4 ms·
Silicon Valley Censorship
- sewercake 9y ago"Conservative news, it seems, is considered fake news. Liberals should oppose this dogma before their own news comes under attack." These policies are, it seems, affecting Left wing organizations as well: http://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2017/07/27/goog-j27.html http://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2017/07/27/goog-j27.html
- vvanders 9y agoMy beef with that line is how can I trust a news source that gets something basic like climate change totally wrong? I'll happily read a conservative news story that understands facts but many ignore/lie about them to drive their political agenda.
- nvahalik 9y ago> I'll happily read a conservative news story that understands facts but many ignore/lie about them to drive their political agenda. The same can be said about the other side. All too often our ideology drives what we believe rather than being able to see and sift through people's arguments. The problem is that "both sides" tend to read to reinforce what they know rather than to challenge it. Why not try to understand someone's argument. For example I've talked to several people who 1) agree climate change is happening but 2) disagree with most of the people who are very pro cap-and-trade or emissions limiting.
- vvanders 9y agoI have plenty of conservative people(one of the benefits in living in a rural area) who I love having a solid discussion with. I was specifically talking about conservative news sources. Fiscal conservatives I totally grok(and don't disagree with some select things). However the current mainstream conservative bent seems far from that. If you have no basis in facts how can you even work towards any common ground?
- smsm42 9y agoThe key here is to distinguish between three things: a) established facts b) controversial facts and c) opinions. Now, the whole classification is somewhat subjective, thus it is tricky, but if you want to appreciate - and I mean appreciate, and not prove to yourself once again you are right and they are wrong - different points of view, you need to make those distinctions. For this specific climate change thing: if the news story gets established facts wrong - e.g. claims that Earth is literally flat, or that Earth is literally 7000 years old, or that study X was about Y and had these numbers, when the story actually was about "not Y" and had completely different numbers, etc. - that is a disqualifier, there is no use in reading such story and such news source. If they get controversial facts wrong - i.e. claim that critically acclaimed climate model is actually flawed because of reasons X, Y, Z or that a study about climate that makes conclusion A instead should be making conclusion B - you may very well disagree with them, but that disagreement is not a disqualifier - at least it should not be if you are genuinely interested in discussion and not confirmation of pre-existing beliefs. It doesn't mean that article is right - the criticism may turn out to be completely wrong - but the mere fact of disagreement should not be a problem. If they get opinions wrong - i.e. they advocate political solution A to a problem X while you favor solution B, then again they may be wrong, but this is the normal course of politics - many solutions have tons of trade-offs, and even if it were possible to always identify the superior one (which is not), it'd only mean millions of people that support sub-optimal ones are wrong, and given that there's no guarantee you'd not end up - and frequently - among those, there's no reason to refuse to even consider alternative perspective. Again, you do not have to agree with it - but having different opinion is not a disqualifying thing for a news source.
- dustingetz 9y agoYou don't have to censor it! You just have to categorize it! Use all the fancy recommendation algorithms to let the scholars scholar, and the trolls happily troll with other trolls. Users get a birds eye view of everything, and can zoom in on the content they are looking for. You don't even need an algorithm, you can crowdsource this stuff with simple moderation tools, just a little more sophisticated than an up/down button, and don't notify me for content that i dont appreciate.
- moxious 9y agoMost will argue that categorizing out of the default is still hiding content. You can go to reddit and browse the negative posts but who does? It's really a battle for default display under the correct assumption that the user base doesn't look any further. It's about whether you're part of the public dialogue or whether you're relegated to some back alley
- jordigh 9y ago> the trolls happily troll with other trolls I'm pretty sure even that's a bad solution. That's how we got 4chan and T_D and eventually Trump. https://medium.com/@DaleBeran/4chan-the-skeleton-key-to-the-rise-of-trump-624e7cb798cb https://medium.com/@DaleBeran/4chan-the-skeleton-key-to-the-...
- smsm42 9y agoCategorization is often a very short distance away from censorship, if it is made in terms of value judgements such as "toxic". > Use all the fancy recommendation algorithms to let the scholars scholar, and the trolls happily troll with other trolls. The problem is that this algorithm has nothing to do with scholarly value of the uterring, while it will be widely perceived as an objective judgement on such value. If you call somebody a "troll", it's just your opinion, if you use blackbox algorithm to do it, it's kinda objective truth. That's the worrying part - because there's no evidence blackbox algorithm is better, and actually so far plenty of evidence it's worse.
