11 ms·
Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO
- thaumasiotes 9y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-07-28/libor-phone-smashing-and-hacking https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-07-28/libor-pho... is vindicated! > Who will be the next chief executive officer of Uber Technologies Inc.? The shortlist includes "fewer than six candidates," and they seem to be pretty big names: Meg Whitman of Hewlett Packard Enterprise Co. has turned Uber down, and Jeffrey Immelt of General Electric Co. is in the running. It is hard to know how attractive an opportunity Uber is for someone who has already run a much bigger and more profitable public company, and you could imagine a lot of quick "no's" from that list. I hope it's like "Meg Whitman, Jeffrey Immelt, Jeff Bezos, Barack Obama and ... wait ... Travis Kalanick ... how'd he get on this list?"
- sschueller 9y agoThey might as well re-phrase the question to "Who wants to go the prison?" :)
- kartD 9y agoPossibly the most incompetent board of directors in the past decade. Can't reign Travis in, couldn't avoid all of this by forcing Travis to get an adult COO like Sandberg, fire him after he takes a break to mourn his moms death. They should all resign as well. A boards job is to reign in the CEO's bad tendencies. Really what have any of them accomplished by being on the board? Is there anything they can point to? And on top of all of that, their busy leaking news instead of picking a CEO...
- sebleon 9y ago> Really what have any of them accomplished by being on the board? They provided high-level guidance of a company that went from non-existent to $70Bn valuation in 7 years. I'd be very curious to know what boards you approve of.
- icebraining 9y agoAren't most board members the same people who decided on that valuation, ie, the investors?
- throw2016 9y agoThe same can be said of Travis if not more yet he is out. So why should the board remain?
- kgwgk 9y agoBecause the shareholders have not decided otherwise.
- kgwgk 9y agoI don't usually argue with downvotes, but I'm going to make an exception. The board decided that a change of CEO was requiered. Who has the power to decide a change in the board is required? HN commenters?
- calbear81 9y agoThe shareholders who in this case are represented by the board members. In a public company, an activist investor can bring the votes and force a change in the board. Similarly, a majority investor could technically sway board members to vote out another member (as long as it's allowed in the bylaws)
- kgwgk 9y agoThat was exactly my point. This piece by Matt Levine is relevant (https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-04-24/board-votes-and-performance-reviews https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-04-24/board-vot...): "On the other hand, you know, the buck has to stop somewhere. But where? The CEO is an obvious answer, and he is gone, but the buck is still moving. It might get the board. What's next? Should the shareholders fire themselves, for failing to catch the problem in time? There is a traditional model in which the board of directors represents the shareholders: When management messes up, the board gets angry on behalf of the shareholders; their dudgeon becomes its dudgeon. The modern model is increasingly that the board is identified with management: When management messes up, the shareholders get angry at the board; their dudgeon turns against the board. The modern model might be more accurate in describing the relationship between many boards and managements. But you want a balance between dudgeon and continuity. If the managers mess up and the board gets rid of them, it can demand that the new managers fix the problem, and hold them accountable for doing it. But if you get rid of the board too, then who stays around to make sure the problem gets fixed?"
- dalbasal 9y agoI guess the question is, what kind of competencies would one expect to find in a board. Board seats are typically filled by "money people." I think most boards have a good understanding of accounting, investment, fundraising... If they have founders, employees or specifically recruited outside managers they might have a good understanding of product or market strategies. But, managing crisis like this? In principle, boards can remove and replace CEOs but this is such a rare occurrence. There's no lower stakes equivalent to it. They don't have to remove and replace more junior managers. Competencies in an area you never touch on... in a scenario most board members have never seen... it would be a kind of fluke if they happened to be competent at this sort of task.
- DanBC 9y ago> I guess the question is, what kind of competencies would one expect to find in a board I've been looking into this in the context of English NHS Trusts. Here are a few things I've found useful. https://nhsproviders.org/media/1057/we-need-to-talk-about-boards-boards-leadership-and-the-nhs.pdf https://nhsproviders.org/media/1057/we-need-to-talk-about-bo... https://www.leadershipacademy.nhs.uk/resources/healthy-nhs-board/ https://www.leadershipacademy.nhs.uk/resources/healthy-nhs-b... Effective challenge on a unitary board: http://www.frontline-consultants.com/announcements/effective-challenge-on-a-unitary-board http://www.frontline-consultants.com/announcements/effective... There was quite a lot of work in the UK about effective boards after the Guinness scandal, among others.
