4 ms·
Doesn't it seem though that politics is a deadlock, with nations playing a game of chicken that has no winner? It's a case of the tragedy of the commons. No p
by colordrops 9y ago
Doesn't it seem though that politics is a deadlock, with nations playing a game of chicken that has no winner? It's a case of the tragedy of the commons. No power broker is going to sacrifice their economy or political backers enough to make a difference, as there would always be someone else with a more short term view take advantage of their temporary weakness.
It seems that there is no feasible solution other than technical, however unlikely a technical solution is.
- yulaow 9y agoThe problem is that the economical background of our society is based on exploiting all resources and pushing the limits of the society itself (both with high reproduction rates and in mass production of goods). If we want to change the climate situation, we first need to change the whole economic system and related political measures.
- colordrops 9y agoI agree with you, but my point is that is impossible, because of said power brokers not willing to risk their power.
- evanlivingston 9y agoIf history relied on those in power giving up their power, rather than people taking power away from them, we would be living in a very different world. Political vs. technological is a false dichotomy. There are many other dimensions to the world. Personally, I think we need a monumental social breakthrough akin to the enlightenment to solve climate change.
- colordrops 9y agoBut people don't rebel until some force was clearly threatening their survival. If people rebel only when their immediate survival is threatened by global warming, it will already be too late.
- guscost 9y agoSpeaking more as an engineer than as a contrarian here: If that's your plan, you're going to fail at it.
- freshhawk 9y agoThat's definitely what Kings used to say. And chieftains of hunter/gatherer tribes before them.
- dane-pgp 9y agoWhen you say "our society is based on ... high reproduction rates", which society are you talking about, and which reproduction rates? Currently most of humanity has less than replacement level of fertility: http://www.economist.com/node/14743589 http://www.economist.com/node/14743589 Are you saying that the economy is failing because of low reproduction rates?
- lumberjack 9y agoThe Paris Agreement was an attempt at fixing that problem. I think it's still the way forward.
- sgc 9y agoNo it wasn't. It was an attempt to start thinking about the problem. Everyone knows it is completely insufficient. I agree that we need it, even dearly, but we do need to focus on creating easier and more commercially advantageous solutions to reduce the amount of force (political or otherwise) required to implement an effective solution. Otherwise, frankly, forget it. People are going to be kicking and screaming against it and we just don't have the time for their bs. So studies like these are also insufficient, but in my opinion one of the more important aspects of moving forward with just getting this done rather than talking about it.
- melling 9y agoThe Drawdown looks like it’s trying to help the policy makers on how to effectively reduce CO2. Different countries are making different decisions that work for them. I’m not sure why someone is complaining about this book. It seems like it would quite helpful. The Paris Agreement, for example, lets countries decide what’s best for them. For instance, according to the site, onshore wind turbines appear to be one of the better solutions for generating electricity. 84.6 GIGATONS REDUCED CO2 $1.23 TRILLION NET IMPLEMENTATION COST $7.43 TRILLION NET OPERATIONAL SAVINGS
- freshhawk 9y agoYou are right, but only if you discount the more extreme solutions to those tragedy of the commons/power broker problems. There is a historically effective solution to those problems, the one we all hate to think about, that has a high likelihood of failure, causes massive amounts of suffering and has multi-generation length unintended consequences: violence.
- colordrops 9y agoAs I mentioned in another comment, by the time it is clear to the common person that their immediate suffering is due to climate change that could have been prevented by political means, it will have been too late. Mass uprisings typically do not overthrow governments until immediate survival is threatened.
- freshhawk 9y agoOh definitely, realistically it's not going to happen, certainly not in time. I was treating that more as a hypothetical.