4 ms·
Something is old so now you can’t own it? Does a 40 year old house suddenly become public domain just because people like to visit? If you made something, you a
by briandear 9y ago
Something is old so now you can’t own it? Does a 40 year old house suddenly become public domain just because people like to visit? If you made something, you and your heirs have a right to that, it doesn’t just get confiscated because it’s popular. Some of Bob Dylan’s songs are over 50 years old; does that mean he shouldn’t own the stuff he created? That is just theft. Nobody has a “right” to anything I create unless I say so.
- cookiecaper 9y agoThat is not how intellectual goods work. They require their own class of property laws called "intellectual property" precisely because they are different from real property. Real property provides the basic needs of human life, and any single parcel or space can only be occupied or used by a single entity at a time. It exists in time and space as a physical good. Persons and families are entitled to protect this property, with force if necessary, because they depend on it for their ongoing maintenance and habitation. Real property laws provide structure to our approach to real property so that we can live in a neighborly civilization instead of a smattering of independent militarized tribes. Intellectual property, on the other hand, exists in an abstract, non-physical space. The same intellectual content can exist with perfect fidelity in an unlimited number of minds, and because intellectual goods are not subject to physical laws of space and time, they can be shared and utilized fully and simultaneously by everyone capable of processing and storing them. This free-flowing nature makes intellectual goods extremely powerful, but it also gives them limited economic utility, because the supply is very hard to constrain. This was true in the past, and it's 1000x truer with the advent of the internet, which allows us to transfer intellectual goods practically anywhere in the world perfectly, exactly, and instantaneously. Now you don't even need to stay on good terms with the neighborhood sage for access to the treasure trove of intellectual goods! Disembodied intellectual goods are useful, but they are not necessary for survival, and thus it is rarely if ever justified to use force in the "defense" of them. This is very different from real property, which must be reserved and defended to ensure survival. To the extent that we do decide to use force to "defend" such goods, we should tread lightly. The analog to real property is very weak indeed. Copyright essentially injects the government as a middleman into a voluntary and free market transaction, and says "I know you THINK you want that, but we aren't going to allow you to buy it from him, because we say someone else deserves the money more than him". Such interjections are another area where we should tread very lightly, and in recent decades, we have done anything but. Our current iteration of copyright-gone-amok constrains our speech and does a great deal of damage that no one with an audience is willing to talk about, because they're all too busy enjoying the money stream from it to comment on its destructive consequences.
- flycaliguy 9y agoLanguage like "perfect fidelity in an unlimited number of minds" just doesn't add up in my head. Nobody can reproduce the sound of a recording in their mind without listening to a tape/record/cd/file of it. How is your speech being constrained by a record label anyways? A recording of a performance belongs to the creators of that recording. You don't have the right to reproduce it without paying them. That's that. It has nothing to do with your speech and everything to do with people in the entertainment industry getting paid for their work.
- fnord123 9y agoSongs aren't physical things; they are ideas. And you cannot own ideas. Allowing people to own it in the first place was a compromise by the commons so people could make some money from creating things by owning it for a short time. The copyright extensions have stolen these ideas from the commons.
- flycaliguy 9y agoA song in this context is not an "idea". They are a recording made by skilled technicians of a performance by skilled musicians. Creating a recording of a song that people want to listen to requires a lot of professionals who deserve compensation.
- mcguire 9y agoMany people deserve many things. The world, unfortunately, does not give everyone what they deserve.
- flycaliguy 9y agoThankfully society gave the world a legal system. Now when a business distributes music belonging to another business, compensation through the courts can be pursued in cases of piracy.
- mcguire 9y agoWhen should we expect the legal system to redress all of the other deserving, injured parties?
- flycaliguy 9y agoPlease be more specific of their need and I'll do my best to twist an answer around. In the mean time, I'll continue to feed my family using the modest wage I make mastering records that so many people think are just magic ideas that float in the air with no value.