3 ms·
>In a lot of ways, this is no different than people claiming the FB 'true name' policy doesn't matter/is actually a positive. Maybe for them, but not for the fo
by slg 9y ago
>In a lot of ways, this is no different than people claiming the FB 'true name' policy doesn't matter/is actually a positive. Maybe for them, but not for the former partner of an abusive spouse, or the gay kid in Russia or Alabama.
This is exactly what I am talking about. Do you honestly see no hyperbole in this? Roomba having a map of my floors is no different than a policy that leads to gay kids in Russia being thrown in jail. Things aren't binary. We can deal with them in nuance. Equating these two together weakens your argument against both of them.
- CamperBob2 9y agoThis is exactly what I am talking about. Do you honestly see no hyperbole in this? Roomba having a map of my floors is no different than a policy that leads to gay kids in Russia being thrown in jail. Things aren't binary. We can deal with them in nuance. Equating these two together weakens your argument against both of them. yourapostasy's post elsewhere in the thread ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14876581 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14876581 ) is worth considering before dismissing these concerns as "hyperbole." When it comes to Big Data -- and Big Metadata, for that matter -- quantity has a quality all its own. If this type of data weren't valuable, and hence worth safeguarding, there would be no market for it.
- Karunamon 9y agoSo where's the market for piecemeal vacuum-robot-collected floor plans?
- IncRnd 9y ago> So where's the market for piecemeal vacuum-robot-collected floor plans? When iRobot releases their commercial automatic floor cleaning robot, consider your restricted floor-plans as mapped. Even today, there's a market eerily similar to the market of videos from hijacked xbox cameras in order to show room contents. There are lots of other markets I can think of off the top of my head. Don't discount what data can reveal.
- __jal 9y ago> We can deal with them in nuance. I'd like to agree with you, but I'm becoming less sure of that with every day. For instance, you breezed right past my point (that privacy risks are different for different people) to hammer more on your presumptuous assertion that floor maps don't (or maybe you mean shouldn't) matter to anyone.
- bentruyman 9y agoSure, and as someone who owns an older model, this feature (as I'm learning about it today) actually sounds compelling for my particular use case. But I also put covers/tape over my webcams. So sure, privacy concerns are all relative. However, in this case, I still cannot understand all the negativity still being directed toward iRobot. We know data they're collecting, we know why they're collecting it, and uploading mapping data is opt-in. If any of these things concerns you, can you just not buy it and move on?
- __jal 9y agoIf my ranting concerns you, can you just not ignore it and move on? I just can't understand the negativity... More seriously, I see value in iRobot and others hearing loud noise about how stuff like this is not OK to many of us. - "We" may know this, but I doubt there's a "we also sell your data" sticker on the box, and lots of other people don't. - If people don't push back, manufacturers will hear that this is acceptable. I'd like this to not be acceptable. - iRobot may have floated this in order to find out what people thought, but many other companies are much less scrupulous. They need to hear loud and clear that this is not acceptable. - If loud outcries happen each time some company tries to normalize data grabs like this, they won't be normalized. That's a world I'd like to live in, so I'll keep being loud, thanks.