- dustingetz 9y ago
- jordigh 9y agoI hate the idea that just because it's fuzzy to define what constitutes unwanted behaviour online that we must allow all behaviour. That we'll be censors destroying free speech if we ban trolls. That's just not how society works. All of our laws are fuzzy and open to interpretation. Everything is uncertain. But just because we can't robotically and unambiguously define all undesirable behaviour doesn't meant that we have to allow all of it. We don't have to let everyone do whatever they want in the comments section of every website online. We should do with online undesirables the same thing with do with any other kind of undesirable: shun them and remove them from polite society. Automatic moderation won't be perfect, but neither will human moderation. I, for one, would be super happy if the bottom half of the internet were readable again.
- justicezyx 9y agoI guess Chinese government shares the same idea. Joking aside, this is why social science is inherently intractable. The only way to mitigate is to educate citizens, not censorship or regulations. But education is not only hard, also highly profitable...
- spaceseaman 9y agoThe whole point of his post is that ALL governments are founded on this idea. You would not have a need for government in the first place if it wasn't for undesirable people doing undesirable things. In the United States, we founded our government on the principle that governments shouldn't get involved with the concept of free speech. This doesn't mean all speech is free. We put certain limits on when free speech takes effect, and this is actually a perfect example of how the law must take imprecise definitions into consideration. [Insert the usual, "free speech isn't really what you think it is" that I'm sure the internet has seen millions of times over]. The poster's point was that commercial platforms must address the same issue of undesirables. People realized that allowing the government to prohibit certain forms of speech has the negative externality that governments also gain the power to regulate all speech. On the other hand, corporations can never feasibly have that much power. They can only limit speech on their own platform. There's always another place to speak freely if you wish. This is why I find the "free speech" argument for not regulating internet comments intractable. It assumes that since we don't want governments regulating all speech, we don't want corporations regulating speech on their platform. But that simply doesn't make sense for idealogical reasons, which I believe was the top-level poster's point.
- subliminalpanda 9y ago"The Middle East Forum (MEF) is an American conservative[2] think tank founded in 1990 by Daniel Pipes, who serves as its president.[3] MEF became an independent non-profit organization in 1994. It publishes a journal, the Middle East Quarterly." [0] A quote, emphasis mine: "Both these groups are designated terrorist organizations in the United Arab Emirates". So the UAE doesn't like them. Why should we care that the UAE doesn't like them? Why specifically the UAE and just them? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_East_Forum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_East_Forum
- mikeyouse 9y agoPipes is an odious person in his own right.. If Google ranks his posts lower than normal sources, I'd consider that algorithm working well. > To borrow a computer term, if Ayatollah Khomeini, Osama bin Laden, and Nidal Hasan represent Islamism 1.0, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan (the prime minister of Turkey), Tariq Ramadan (a Swiss intellectual), and Keith Ellison (a U.S. congressman) represent Islamism 2.0. The former kill more people but the latter pose a greater threat to Western civilization. And he obviously doesn't understand what Silicon Valley Community Foundation is.. SVCF is a public charity that holds Donor Advised Funds for its clients. The checks to the charities that he dislikes came from the SVCF bank account, but only because one of their clients advised SVCF to give them a grant. Since all of SVCF's grants are available, you can easily see that the money went to the SFBay Area branch of CAIR who lately have been filing civil rights lawsuits against the Muslim ban.. not exactly Hezbollah: https://twitter.com/CAIRSFBA https://twitter.com/CAIRSFBA
- yongjik 9y agoClicking through links gave me this gem[1] by a Daniel Pipes: > "If I were a Muslim I would let you know," Barack Obama has said, and I believe him. In fact, he is a practicing Christian, a member of the Trinity United Church of Christ. He is not now a Muslim. > But was he ever a Muslim or seen by others as a Muslim? More precisely, might Muslims consider him a murtadd (apostate), that is, a Muslim who converted to another religion and, therefore, someone whose blood may be shed? ... > These statements raise two questions: What is Obama's true connection to Islam and what implications might this have for an Obama presidency? Hmm, yeah, definitely someone qualified to lecture Silicon Valley on free speech. [1] http://www.danielpipes.org/5286/was-barack-obama-a-muslim http://www.danielpipes.org/5286/was-barack-obama-a-muslim
- magicfractal 9y agoDecentralized services is the only way to have the public discourse owned by the public. We should take the matter into our own hands, use technology to solve this issue and stop entrusting these big corporations to defend our free speech rights because it's clear they're more worried about profits for the next quarter than supporting the environment that allowed their rise in the first place.
- 1_2__4 9y agoOh look more Daniel Pipes nonsense. As in, conservative idiots complaining that their desperate attempts at gaslighting, distraction and vilification don't work so well in a world where their agenda is on full display to anyone who cares to pay attention. It's not censorship to ignore efforts to mislead the public. And I'm not at all sensitive to exhortations from such people that their message is t making it out.
