3 ms·
> The colorable, divisible infinite sets in RT22 are abstractions that have no analogue in the real world. And yet, Yokoyama and Patey’s proof shows that mathem
by vanderZwan 9y ago
> The colorable, divisible infinite sets in RT22 are abstractions that have no analogue in the real world. And yet, Yokoyama and Patey’s proof shows that mathematicians are free to use this infinite apparatus to prove statements in finitistic mathematics — including the rules of numbers and arithmetic, which arguably underlie all the math that is required in science — without fear that the resulting theorems rest upon the logically shaky notion of infinity. That’s because all the finitistic consequences of RT22 are “true” with or without infinity; they are guaranteed to be provable in some other, purely finitistic way. RT22’s infinite structures “may make the proof easier to find,” explained Slaman, “but in the end you didn’t need them. You could give a kind of native proof — a [finitistic] proof.”
I'm not a mathematician, but this sounds a lot like proof by induction VS proof by anything except induction.
- vanderZwan 9y agoMaybe I should have clarified. I recall being taught induction in my first year of physics, but the maths professor told us that it is generally frowned upon as a proof because it does not give any insight. So if there is a choice between two proofs, the other option is almost always more useful. This last sentence sounds a lot like that: > RT22’s infinite structures “may make the proof easier to find,” explained Slaman, “but in the end you didn’t need them. You could give a kind of native proof — a [finitistic] proof.”