4 ms·
Exactly, unless there is some 'suicide' clause in the company bylaws that says all data will be destroyed on change of ownership (which would be fiduciarily [1]
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Exactly, unless there is some 'suicide' clause in the company bylaws that says all data will be destroyed on change of ownership (which would be fiduciarily [1] irresponsible anyway) then the statement of the CEO is constrained to 'during my tenure' at best. And 'during my tenure, while we are meeting our numbers goals' at worst.
[1] I don't think that is a word but hopefully what I hope it would mean if it were a word is clear :-)
- ra1n85 9y agoI like that - but how would you enforce it? Wouldn't it actually just deter companies interested in acquiring out of interest in the acquisition's customer data?
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoAt an implementation level, you could make it optional for customers to delete their data (preferably opt-out of deletion). A purchaser looking to woo your clients (and continue to provide your service) rather than exploit your goodwill shouldn't have trouble retaining the majority of the data. There's no reason to force data deletion, but leaving the choice to customers if they want to trust the purchasing company the way they trusted you prevents a lot of conflicts of interest and abusive behaviors.
- ChuckMcM 9y ago> Wouldn't it actually just deter companies interested in acquiring out of interest > in the acquisition's customer data? Yes, that is exactly it. So at some level the data is a company asset that has 'value' to a potential acquiring company. And if you decide to destroy the value of that asset to an acquiring company (by having it self destruct on acquisition) then you've intentionally reduced the value of the company. Your fiduciary responsibility as a board member or executive is to maximize the value of the company. The long held theory here is that the share holder's elect board members to represent their interest in the company, which is notionally the 'value' of their shares, so for the board to be doing the shareholder's bidding they would not allow the CEO to explicitly damage the value of the company by impairing one of its assets with a destruct clause.
- amluto 9y agoThat seems like a dubious analysis. If the destruct clause helps sales, then maybe its not irresponsible after all.
- kbenson 9y agoI think it could be more nuanced than that. You could trade that possible future value for good PR and public image, especially if you are fighting a lot of bad PR because of people's worries about that data. Putting a clause in without letting anyone know about it would be destroying the value, but if you attempt to capitalize the on public perception of the move I think it would be really hard to make a case that it was irresponsible without some corroborating evidence that nobody thought it would help.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- enoch_r 9y agoBy this logic, having a sale is also a violation of fiduciary responsibility. As others have pointed out, looking only at the costs associated with a decision to "spend" assets is not what fiduciary responsibility requires.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoI disagree with your assessment that it's a priori fiduciarily irresponsible [1]: it's entirely possible that the extra business gained by having a data self-destruct term would create a better financial situation for the company than having the data available to re-purpose would, and thus would be in the best interest of the shareholders. (There are similar arguments about marketplace health, etc. There's not a strict duty to generate the best financials, per se.) As a tangent, there's also mechanisms you could use besides something in the bylaws to prevent it -- I don't think you actually need anything but restructuring the contract. (Though, obviously, bylaws or articles would carry more weight.) [1] I like that phrase!
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThat is a good argument, and it would rest on being able to show the greater good from the business model. If I were your activist shareholder though I would argue that your argument conflates the residual value of the company with the operational value :-).
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoCould you elaborate on your argument?
