5 ms·
Pigs are smart and sensitive, yet we continue to justify killing them for food
- RickJWag 9y agoPigs are vicious animals that will ruthlessly attack other animals and even humans. (In places where feral hogs run loose, they are found very difficult to control.) Besides, bacon is delicious.
- divbit 9y agoI know this sounds selfish, but I sometimes wonder if it would be possible to genetically engineer a pig to stay a cute young piglet for it's entire life, rather than turning into a large, hungry adult pig. In this way, pigs could be companion animals, rather than food animals, and I haven't thought through all the angles, but if I was a pig, it seems that would sound be more appealing for sure. (Compare below images: http://beavercreekfarm.co/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/Charlotte_5738_LR-1024x681.jpg http://beavercreekfarm.co/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/Charlot... http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/disney/images/b/bb/Free_walt_disney_piglet_wallpaper.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20140415074205 http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/disney/images/b/bb/Free_... )
- jstanley 9y agoI don't see anything wrong with the first picture. It's gruff, but it's not repulsive.
- Drakim 9y agoEven if we ignore appearances, at some point there is just a max size convenience limit to house pets.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- divbit_m 9y agowhat are you, racist pig ?!
- divbit_m 9y agoer... ag-ist
- koala_man 9y agoWell, we /did/ turn wolves into Pomeranians.
- unclenoriega 9y agoThe neoteny is real.
- stevep98 9y agoYou could say the same about dogs and cats. Wouldn't everyone love it if their puppy or kitten would stay cute forever. But then again, if you've somehow invented a way for animals to stay looking young forever, 7 billion humans might want a word with you...
- belorn 9y agoMaybe a bit ironic in this case but that first image is of a adult mini pig which is general seen as a companion animal and not a farm animal that is used for food. Also, those pigs just love being scratched behind the ear. My family had one when I was growing up, and they are quite nicer and more friendly than piglets for regular domestic pigs (which we also had).
- exogeny 9y agoBacon: it's delicious.
- ethbro 9y agoI actually started cutting pork out of my diet after a comment on HN about vegetarianism and meat choices pointed out the same thing. I still eat it -- because it's so ubiquitous -- but am trying to shift to chicken whenever I have the choice. Eating something that's smart and social just seems wrong to me, when there are plenty of stupider animals as alternatives. Also... watch Okja on Netflix ( https://www.netflix.com/title/80091936 https://www.netflix.com/title/80091936 ), especially the ending.
- themgt 9y agoAs a counterpoint I recently saw an astonishing-if-true stat of the number of animals killed per million calories by food [1]. About 14x as many chickens die vs pigs. Even if pigs are smarter, that may change the way you weight the ethics a bit. We should all be eating brainless bivalves perhaps? [2] [1]: http://www.animalvisuals.org/projects/data/1mc http://www.animalvisuals.org/projects/data/1mc [2]: https://sentientist.org/2013/05/20/the-ethical-case-for-eating-oysters-and-mussels/ https://sentientist.org/2013/05/20/the-ethical-case-for-eati...
- acconrad 9y agoSo with reference 2 I don't understand how you can be okay eating mussels but not okay eating eggs or dairy. If a hen naturally drops eggs and those eggs don't turn into chicks, they will rot anyway. And dairy involves no death. So why would one be "vegan" and eat oysters but not eat dairy or eggs?
- philipcristiano 9y agoDairy and eggs both involve the death of animals. Dairy cows produce milk for their offspring. In order for us to get milk the offspring must be removed. Typically males are sold for veal, females continue as dairy cows. The production of laying hens results in roughly 50/50 male vs female chickens. Most of the males are killed shortly after hatching as they are not the variety kept for meat.
- hprotagonist 9y ago
- c517402 9y agoAnd yet the wild population still needs to be controlled. http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/a-plague-of-pigs-in-texas-73769069/ http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/a-plague-of-pig...
- acconrad 9y agoOpportunistic omnivores that wreak havoc on wherever they go? Sounds like another sentient species I'm acutely familiar with. If you replaced "wild hogs" with "humans" the narrative wouldn't read much differently, but probably on a government/national scale. Do you believe our population be controlled by mass killings?
- ubersoldat2k7 9y agoNot only smart and sensitive, they are very very clean. We have a minipig and it won't do any of its stuff on its house or surroundings. I'm sure the big ones, if weren't forced because of us humans to live enclosed, would behave the same way.
- mcappleton 9y agoI care about animals. I try to at least only buy cage free eggs and meat from humanely treated animals. However I wonder if the author is also against killing lions, wolves and other predators. Those animals are so brutal in how they kill they make people look like angels. I don't understand how naturalists can so vigorously protect animals who's life depends on mauling other animals regularly.
- hprotagonist 9y agoit is something of a massive troll, but this essay does take your idea seriously: http://www.jpe.ox.ac.uk/papers/consistent-vegetarianism-and-the-suffering-of-wild-animals/ http://www.jpe.ox.ac.uk/papers/consistent-vegetarianism-and-...
- secstate 9y agoThis is delightful, and very close to Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall's Meat Manifesto, which is in his cookbook/textbook on eating meat entitled, Meat. Basically, the contract we have with domesticated animals is that we'll remove the daily suffering of a wild animal's life, and in exchange we will eat you a time we specify. Having slaughtered animals myself, and watched animals die at the hands of foxes and (oh God) fishers. I'd say turning them upside down and making a single cut across their carotid artery is about as easy as it comes.
- mcappleton 9y agoThis is a great article. Thank you for sharing it.
- mnm1 9y agoThe incorrect premise here is that we won't kill and/or eat smart animals. Cute animals may (or may not) get a pass, but humans don't care about smart animals. After a decade and a half as a vegetarian, I realized we're nowhere advanced enough to make a difference in this or most other causes and a lifetime of vegetarianism won't even make a difference. Hell, we can't even stop killing ourselves and causing mass extinction events through our actions. A human, in its natural state, is the most disgusting, cruelest, nastiest creature in the known universe. Until we can figure out how to provide tools to the majority of people to raise them up out of this state (at least levels 1-2 of Maslow's pyramid), we have no hope in hell of fixing problems like this. This is not an argument to not try. It's simply an explanation of what is. If we ever get to a point where humans are able to fix such problems and have empathy and respect for each other and other creatures, it'll be amazing indeed. I certainly won't see it in my life or any of my peers' children's lives, I'm pretty sure of that, but I think certain cultures have indeed made big strides towards this in the last 50-100 years.
- dpark 9y ago> A human, in its natural state, is the most disgusting, cruelest, nastiest creature in the known universe. Claims like this are utterly lacking perspective. Cats will happily torture smaller animals. Primates hunt each other. Dolphins rape. Humans are animals, yes. In no way are they more disgusting or cruel than others, though.
- devnonymous 9y ago> Claims like this are utterly lacking perspective Hmm, lack of perspective you say? IMHO, the ability to point at cruelty in other animals and find reasonable justification of our own actions (which in magnitude, are not even into the same ballpark of cruelty) has got to count as somewhat vile, and uniquely human, don't you think?
- dpark 9y agoNo. Awareness of the realities of the world does not count as vile. Whether or not humans should be more empathetic or less violent or whatever else, it is absurd to call humans worse than other animals simply because humans happen to be smart and aware. Or alternatively pigs are terrible animals because they're smarter than average and happy to kill other animals (including humans).
- zzalpha 9y agoSo if we've decided an animal is dumb or insensitive, it's fine? Based on what scale? Are cows dumb enough? What about chickens? Goldfish can be trained to swim through obstacle courses, so are they too smart?