3 ms·
The airbag significantly reduced the distance between your face and anything else. In all but the most serious crashes your face will not hit anything if the s
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
The airbag significantly reduced the distance between your face and anything else. In all but the most serious crashes your face will not hit anything if the seat-belt fits well.
I'd rather have a sore neck from driving into a wall at 35mph than have a concussion from bouncing my face off of a bag full of high pressure gas.
Side curtain airbags are a much more useful technology than frontal ones.
Edit: Fire needs three things, fuel, oxygen and ignition. The atmosphere has oxygen. A gasoline vehicle keeps the fuel and ignition relatively far from each other. A battery contains both fuel and a source of ignition in close proximity. A punctured gas tank will not cause a fire every time. A punctured battery pack will cause a fire basically every time. In many cases a rusted out or leaking fuel system is noticed well before it starts a fire. There isn't much opportunity to notice a high-amperage short before it's a problem. Putting out a fire is even harder on electric vehicles. You can't throw foam and water on an internal short. There are many advantages of electric vehicles. Fire safety is not one of them.
- manigandham 9y ago> In all but the most serious crashes your face will not hit anything if the seat-belt fits well. Great, then there's nothing to worry about... but if it is a serious crash, you'll wish you had an airbag to bounce off of rather than a hard steering column, dashboard and windshield.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoMost people will never be in an airbag deploying crash in their lives. Of the minority that will very few will be in the kind of crash where a (frontal) airbag is what prevents them from serious harm. If OEMs would just be less trigger happy with frontal airbag deployment then I'd be satisfied but the problem with that is that then you get the Concerned Mothers Association(TM) complaining about OEMs not doing everything they can to "save lives" and publicizing a few edge cases.
- c22 9y agoWhen I slammed into an oncoming left turning car at 50mph I was not wearing a seatbelt, my Subaru rolled completely over and the front airbag deployed. I left the accident with minor lacerations and no broken bones or major bruising. In 20 years of driving airbag equipped cars this has been my only experience of an airbag deployment. So far I'm a happy customer.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoWear your goddamn seatbelt. You are an edge case.
- c22 9y agoBut isn't spontaneous deployment of airbags causing grave injury also an edge case? [1] Not only do I wear a seatbelt since that incident but I'm also, by orders of magnitude, a more conscientious driver than I was prior. [1] https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/AB0707 https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/...
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoSpontaneous deployment, yes, that's an edge case. Turning an accident that would have left one only bruised from the seatbelt into one that also includes a broken nose and injuries to one's hands and arms is fairly common.
- yellowapple 9y ago"In all but the most serious crashes your face will not hit anything if the seat-belt fits well." That's not really a good thing. Having something to catch your head helps prevent neck injuries. In a high-speed crash, the forces involved could actually be debilitating and/or life-threatening.
- ams6110 9y agoUnless it's a Takata airbag and the thing that catches your face is a piece of metal shrapnel. You do understand that airbags are bombs. The inflation mechanism literally uses explosives. They can and have killed people especially children and the elderly. Early generation airbags are more violent and dangerous because the standard was to protect an unbelted driver.
- njarboe 9y agoI believe this is still the standard in North America.
- semi-extrinsic 9y ago> They can and have killed people especially children and the elderly. Who puts children in front of airbags?? The car is half-way covered in stickers saying not to.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIs a few lives saved in (rare) high speed accidents worth setting off explosions in people's faces and turning an otherwise minor accident into a trip to the hospital? If all you care about are deaths per distance then you probably want the former. If you care about minimizing accidents that require any medical care reducing the number of small explosions near people's faces is the better bet. Someone else posted the a NYT link that's relevant. This is for driver's frontal airbags only. Passenger airbags and side curtain airbags are less bad because people usually sit farther from the passenger airbag and there is less support in side impacts.
- Fjolsvith 9y agoI have been in an accident with no air bag deployed and wearing my seat belt. I was rear-ended by a vehicle doing 45 mph faster than mine. I had torn ligaments in my neck that took years to fully recover from. An air bag might have reduced my injury to a sore neck. P.S. I was in a 1964 Chevrolet C10 Pickup that I had installed seat belts in.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoSeriously? An airbag isn't there to protect you from rear-endings. That's what headrests (which your '64 C10 did not have) are for.
- Fjolsvith 9y agoMy forehead and shoulders bounced off the steering wheel so hard that the left lens of my eyeglasses popped out. My mother, who was with me, didn't have her seat belt on. She was bounced so hard against the ceiling she was knocked unconscious.