- ChuckMcM 9y agoSure, I'm not invested enough in the outcome to drill down to the numbers but I'm happy to share how I would analyze it. There are two choices the analysis; 'do nothing' which leaves the business as it is, collecting sensor data from the operation of the robots into aggregated data sets, and 'destruct on sale' which is a promise to delete any and all sensor data collected so that the new owner can not use it. I am further assuming that at the time of sale the business has two components of value, its 'operational' value which is the annual recurring revenue of its subscribers/users less the cost of managing the revenue, and 'residual' value which consists of company assets such as the physical plant (offices), algorithms or patents, real estate holdings, and data sets. In the 'do nothing' case we assume that subscription rates ($SUBS) stay the same (so revenue is unchanged) and that the data set accumulated has some value (say $DS)). Using $SUBS as the revenue model, $ASSETS for the stuff that doesn't change in either choice (office, patents) the value generated by the company would be something like: years * $SUBS + $ASSETS + $DS. And in the scenario where you argue that destroying the data would result in more users it would be years * ($SUBS + $Delta) + $ASSETS. Does that make sense so far? So my analysis would say that the 'better' choice is the one that generates more value over time for the company. And given the structure above that depends entirely on one thing, is the value of ($DELTA * years) greater or less than the value of $DS. Next I'm going to stipulate that the value of $DS has a 'years' component as well since the data set keeps customer data regardless if they are a current customer or not. So the more customers you've had over the years the more value $DS. And using that stipulation I'm going to simplify the analysis to just the comparison of $DELTA and $DS. Then I'm going to ask can we characterize the size of $DELTA? And I will argue, perhaps unfairly, that $DELTA would consist entirely of people who 'care about privacy.' Then I'm going to look at all of the experiments in tech where the differentiating factor of the product was 'privacy' or 'less tracking' and compare their addressable customer market to the the overall market. (I actually got to 'live' this advocating the privacy features of the Blekko search engine to people) Then I'm going to argue that while there are many people who will talk about their concerns around privacy and security the number that will change their behavior relative to that concern if astonishingly small. It shouldn't be but there are examples all around of how it is. And based on that argument I'm going to argue that $DELTA is very small, 1 or 2% of the subscriber base at best. Then I am going to talk about the challenges of developing a dataset like $DS. How difficult it would be for anyone to create such a data set without a way of explicitly running a sensor suite in thousands of homes. And given how hard it is to compete, that someone with sole possession of that data would have a competitive advantage over others who might seek to use it, or might have a salable product based on that data that nobody else could offer. (joke idea: use it to validate square footage numbers in Redfin listings). I would argue that this data set which would be unique in the world would be very valuable, and assert that $DS was >> $DELTA and so the right choice for the company was to keep it. And in that analysis, if the most value would be maintained by keeping it, then changing the company so that it could not be kept would impair the value of the company and violate the fiduciary duty of the board.
- Hupriene 9y agoThere doesn't have to be any bylaw changes, there just needs to be a contract with the customer regarding the usage of their data. One of the old fashioned kinds of contracts that doesn't allow one party to make unilateral changes to it. Then if they eventually do sell the data, they invite a class action lawsuit for breach of contract.
- lomnakkus 9y agoI don't mean to heap on you, but do you know of any actual cases where it's happened? (Apologies, for not reading the whole thread, headed out the door...) It seems quite interesting as a concept what a company is once it's bought and traded. What, exactly, is the precedence of interests? Is it state-first? Or owner-first? Or maybe a combination of the two? ... or am I just too drunk?
- ChuckMcM 9y ago"its" ? I'm not sure what the "its" in your first sentence refers to. I am not an expert, I've played a part in no more than 10 companies being sold or purchased. In all the cases that I participated it the process involved creating a 'third' company that was essentially wholly owned by the acquiring company, and then that third company 'bought' some or all of the assets (physical or intellectual) of the company being bought. And then the purchased company was typically dissolved after a period of time that would allow for things like contracts or other actions to transpire while the entity existed. At a future point the intermediary company gets absorbed into its parent with a full transfer of all assets and that triggers its own dissolution clause. The bylaws have always been the controlling documents for who could approve the sale, and how that process would complete. California adds a 'fairness' hearing sometimes[1] which I was told provides some protection against future lawsuits. Bottom line a company is its employees, contracts, customers, physical property, intellectual property, cash accounts, and financial obligations. The entity or body authorized to sell the company can sell any or all of those pieces. [1] http://www.dbo.ca.gov/ENF/FairnessHearings/ http://www.dbo.ca.gov/ENF/FairnessHearings/