19 ms·
Teenagers who read news online may be a criminals, according to the DoJ (2013)
- DarkKomunalec 9y ago"And it’s no excuse to say that the vast majority of these cases will never be prosecuted. As the Ninth Circuit explained, “Ubiquitous, seldom-prosecuted crimes invite arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement.” Instead of pursuing only suspects of actual crimes, it opens the door for prosecutors to go after people because the government doesn’t like them." This should be branded onto anyone that ever defended an overbroad law with 'It'll only be used to go after bad guys!'
- awkwarddaturtle 9y ago> This should be branded into anyone that ever defended an overbroad law with 'It'll only be used to go after bad guys!' Is it shocking to anyone else that there are so many comments like that on HN recently? "It'll only be used to go after bad guys!" or "If you don't have nothing to hide then you have nothing to worry about" or "I support free speech BUT ...". There is a surprising amount of pro-government and anti-free speech sentiment/comments lately.
- honestoHeminway 9y agoAs if a society, if things get bad- would not behave rationally? Almost, as if there was a war-mode, where we vote for erratical leaders, close the ranks, shut down all free communications, and would invade some neighbourhood until things are good again. Of course to accept the ugliness of reality and the finite ressource of reason- that would be a real blow to all those utopian daydreams. So never gonna happen.
- hellbanner 9y agoYou think they're pro-gov astroturfing? I interpreted their comment as the opposite..
- swiley 9y agoThis happens at the university I go to: wearing shorts is against the rules (being written up enough times for it can get you expelled) but no one cares because it's the students (RAs) that enforce it. So when people are mad at each other (or someone just likes wielding their power) other people end up hurt. "It's not enforced" is a terrible excuse for bad laws. Not that I like shorts, they're pretty ugly.
- strictnein 9y ago> Not that I like shorts, they're pretty ugly. Shorts are life.
- TylerH 9y agoWhat weird backward university is this that doesn't allow shorts?!
- bryanrasmussen 9y agoBrigham Young University maybe http://www.byui.edu/student-honor-office/ces-honor-code/dress-and-grooming http://www.byui.edu/student-honor-office/ces-honor-code/dres...
- dmoy 9y agoHuh not what I was told (though they ban most shorts you could reasonably buy at a store, especially for women, or something like that)
- bryanrasmussen 9y agowell the original poster said it was not enforced.
- dmoy 9y agoNot even BYU completely bans shorts (at least according to a disillusioned co-worker). Ok looks like Pensacola Christian College basically bans shorts.
- Chathamization 9y agoThis is a huge problem with the U.S. legal system. A lot of common behavior has been criminalized, to the point where most people could probably be pursued for something. There's a general shrug about this, followed by a "I doubt they'd actually go after you for that." But that ends up meaning that authorities can target an individual when they want to, and since this is often followed by throwing a lot of shade about the targeted individual people think it's justified.
- euyyn 9y agoWhat's an example of such common behavior?
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoLicense plates aren't exactly common on wood splitters, irrigation trenches, concrete mixers and other towable equipment that's small enough to be a two man lift but they're required. In some states it's a higher end misdemeanor to not have your papers in order when traveling on public roads. I know that's not something the typical urban/suburban HN visitor deals with on a daily basis but it happens.
- DarkKomunalec 9y agohttps://mic.com/articles/86797/8-ways-we-regularly-commit-felonies-without-realizing-it https://mic.com/articles/86797/8-ways-we-regularly-commit-fe... I wouldn't call any of those exactly 'common', but they're far from criminal.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIt doesn't have to be common or recent as long as a sufficient number of people are caught in the dragnet. These laws exist to only be used sparingly as needed. They're to be used as a surprise "gotcha" for someone that couldn't otherwise be "gotten" If prosecution under these sort of laws was overused they the laws would be changed. I'm not saying I agree with it.
- 9y ago
- toomanybeersies 9y agoRelevant quote I got from HN the other day: > To my friends, everything; to my enemies, the law > -Óscar R. Benavides
- cardamomo 9y agoThis is basically a re-write of this EFF post from 2013: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/04/are-you-teenager-who-reads-news-online-according-justice-department-you-may-be https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/04/are-you-teenager-who-r... Previous HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5486398 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5486398 EDIT: Someone has updated the original post. Yay!
- a_imho 9y agoIsn't everyone violating the CFAA [1] already? It is not clear whether a child is being prosecuted for this kind of specific tos violation. [1]http://blog.erratasec.com/2012/11/you-are-committing-crime-right-now.html http://blog.erratasec.com/2012/11/you-are-committing-crime-r...
