4 ms·
[random advice from the internet] I think the idea is interesting and the execution seems well done. Because, I don't want to log in with Facebook to save, I c
by brudgers 9y ago
[random advice from the internet]
I think the idea is interesting and the execution seems well done. Because, I don't want to log in with Facebook to save, I can't see the end result and ultimately have no idea whether or not it is actually any good. So I will probably never use it, and almost certainly never recommend it (since I have no idea if at the end of the road Time.graphics is actually any good.
From a business standpoint:
What is the business value of a visitor's Facebook login?
What is the business value of providing accurate
knowledge of the *final* product to a visitor?
What business problem does obtaining a visitor's Facebook
login directly solve right now, here in the context
of a 'Show HN'?
Years ago I tried selling software and my strategy was simple. I made a free demo version that showed what could be done and provided a lousy high level functional experience (i.e. it could not be used for actual work) so that people would buy it. I don't think people tend to buy software that leaves them with a bad taste in their mouth. I don't think time spent building tooling that makes the demo lousy is time well spent.
At any size it makes sense to understand potential users. At a certain size it probably makes sense to use Facebook as a tool to aggregate data. When there are only a couple of hundred or ten or one, then it is better view them individually. Ask them, "Am I solving your problem?"
Good luck.
- fiatjaf 9y agoThere's an email + password login right below the Facebook login. But yes, a demo seems like a good idea, if it is not too hard.
- Jenkam 9y agoI don't understand what you mean. What demo?
- brudgers 9y agoProviding an email address is not part of my 'timeline problem' I am trying to solve. Not providing an email address (or Facebook login) is part of another problem that I have been trying to solve for years. That's not to say that providing an email address or a Facebook login is always too high a price. But here there is no significant benefit to providing it and a reasonable probability of detriment based on my experience. Going further, there is no functional reason for requiring a login. Because the login sits in front of all the value on my end and there's not really anything good that can come from providing that information, I am inclined to assign a higher probability to their being a bad outcome. To be clear, I am writing all this in the context of providing "Show HN" feedback. The login seems like clicking a checkbox on the checklist of "startup best practices" sitting in Github repository. Collecting emails and Facebook logins is easier than listening to users. Emails and Facebook provide ways of telling rather than listening.
- fiatjaf 9y agoI think I understand what you're saying, but have you considered that user accounts exist not only for putting email addresses in a mailing list? Anyway, what would you suggest?
- brudgers 9y agoMy suggestion is to ignore login until there is a functional reason. Today, people landing on the page is pure gold. The important functional information is how they use the product. Sure, user accounts can exist for many reasons. Right now, there is no evidence that for this site right now the reasons are for my benefit. That's not to say in the wider world there are not people who would benefit from persistent identity in regard to a timeline making site. It is even possible that I might benefit from establishing a persistent identity, but there's no statement of a value proposition as to why nor do the possible reasons seem more likely than the idea that persistent identity is not for my benefit, and hence Occam's razor. Perhaps the reason is to use Facebook/email is to build Hacker News for timelines. Great, that's functional..once there is a social space, not now. If the login is to pitch an investor by showing uniques traction, it's non-functional.
- Jenkam 9y agoYou can create a timeline without log it but if you want to save it, so..