- mathattack 9y agoFor better or worse, they accepted investments with limited power to influence the company.
- malandrew 9y agoIncompetence is ousting the CEO that grew a company to $70B with no succession plan. FWIW, the only two boardmembers involved in the ousting were Benchmark and TPG. Let this be a warning to anyone ever considering either for a board seat.
- InternetUser 9y ago> A boards job is to reign in the CEO's bad tendencies. A board's job is to rein in the CEO's bad tendencies.
- lettergram 9y agoI don't really understand why the author of the article is worried about the CEO not being a woman... Seriously, who cares? It's not going to look good for who ever takes over and there are a lot less woman candidates. Uber will be lucky if it makes it to 2019 IMO. Would give them 6 months, but half the valley invested in them.
- AJRF 9y agoKara Swisher writes "Ew" in news articles. Her work is devoid of substance and just pushes an agenda that is populist and will get her likes from the largest group of people on Twitter
- n72 9y agoYup, this doesn't contain any quotes from well placed sources or anything like that nor delivers any new information about, say, Meg Whitman's candidacy. Totally devoid of merit.
- malandrew 9y agoThere is no better evidence of her bias against Travis and Uber than how she conducted herself in her interview with Adam Lashinsky. Here's the full transcript: https://www.recode.net/2017/7/16/15980006/transcript-journalist-author-adam-lashinsky-book-uber-wild-ride-live-onstage-recode-decode https://www.recode.net/2017/7/16/15980006/transcript-journal... She isn't a journalist. She's an activist pushing an agenda, facts-be-damned. Long gone are the day's of Walter Cronkite's "And that's the way it is."
- theseatoms 9y agoThis is a much broader trend in contemporary media. The line between news and editorial has been all but erased.
- malandrew 9y agoYes, I agree. However, it's one thing to occasionally give an opinion in the course of practicing journalism and something entirely different to steer the conversation towards the message you're trying to push. Kara wasn't even subtle about it this interview. Her bias was not just showing, but on full display for all to see. It's really unfortunate because the individuals in the general population don't really get the facts and an opportunity to each come to slightly different conclusions. It's journalist malpractice to tell people what to think, since that's not journalism. That's propaganda.
- whbk 9y agoI'm shocked, shocked I tell you, that a guy that founded a massive company and drove it to unparalleled success only to be forced out while in the early stages of mourning his mother's unexpected death (and caring for his severely injured father) has not gone quietly into the night. I think the passenger rape records issue was the straw that broke the camel's back and he had to go, but I don't think it needed to be done the way it was. Sure, there's a decent argument that he only has one speed and would be meddling regardless (as he supposedly was while he was supposed to be "on leave"), but doing it the way they did made Travis lashing out once he'd had a bit of time to process it an absolute 100% certainty.
- wavefunction 9y agoYou're completely eliding all the scandals and scummy behavior by various members of Uber under his watch. And while I sympathize with what his family is facing in their personal tragedy, that it occurred at the same time those various scandals came to a head is merely a coincidence in timing, if an unfortunate one for Kalanick.
- whbk 9y agoCheck the first sentence of the 2nd paragraph - I agree that he needed to be replaced due to the multitude of issues. I just think the execution of it was very poor coming within a week of his mother's death. Remember, he was already "on leave" - whether he was honoring it or not. By public accounts, he wasn't. So the board said "ok, he's not going to change, let's remove him." My argument is they should've given him a couple weeks and then sat him down and had the "the well has broken, we need a new face for the good of the company, please support this" talk. Instead, they blindsided him at a hotel that he'd flown to halfway across the country to try to help the company (recruiting a COO) while his father's still severely injured. Had they done it in a more humane way, they might have been able to secure more cooperation in the long-term, and they could've begun to quietly get their ducks in a row during that 2-3 week grace period before giving him the ultimatum. Instead, they executed it at a moment of maximum weakness for him, which got the job done in the moment but set themselves up for him to go scorched earth in the long-term, undermining the whole exercise. Again, I do think they needed to fire him, but they'd bought a bit of time with him "going on leave" and I think it might have been more effective had they leveraged it rather than going for the immediate KO. Perhaps we would've ended up here regardless, but maybe not.
