4 ms·
I think that the core concept of the article is somewhat misplaced. What used to sell WhatsApp and other IMs wasn't privacy, it was SMS at no cost and without
by pmontra 9y ago
I think that the core concept of the article is somewhat misplaced.
What used to sell WhatsApp and other IMs wasn't privacy, it was SMS at no cost and without limits. Then came the better UI, emoticons, group chats and network effects.
Only few people understand the privacy differences with SMS. Proof: how many security codes did you verify compared to the number of your active contacts?
About Twitter, its growth is limited not because of privacy concerns but because everybody understands that it's a public chat. Privacy is not even in the equation, nobody expects it so nobody is concerned about it. It's really down to the I don't have anything to say in public thing. People have a lot to say to friends but little to strangers. Not everybody is a blogger or has to send press releases, and even them, maybe only in their working persona.
To recap. Not only it's comparing apples to oranges (the post acknowledge that) but privacy is not a factor in both IMs and Twitter, unless you think that parents' advice "do not talk to strangers" is about privacy.
- pessimizer 9y ago> What used to sell WhatsApp and other IMs wasn't privacy, it was SMS at no cost and without limits. I disagree. I'm pretty sure having to pay extra for SMS and limits on the number of messages were things of the distant past before WhatsApp started.
- 1_player 9y agoNot sure where you're located but here in the UK (or Italy) SMS are not free, unless you have a mobile plan and/or you're texting someone on the same network. Good luck if you're texting someone in another country. That's why (almost) everybody in Europe uses WhatsApp. I use SMS _only_ to receive 2FA codes.
- sametmax 9y agoNot in France. SMS are free and unlimited on all providers, across all providers.
- rotorblade 9y ago"free" is a bit misleading, imo. If you pay for a monthly subscription, then... yes, but really no (although this might be beside the point you make). And Pay-as-you-go cards are also a thing, where it is certainly not true (although such cards have been made borderline completely useless with the new idiotically formulated 'roaming free' EU rules).
- Markoff 9y agowhy are prepaid cards useless thanks to roaming? i don't see relation there, i use prepaid card and i am lot in roaming
- rotorblade 9y agoThey added a clause in the law in which the service providers are allowed to sell prepaid cards with roaming disabled completely. Several (in Sweden all but one, France at least the one I'm using) service providers chose this option for their prepaid. The why is quite obvious, instead of upping the price on the per-minute/-sms charges on prepaid, they disabled it to force you to buy a monthly subscription instead. For me, this means that my phone does not work anywhere in EU anymore except Sweden and France (and I have two SIMs) unless I increase my phone spending with about 2000% (yes, I do not use my phone much), I cannot change the contracts because I cannot live in two countries at once [#], and will most likely lose the number I have had for over 20 years. Even so, if I change to a monthly subscription they are allowed to cancel my contract if I "misuse" the new roaming rules, which I will because I want to keep my Swedish number but I will not live there for several more years (at least). The new roaming rules only helps tourists (although I believe that the monthly fees have gone up all over EU since the transition to "roaming free" rules, so only the service providers are gaining anything on the transition). For people who have to be mobile across the EU it is a total nightmare. This has made me very angry (perhaps unproportionately so), and it is my opinion that the EU MPs that put forth this law should be ashamed and this is a complete failure. [#] I can change it in France, since I live here, but I'm moving away from here soon, so why bother, but not to Sweden. So I have to break some country's law by saying I move back to Sweden when I don't, change my contract, move to where I actually am, and then lose my number anyway at 1000% the cost of my old card. And when I move, since this is not to France nor Sweden, but still in the EU, my phone will not work at all moving there! All things you have to do when moving to a new country I have to manage without a phone now.
- pitzips 9y agoI hadn't heard of WhatsApp for years being in the USA. You are right that in the states texting was free much earlier. It spread like fire with Europeans being able to text across countries. Texting was free within country, but between was expensive.
- pmontra 9y agoNot free, even now. There are plans with a limited number of messages per month (100 to 1000). The teenager children of my friends used up them in no time. Then came WhatsApp, Messenger, Snapchat. Messaging inside the EU costs as much as messaging inside one's own country now but this is very recent. Messaging between other countries can cost up to 2 Euro per message. Not a typo. One wonders if it is to empty people accounts. I put my phone in airplane mode whenever I'm outside the EU and use Wi-Fi to call and text.