5 ms·
I can't help but feel that privacy controversies like this are going to turn into a "boy who cried wolf" situation if we freak out anytime anyone collects the l
by slg 9y ago
I can't help but feel that privacy controversies like this are going to turn into a "boy who cried wolf" situation if we freak out anytime anyone collects the least bit of data about us. Who really cares if this company collects and/or sells mapping data of our floors? Why should I be worried if Amazon knows the distance between my couch and coffee table? Isn't our outrage better preserved for when our privacy is truly invaded?
- eridius 9y agoOutrage is absolutely appropriate for cases like this. This isn't "boy who cried wolf". The fact that cases like this generate outrage serves as a reminder to everybody that privacy is important and as a strong signal to companies that they can't do stuff like this without customer backlash. If we just sat quietly and did nothing when iRobot seems to be selling our data, then that just opens the door to worse privacy violations.
- handedness 9y agoA world in which people overreact to privacy violations (whether perceived or real) isn't one I envision happening any time soon. Sure, there'll be periodic and pointless indignation, but then the vast majority of those complaining will go back to trading their personal information for free stuff.
- CameronBanga 9y agoThat's the great thing about having a market and the ability to share this information. You go ahead and buy the Roomba, and I'll just avoid them all together. It's fine. But I'm glad to know that this was on the cards, and plan to vote with my pocket and not buy products that intend to do something like this. I hate to sound alarmist, but as our world grows increasingly connected, I tend to be a bit cautious as to why I'm giving up this data and for what benefit. I see stories like this (https://carpeaqua.com/2017/07/07/hack-the-planet/ https://carpeaqua.com/2017/07/07/hack-the-planet/) and wouldn't have thought before that my PayPal accounts or other financial information could be at risk because of an AT&T issue, but some criminal was smart and exploited the weak link here. I don't have any idea as to how criminals in the future will exploit my personal house data in order to steal from me, but just in case they find a way, I'd rather not offer up that data because "who cares".
- alekratz 9y ago> I don't have any idea as to how criminals in the future will exploit my personal house data in order to steal from me, ... Floor plans are quite useful for staging a burglary.
- netfire 9y agoIt seems like you could get a basic idea of what rooms are where just by looking the exterior of the house using satellite images, street view, or driving by a house. Also if your house has ever been listed for sale, there's likely pictures of the interior out on the web as well. Would the robot-generated maps provide much additional information to thieves?
- slg 9y agoWhich is likely already available publicly along with many of the other things people are pointing out like square footage of a home. And maybe you live in a much bigger place than I do, but a burglar isn't going to be planning to rob me like they are planning to steal the Mona Lisa from the Louvre. My house isn't that complicated, you don't need to spend much time planning when you can deduce a floor plan pretty quickly. It also isn't like a Roomba created floor plan would have any idea on where in my house the valuables are stored.
- bagacrap 9y agoDon't assume they'll be so uncreative with your data. For example, if there are time stamps on the collected data it could tell someone when the Roomba tends to run and that might indicate when you are gone from your home.
- Chardok 9y agoJust because you can't think of abuses to your couch-to-coffee table distance or your floor layout doesn't mean that they could potentially be privacy-invading, especially when they are fed into massive AI databases. You could call me paranoid, but I prefer all data I generate in private to be limited to whom I want to share it with.
- indigochill 9y agoSuppose I'm an insurance company. If I know how far a robot had to travel to clean your floor, I know your house's square footage which means I can make estimates about your income and lifestyle based on data from millions of other people. Maybe I decide (doesn't matter that it's wrongly as long as I decide it's pertinent) from your probable lifestyle based on this data that you may be at risk for developing a health condition and so I charge you more for health insurance. If I'm a burglar, it's convenient to map out your house before I burgle you. There's just no reason pertaining to cleaning floors that the floor plan needs to get saved anywhere. Companies collect data for the purpose of extracting value from it. If they just wanted to make smart devices better, they could have the devices communicate on a closed network without sending data anywhere outside the network.