- Animats 9y agoIt's a tough problem. Uber's success is due to the CEO being an asshole. Yet that's become a problem. How about Peter Thiel? He's a strong enough personality for the job. He's gay, so the women at Uber don't have to worry. Thiel was at one time talked about for a job in the Trump Administration, but that's now a worse option than running Uber. He's on a few boards and nominally runs a not-very-successful hedge fund [1], so he's more or less available. [1] https://www.quora.com/What-went-wrong-with-Peter-Thiels-hedge-fund-Clarium-Capital https://www.quora.com/What-went-wrong-with-Peter-Thiels-hedg...
- diN0bot 9y ago(a) we don't know that uber's success is due to travis being an asshole. could simply be an (unfortunate) correlation. (b) "He's gay, so the women at Uber don't have to worry." wtf? being gay is orthogonal to being a misogynist, much less preventing organizational misogyny.
- fastball 9y agoI don't think I've ever met a gay misogynist, much less heard of one.
- Grue3 9y agoMilo Yiannopoulos?
- fastball 9y agoI must admit I'm only vaguely aware of him. Which of his stances are misogynistic?
- kgwgk 9y agoNot such a strange concept. I have no opinion on the subject, but other people do: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/men/thinking-man/the-gay-community-needs-to-deal-with-its-misogyny-problem/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/men/thinking-man/the-gay-communit... https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/nov/06/misogyny-gay-men-sexist-rose-mcgowan-rights-women?CMP=fb_gu https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/nov/06/misogy...
- martinmusio7 9y agoThis happens when people can't communicate enough.
- surfmike 9y agoI'm still surprised that I never see Robin Chase's name floated. She's a successful serial transportation entrepreneur, and even wrote an op-ed outlining a vision for Uber post-Travis: https://www.google.de/amp/s/www.wired.com/story/what-ubers-next-ceo-needs-to-say/amp https://www.google.de/amp/s/www.wired.com/story/what-ubers-n...
- whbk 9y agoDecent chance she wanted the job (and penned the op-ed with that in mind), but the feeling wasn't mutual.
- basseq 9y agoI would doubt Uber's board wants a "serial entrepreneur". Uber is going to be a $12-15B (revs) company this year, potentially with an impending IPO. That's two orders of magnitude larger than Robin Chase's experience at ZipCar. I would bet they're looking for someone with experience at (growing) companies in the $15-30B range, probably from a logistics-centric industry.
- geofft 9y agoNon-AMP link because it's faster: https://www.wired.com/story/what-ubers-next-ceo-needs-to-say https://www.wired.com/story/what-ubers-next-ceo-needs-to-say
- elmar 9y agoWHAT UBER'S NEXT CEO NEEDS TO SAY by Robin Chase https://www.wired.com/story/what-ubers-next-ceo-needs-to-say/ https://www.wired.com/story/what-ubers-next-ceo-needs-to-say... BTW Robin Chase is probably a great candidate to be CEO of Uber.
- fil_a_del_fee_a 9y agoI stopped reading after "The Trump administration, right?".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- miheermunjal 9y agoworst part is, the BoD can't seem to decide on enough strategy to sustain the momentum Uber has built up. It's more in their incentive to pick someone short-term to get through IPO-ing to some degree, than you can be sustained by the public market if nothing else.
- redm 9y agoIt's a nice article that summarizes the current turmoil of Uber well if it's all accurate. I don't understand the need to make the article political thought with the references to Trump and Anthony Scaramucci, there's just no relevance.
- Sacho 9y agoI don't think the mention of Trump was political - it's undisputed that his presidency has been plagued by leaks so far. The mention of Scaramucci seems to be closer, I don't understand the relevance of it.
- AmericanOP 9y agoNone of you have any idea what travis offered on a personal level or did on a daily basis in the fight to build a brand and open new markets. No cohesion here either, just more twitter zeitgeist groupthink.
- pcsanwald 9y agoThere isn't an interim CEO and the company is currently managed by committee. The board is waffling around and doesn't seem committed to finding a replacement, even interim. I'd say that Travis K isn't the only one planning a Travis K comeback.