- II2II 9y agoThe point is that one law means that the age restriction is a standard clause in most website's TOS, while another law makes it a felony for minors to access website because of that standard term of service. The combination of the two laws is what makes it different from violating the TOS due to a clause being inserted at the site owner's own volition.
- phkahler 9y agoIf violating a web sites terms of service is a felony, then the government has delegated authority in defining felonies to every web site operator. That is not appropriate. This goes back to the old problem of identity. If people were identifiable on the internet then web sites could easily blacklist or whitelist users and no rely on ToS for things like this.
- gasof 9y ago... or they could end up still using a ToS; you think Facebook would give up getting licensed to do everything they do with your data? However, they'd now be able to prosecute you much more effectively (in the case of IRL/state-backed identities).
- ttflee 9y agohttps://www.xkcd.com/501/ https://www.xkcd.com/501/
- mtl_usr 9y agoI was once called "snobbish" because I used the term " transitive" while discussing a similar issue with non-technical people in the legal field. If only the legislator understood technology instead of simply using the "everything is a contract" and the "website is like a house people can break into" (failed) analogies.
- rayiner 9y agoThe CFAA is a clusterfuck that has generated splits among the federal appellate courts on what it means. The Second Circuit, adopting a narrow interpretation of what "exceeds authorized access" means, put it well: https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=11783993212131547013&q=807+F.3d+508&hl=en&as_sdt=20006 https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=117839932121315... ("Where, as here, ordinary tools of legislative construction fail to establish that the Government's position is unambiguously correct, we are required by the rule of lenity to adopt the interpretation that favors the defendant. Santos, 553 U.S. at 514, 128 S.Ct. 2020; United States v. Granderson, 511 U.S. 39, 54, 114 S.Ct. 1259, 127 L.Ed.2d 611 (1994). We do not think it too much to ask that Congress define criminal conduct with precision and clarity."). Can't give the DOJ a pass here either. Prosecutors should not be pushing the boundaries of creative legal theories; that's for defense lawyers.
- throwanem 9y agoThis comes out of the Lori Drew case. For those unaware, Lori Drew, a grown-ass woman, recruited accomplices into a weaponized catfishing campaign that drove a 13-year-old to suicide. That's apparently not a crime, or so I gather a federal district court has ruled. I'm not sure I would want one to rule differently - there are subtle and trepidatious ramifications here, and the social norms of online behavior are as yet very ill defined. But this isn't the hill I'd choose to die on.
- hellbanner 9y agoRelated (also frontpage): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14891301 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14891301
- interfixus 9y ago>In the DOJ’s world, this means anyone under 18 who reads a Hearst newspaper online could hypothetically face jail time Jail time? What is it with this American propensity for locking up more or less everybody? As seen from the other site of the pond, it does at times sort of beggar belief.
- cr0sh 9y agoMany prisons in the US are privately operated (Corrections Corporation of America is one of the large companies that run private prisons). These companies then sell certain services to the public - such as telemarketing (seriously). In other words, that person you're talking to in a telemarketing context may very well be a prisoner in a CCA owned facility! Now - prisoners aren't forced (?) to participate in these activities, but they are highly encouraged; it gives them a bit of money for the commissary (very small bit) and other things, plus gives them "job skills" for the outside, and probably also a mark on their records for later parole review purposes ("hey, she participated in this, and became a model "employee" as a telemarketer - let's factor that into her record for an early release"). So - there is a strong incentive to participate in these programs. They aren't limited to telemarketing either: If you can think of something which can be done by low-skilled workers who are a "captive audience" so to speak, it is probably sold as a service by these private prison companies to other businesses. For instance, another big one is "product assembly" (putting furniture together, or electronics, or other similar work). So - these companies - the private prisons - need more employees, right? You know, to sell their services. These employees are very cheap (and easy to coerce to work - after all, they are also prisoners!): Just pay lowest-bidder for food and housing, then get 'em inside. Best way to do that is to lobby for more restrictive laws, make more things felonies, etc... Right? Understand? Kinda sounds like a form of indentured servitude, or corporate prison slavery, right? Maybe because it is...? Because that's how it really is here in the "Land of the Free! (tm)(c)(r)". /USA! USA!, MAGA!, and all that crap...
- scaryspooky 9y agoPrivate prisons have 7% state and 18% federal of the total population. Blaming private prisons for the problems of US corrections as a whole is disingenuous. https://www.aclu.org/issues/mass-incarceration/privatization-criminal-justice/private-prisons https://www.aclu.org/issues/mass-incarceration/privatization...