’t think I’m attacking a straw man here but I might, so correct me. “Anything goes (as long as statements about the world are concerned)” seems like a fair characterization to me, though.
- ThomPete 16y agoThe difference is that the former tells you that it doesn't matter what you do everything goes. The latter tells you to be careful to think that what you know is certain.
- ugh 16y agoPostmodernism doesn’t seem to have any tools to decide between two statements, does it? Hence, everything still goes.
- _delirium 16y agoIt varies a lot depending on who you ask, and most postmodernists probably don't really have a theory of truth. Some really don't believe it's a meaningful concept, or even if they do, think it's epistemologically never accessible, so not worth bothering with. Some are open to coherence theories of truth, though, more or less that you can't decide whether something is "really" true, but you can decide if sets of beliefs are coherent with each other, within a particular culture's conception of coherence. That's actually not too different from coherence theories of truth that a lot of logicians hold, which is that "truth" is consistency relative to a formal system. Whether that turns into anything-goes seems to depend on just how arbitrary the choice of formal system is. A different direction is Richard Rorty trying to take some branch of postmodernism and weld it with early-20th-c. American pragmatism: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophy_and_the_Mirror_of_Nature http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophy_and_the_Mirror_of_Na...
- ubernostrum 16y agoAnd in one paragraph Dawkins shows that he has no understanding of postmodernism what so ever. So far as I'm concerned, no-one -- including everyone who's ever called themselves a postmodernist -- has any understanding of it. There's no "there" there, only a few trite remarks about absolutes and a race to see who can out-jargon, out-pigeonhole and out-frame whom. (all of which makes me incredibly glad that I earned my degree from a program which leaned heavily toward the analytic tradition; analytic philosophy has certainly had its big screwups, but A) it tends to be much more honest about itself and B) it still manages to occasionally produce useful results in spite of that)
- Qz 16y agoThere's no "there" there... What's funny is that is (in a way) exactly what post-modernism is talking about. There's no "there" there anywhere. "There" is a shifting frame of reference, gone before you finished contemplating it.
- Tycho 16y agoIt sort of makes sense to me within the domain of literary fiction. Mordernism was all about showing the cracks of the modern world - disintegration of institutions like religion, the damage done by WW1, differing-perspectives/unreliable-narrators, proliferation of media, abandoning rural life, etc. Modernist literature strained to show/express these cracks. Post-Modernist literature simply accepts them and works from there. But yeah 'what is Post-Modernism?' is one of those 'ahhh, ummm...' questions.
- Locke1689 16y agoI'd like to back your applause of analytic philosophy but would like to defend continental philosophy against postmodernism for a moment, as well. I think the prototypical example of dense prose in continental philosophy would be Heidegger, but at the same time I don't think that people would say that Sein und Zeit is gibberish. Now, many analytic philosophers (including myself) would probably agree that Sein und Zeit probably falls to the same psychoanalytic-assumption-as-truth that is categorical of existentialism but I definitely didn't have a problem seeing an argument from Heidegger. Simply, I just wanted to note that simply because a work appears dense or confusing doesn't mean that it is gibberish. Now, in the case of postmodernism, most of it happens to be both dense and gibberish.