5 ms·
We can ask ourselves what could exist without ads. Most newspapers could make old-style ad deals, like they do for print. A few newspapers also still finance t
by kuschku 9y ago
We can ask ourselves what could exist without ads.
Most newspapers could make old-style ad deals, like they do for print. A few newspapers also still finance their sites almost entirely through subscriptions, and those would continue to exist (e.g. Süddeutsche, SPIEGEL). As would obviously publicly financed sites (BBC, ARD, ZDF, NPR).
Also products financed via paying customers, such as imgur used to be, or possibly reddit if they change the way reddit gold works.
Also, most people's blogs would continue to exist, as many self-host or use services where the free users are subsidized by the paying ones. Even WhatsApp used to be profitable with that model.
We'd be going back to a 2010 era web, and I'm not so sure that's actually bad. We'd lose the corporate dominance over the web, Google, Facebook, etc.
Now, there is one part where paying user subsidizing doesn't work, but where ads are currently the only model of financing, and that's search engines.
But considering those act as a public service, maybe after advertisers leave the web and Google goes down crashing, a government could just buy Google (as the German government bought DHL, or major shares in VW, they could probably just outright buy Google).
- majewsky 9y agoIf Google were to ask for a monthly fee for the search engine (and hopefully cut down on the data collection a not), I'd totally pay them.
- Filligree 9y agoYou might, but not very many people would. Realistically we'd lose Google.
- kuschku 9y agoYou are worth ~26€ to Google. On average, only ~5% of users are willing to pay, so each paying user would have to subsidize ~19 non-paying users for such a model to be profitable. This would result in you paying around 600€ to use Google. Alternatively, in a paid-only scenario (where you just pay the 26€), Google would become such a niche product that it'd become irrelevant.
- hengheng 9y agoIs that figure a monthly value or a "total customer value", e. g. One-time indulgence payment? And would 26€ per month also remove all Google ads from the Internet?
- kuschku 9y agoThat was a total customer value that leaked a few years ago, if I remember correctly.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eveningcoffee 9y ago26 in what period? Like over the life time, year, month?
- concede_pluto 9y agoThe ad business requires Google to hire a hell of a lot of developers who are not working on the search engine. A pay service would be viable on less revenue. And nobody knows who many people are actually willing to pay for Google search because we've never had to.