4 ms·
> Why would Average Joe do any better? They wouldn't. It only works when the electorate is educated and rational - and that is almost never the case.
by manigandham 9y ago
> Why would Average Joe do any better?
They wouldn't. It only works when the electorate is educated and rational - and that is almost never the case.
- Spivak 9y agoThey would. So long as your the Average Joe makes the correct decision 51% of the time in the long run we'll turn out fine.
- manigandham 9y agoThat makes no sense. What's the correct decision? All the people voting completely against their interests now think they're making the correct decision. Not all decisions or votes are equal and the outcome of an election can change what can even be voted on and by whom for the next round.
- Spivak 9y agoI'm responding to the point that voters need to be rational and educated for a direct democracy to function. It only requires that voters have a bias, however slight, to making the 'right' decision. Don't think too much about how to define 'right' because you'll drive yourself mad. All that matters is the belief that in the long run people tend to make 'right' choices slightly more often than wrong ones.
- manigandham 9y agoThat wasn't the point. The question is whether it's a good idea - and it's not when people don't know or don't care about what they're voting on, both of which requires education and rational (long-term) thinking.
- ZenoArrow 9y ago> "All that matters is the belief that in the long run people tend to make 'right' choices slightly more often than wrong ones." Do they though? I see people making the "wrong" choices very often when the "right" choice is inconvenient for them. I would include myself in that description too.