5 ms·
"Musk’s visions are valuable because they show that even people far outside the field of urban planning can be frustrated with the world others have built for u
by mcguire 9y ago
"Musk’s visions are valuable because they show that even people far outside the field of urban planning can be frustrated with the world others have built for us. They, too, should have a say."
That is a good point. Taking Musk and the HyperLoop seriously is a mistake---unless something has changed that hasn't percolate down to me, it has major problems and probably wouldn't solve the problem it purports to solve in the same way the Concord never revolutionized air travel---but it is a valid criticism of the state of things.
On the other hand, if you take it seriously, it distracts attention from actual solutions.
- puranjay 9y agoThe problem with not taking Musk seriously is that his track records shows you can, indeed, take him seriously. His company made a rocket capable of re-entry ffs
- mamon 9y agoAs someone else in this thread noticed: so far all Musk did was incremental improvements to existing technologies (electric cars, autopilot, space rockets). He has no track of record of actually creating a new technology.
- jacquesm 9y agoExcept that the established players in those markets did not manage to do any of that stuff. Not a huge Musk fan but still let's give credit where credit is due. I see people that have built two web apps call themselves serial entrepreneur, I think Musk is actually worthy of that title and so far he did deliver the goods.
- mamon 9y agoOk, so he is a great entrepreneur: knows how to run the company to be profitable, low cost, high revenue, knows how to advertise, how to make a lot of hype. Those are great skills, but have nothing to do with technology. There are many companies that are better at creating new, disrupting technologies: Google with all of its AI research and Android, Amazon with a cloud platform, even Microsoft with Windows and Office was more disruptive than Tesla or SpaceX will ever be.
- jacquesm 9y agoYes, but you should compare SpaceX with other space entities and Tesla with other car manufacturers. Apples to apples. Comparing Tesla or SpaceX with Google, Amazon or Microsoft is pointless, they are in completely different fields.
- mamon 9y agoBut the point is: both Tesla and SpaceX already had their respective fields, with established players that proved the whole thing at least possible despite being far from perfection. Google or Amazon pioneered completely new fields, something that Musk is just now trying to do with Hyperloop
- jacquesm 9y ago> But the point is: both Tesla and SpaceX already had their respective fields, with established players that proved the whole thing at least possible despite being far from perfection. It is super hard to make something entirely new in an established field. > Google or Amazon pioneered completely new fields, something that Musk is just now trying to do with Hyperloop Google did not pioneer the search engine, Amazon did not pioneer e-commerce.
- Retra 9y agoHow is Hyperloop a new field? It's in the same field as high-speed trains, as it competes directly with them.
- erikpukinskis 9y ago> established players that proved the whole thing at least possible Who landed an orbital booster before SpaceX?
- ClassyJacket 9y agoHow can you possibly call Tesla not disruptive? They're a shining example of a disruptive company. They're turning the automotive industry on its head. No other company has made any comparable, widespread, viable attempt at a good electric car.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mcguire 9y agoA good point. On the other hand, NASA did make a man-rated reusable spacecraft, back in the '70s, while dealing with a huge pile of political horseshit. (This is sort of a Fred Astaire/Ginger Rogers moment.)