- jaredandrews 9y agoI think there is a serious conversation to be had about the implications of this sort of technology but this article reads more like a lazy propaganda piece. My understanding is that this tech is meant to be used on a website forum/comments/etc to organize comments. I find the text that the author tested against particularly bizarre. Does he disagree with the assessment these are "toxic" statements? I would love to see an online conversation where these comments did not lead the thread into flames.
- mikeyouse 9y ago> Does he disagree with the assessment these are "toxic" statements? I would love to see an online conversation where these comments did not lead the thread into flames. He's kind of a nutter.. his entire raison d'être is to sound the alarm about Islamism. The irony of his piece about the evils of algorithms labeling sources is apparently lost on the person who founded an organization explicitly to police speech on college campuses: http://www.campus-watch.org/ http://www.campus-watch.org/
- smsm42 9y agoYou seem to be confusing "monitoring" and "policing". Hint: "police" has power of coercion, "monitor" has only free speech rights to publish information.
- smsm42 9y agoThis robot grades "Islam is a religion" as 78% toxic and "Nobody disagrees that it is wrong to kill Jews" as 98% toxic, while giving "Hitler was a great man" only 51%. It is clearly a very bad tool for detecting toxicity and flame-prone-ness, at least in its current state. The real question, however, is when robots like these become less obviously awful - would they still retain some biases? Would they still grade some speaking styles or some topics as excessively toxic while ignoring the others? Would they just enshrine those biases under the guise of "objective algorithm" and thus make them from somebody's opinion into an "objective fact" in the eyes of the public? That would be a very dangerous situation, I think. We should not delude ourselves into thinking that because there's some ML magic inside this tool, it would be somehow perfect arbiter of human interactions, superior to actual human judgement and free from all biases, prejudices and problems that human judgement has. It is very likely that the case would be it would be worse, because we wouldn't even know whether and why those prejudices happen. And we'd discount it on "well, obviously the robot is right - it's a flawless machine and you are a flawed human".
- tlb 9y agoAre they claiming that the 5-word comment "Radical Islam is a problem" adds something worthwhile to some debate? Evidence of HN threads where people make such provocative but unsubstantive comments is that they quickly devolve into hate-fueled bickering. I don't know what their filters do, but if they're any good a thoughtful critique of radical Islam (or anything else) would pass.
- 99mistakes 9y agoI just don't see how that's provocative outside of some non-western countries. This only becomes provocative if you're dealing with a country that has a recent large minority of muslims that it is trying to appease. One certainly gives a discussion some focus when stating that radical islam is a problem so I don't see how it doesn't add something worthwhile.
- Avi-D-coder 9y agoIt seems to have a problem with Jews and the letter a in particular. "I am a Jew": 78% likely to be perceived as "toxic". "I am a Jewish" 34% likely to be perceived as "toxic". "I am Jewish": 14% likely to be perceived as "toxic". "I am a Christian": 9% likely to be perceived as "toxic". "I am Christian": 3% likely to be perceived as "toxic". "I am a Muslim": 4% likely to be perceived as "toxic". "I am Muslim": 2% likely to be perceived as "toxic". It does not like the word "Islam" or "Jew", but "Judaism" and "Muslim" are fine.
- scythe 9y agoThe solution to online "censorship" IMO is to allow users to choose to view content which has been stripped of trolling vs. raw content. If this user control is effective and accurate, most people will choose to hide trolls, and they'll lose most of their power. The big problem, more than anything, is that it isn't just "fuzzy" to define what constitutes trolling; it's very hard, and furthermore it's one of those problems where human-controlled fail-overs don't work. Individual moderators suck at controlling trolls on average, both because of their biases and their limited experience as finite people. I've seen this in action behind the scenes moderating more than one large Internet forum; sometimes it's very hard to determine whether a particular user deserves to be banned, particularly when people are vocal about controversial topics. The most effective way to promote civility, in my experience, is to ban certain topics altogether. So when people say "should we automatically remove trolls"", I think, well, should we build a fusion reactor? Should we desalinate all the water used in Los Angeles? Should we give people an MRI every time they might have fractured a bone? Should we pull a third of the carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere? Should we eradicate mosquitoes? Should we build Hyperloop? Sure...
- fosco 9y agoThe irony, the thread appears to have been knocked off the front page and in my opinion is the equivalent of being censored. This happened recently on this thread --> https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14868133 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14868133
- atom-morgan 9y agoAnything politically negative related to SV or YC seems to be almost immediately flagged.
- dan-compton 9y agoI find it strange that just a few individuals might codify the language of the masses and delegate its enforcement to a black box.