- yourapostasy 9y ago> Why should I be worried if Amazon knows the distance between my couch and coffee table? Isn't our outrage better preserved for when our privacy is truly invaded? This isn't thinking like a corporation, nor a hacker. This as an APT, information security-wise. These kinds of grants of access to private data by consumers for monetization purposes are never, ever constrained to one highly-specific type of data. They want you to grant access to a data gathering CHANNEL. Once that channel is opened, any additional data they figure out how to gather falls under the same agreement you consented to before. Today, it is room data. Tomorrow, it is dust and pollen collection data. "So what, who cares, they can have measurements of how much dust and pollen is in my home, lol." Yeah? Exactly how much have you worked with the data brokering business? If you've been around the block in that part of the industry for any length of time, you quickly realize that it isn't single individual databases where the real bucks are made. It is novel combinations of datasets giving you a plausible explanation to draw inferences from the data. Go back to the hypothetical dust and pollen measurement. Suppose the GOP loosens the restrictions on risk-pricing medical insurance plans; as long as an insurer can point to a plausible explanation of pricing factors, they can price it however they want above a baseline, but they don't have to make it easy for you to figure that out. Health insurer uses a study [1] to explain how certain levels of dust and pollen are correlated to X% increases in stress-related costs. They purchase the dataset from iRobot. Slap an X% increase onto your premiums, but you are none the wiser on exactly why, and especially where the substantiating data came from, "because it's a trade secret". The practically non-existent privacy protections for American consumers is essentially a license to steal from them. The best part is you never have to be told who gave what information about you, and when. All this data gathering started out as a sales exercise only because that is the low-hanging fruit. The real prize is absolute control over all the decisions you will make that matter to the owners. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3264048/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3264048/
- __jal 9y ago> Who really cares if this company collects and/or sells mapping data of our floors? Me. And not to put too fine a point on it, the people in the market for buying and selling this data. > Why should I be worried if Amazon knows the distance between my couch and coffee table? I'm not going to presume to speak for you. > Isn't our outrage better preserved for when our privacy is truly invaded? ...So don't speak for me when deciding what is an isn't an invasion of privacy. I find this to be a significant invasion, and so do many other folks, some of whom are giving you possible answers to your question. In a lot of ways, this is no different than people claiming the FB 'true name' policy doesn't matter/is actually a positive. Maybe for them, but not for the former partner of an abusive spouse, or the gay kid in Russia or Alabama. Don't presume that your tolerance for data leakage is the same as everyone else's. More generally, the point is that information like this just should be default-private. There is zero reason for me to want information like this to be shared with random third-parties. If iRobot or whomever wants to "enhance the value of their connected devices" with private data about me and/or my possessions, let them approach me and convince me to share it, not just blandly write some bullshit privacy policy and take it from a device I purchased. I love innovation, new toys, etc. But this rush to sneakily inventory/quantify/spy on me, my home, possessions and relations is awful, and will have creepy outcomes. It won't happen to me, because I won't install this shit in my home or use social media, but it will happen. Do what you like with your own sense of privacy, but don't presume to speak for anyone else about what a "true invasion" might be.
- slg 9y ago>In a lot of ways, this is no different than people claiming the FB 'true name' policy doesn't matter/is actually a positive. Maybe for them, but not for the former partner of an abusive spouse, or the gay kid in Russia or Alabama. This is exactly what I am talking about. Do you honestly see no hyperbole in this? Roomba having a map of my floors is no different than a policy that leads to gay kids in Russia being thrown in jail. Things aren't binary. We can deal with them in nuance. Equating these two together weakens your argument against both of them.
- CamperBob2 9y ago
- krapp 9y ago> Why should I be worried if Amazon knows the distance between my couch and coffee table? The only reason I can think of is that square footage can be an indicator of income class.