4 ms·
Can you give an example of a monopoly that lasted for more than a few years (say, a decade) without State intervention?
by icebraining 9y ago
Can you give an example of a monopoly that lasted for more than a few years (say, a decade) without State intervention?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoDeBeers until recently? Monsanto? I think neither relied on direct state intervention. As for whether or not state enables monopolies, it's important to notice that market and governance are not, and can never be, disconnected. If you're big enough, you write your own rules.
- pitaj 9y agoMonsanto is certainly not a monopoly, and their very existence as a large player is kept alive by state-enforced intellectual property.
- rtpg 9y agoStandard Oil? Microsoft? Though these companies ended up getting split up. We didn't make anti-trust laws out of the goodness of our hearts but because doing nothing created monopolies.
- afsina 9y agoOn Standard Oil: https://mises.org/library/100-years-myths-about-standard-oil https://mises.org/library/100-years-myths-about-standard-oil
- icebraining 9y agoMicrosoft is built on State-granted monopolies, like patents.
- rtpg 9y agoPatents? Maybe I'd understand if you were talking about IP law (in which case we're too far apart) but to my knowledge patent threats were not really the tool of MSFT in the 90s. Instead they would opt for more classic techniques like threatening resellers by withholding access to their products.
- icebraining 9y agoThe MSFT in the 90s didn't have a monopoly that had lasted for a decade. My point is not that companies can't achieve market dominance, but that it's almost always short-lived - unless they have the power of the State propping them up. Like the multiple patents that MS got during the 90s, and which have extended until this day.
- Spooky23 9y agoThe best place to observe this is in local property markets. Many central business districts and other urban areas are dominated by a cartel of property companies. Some of these little monopolies are very localized but drive the values of heir neighbors and inhibit growth. Documentation of this stuff is fuzzy for various reasons, many properties are difficult to trace ownership of due to tax and liability concerns. One well known example would be Columbia University in New York City. They own like 25% of Morningside Heights and at least 200 properties in total.
- icebraining 9y agoAccording to various news articles, Morningside Heights prices have risen less than other Manhattan boroughs, and there's plenty of new construction happening, which residents are trying to use State powers to prevent[1]. I can see why finding who owns stuff might be difficult, but the effects should be easier to detect; do you have any examples of districts and urban areas with rising prices and very little or no growth, despite a lack of ordinances and other regulations preventing it? [1] https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20160411/morningside-heights/community-rallies-curb-size-of-proposed-morningside-heights-tower https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20160411/morningside-height...
- Spooky23 9y agoMy hometown, Albany, NY. Many small/midsize cities are similar. Inner city rents are similar to the suburban developments and until recently higher than mortgage payments. The top 5 landlords control 30-50% of the market and own whole blocks at various times.