5 ms·
Frankly, I'm kind of shocked by HN's collective opinion on this subject- and I am not a conservative. In my opinion, it is really very simple. I don't care so
by sliverstorm 16y ago
Frankly, I'm kind of shocked by HN's collective opinion on this subject- and I am not a conservative.
In my opinion, it is really very simple. I don't care so much about the nebulous question of whether it's right or wrong to infringe on IP, and all these other new questions that come about when you remove the physical aspect and introduce CTRL+C/CTRL+V. What matters to me, is that books and music and movies continue to exist.
That won't happen if we insist we deserve it all for free. Who the fuck will spend their life writing music or books or movies if we don't leave them a way to monetize it? Artists are rarely driven by greed (and if they are, disillusioned quickly) but in nearly every human being, the desire to NOT DIE usurps the desire to express yourself creatively, so artists will be forced to abandon their works to continue living.
- jexe 16y agoYou know what else is interesting - the means to produce music and movies is moving down market, fast. My friggin phone records HD, and my Mac comes with some basic music production software, I can self-publish my own books on amazon or just host them electronically myself.. and this trend is only accelerating. So will we see less art in the future? Absolutely not - we'll be seeing huge amounts more, and from people who may not have had access to, say, a recording studio in the past. The economics are changing on both ends of the "business," which I think is a net positive.
- chokma 16y agoI think it is great that one can take an off-the-shelf video camera and make a movie. And this sparks a whole world of creativity. Each day a 100 years of video are uploaded to Youtube. What we need is a way to compensate professional artists and performers in a world where the cost to distribute is effectively zero. Some stuff (for example a "Michael Moore"-style documentary on the oil spill) is complex enough that it is difficult to produce it without having a way to cover your costs. Does Cory Doctorow's way of doing this scale to movie production? Oh, and we need camcorders and the like to integrate free codecs - the ones currently available by default often produce H.264-movies which need a license if you want to profit from your work in any way...
- loup-vaillant 16y ago> Does Cory Doctorow's way of doing this scale to movie production? It may: http://www.ironsky.net/ http://www.ironsky.net/
- ErrantX 16y agoWriting good sheet music is very very definitely an art. Even the vast majority of music graduates are unable to do it. Technology will not help with that. Writing a good book is a serious time commitment. If no one is putting in that time and effort then the quality will decline (it has already, sadly). The ease of producing media is great and a mark of a better society. But making stuff easy does not make creating quality easy.
- mkramlich 16y agoNow if only every Mac also comes with talent pre-installed. And hard work and focus. And years of experience. Oh wait.
- semanticist 16y agoWe're going to see a lot more writers, but probably less editors and publishers. While writing a good novel is difficult, writing a good novel without editing is incredibly so. Anyone can publish their work on the internet, but without a framework to pay for professional editing, it's mostly going to be a bit rubbish.
- iamdave 16y agoPotboilers aren't anything new, my friend. "so artists will be forced to abandon their works to continue living." Exactly how is this bad? What do music artists contribute other than catchy tunes to the grand sphere of what our nation defines? And for that matter, have you seen the statistics of professional athletes who fall face first into the realm of poverty once they retire from their respective sports? It is shocking and frankly, a bit depressing. It's one of those things that invariably happens during the course of man that the lifestyles some of these people live are not going to last forever, and if they build their entire means of existence around "royalties" thinking they'll become the next Mick Jagger or Axl Rose floating comfortably on the sales of platinum albums decades after their last chart topping hit... well...I don't even need to say it.
- sliverstorm 16y ago> Exactly how is this bad? What do music artists contribute other than catchy tunes to the grand sphere of what our nation defines? I'm not an arts person, so I will not present an argument about how art is good or bad for humanity. My point is: 1: I want music artists to stay about, because I like their catchy tunes. 2: Presumably, people who download their music do too, or they wouldn't care about it enough to want to listen in the first place. Ok, so being a pro athlete is not a good long-term plan, but how about if they didn't make a dime when they were still playing? Can you see professional football continuing to exist if the only livable model was for players to work graveyards to support their addiction to oblong leather balls? Kids would still play, high schoolers would still play, but we would have no NFL. P.S. You don't think music plays a role in defining a nation? Then why is it the 2 biggest cues a movie uses to clue you in on setting is dress and music?
- kiba 16y agoOk, so being a pro athlete is not a good long-term plan Being a pro athlete per se isn't a necessary dumb idea. It's just that athletes don't have any financial skills because they rather devote their whole energy to sport. Frankly, it's simply the matter of earning several million bucks and then living off the interest rates. It turns out surprisingly hard as you have to dodge snake oil salemen and the urge to spend all your money on lavish vacations and other money drainers.
- petercooper 16y agoWhat matters to me, is that books and music and movies continue to exist. That won't happen if we insist we deserve it all for free. This guy is a composer, lyricist, and arranger, not a "sheet music producer." Plenty of software developers wouldn't give away their core assets for free or like them to be stolen, but many give away/open source byproducts of their work (libraries and documentation, say). Opening up byproducts is a good way to increase your exposure and increase the value of your core products. On the other hand, he totally has the right to defend his intellectual property. I just think it's misguided in the short term to do so at this level.
- scarlson 16y agoSimilarly, should artists who sample works from public content have to pay royalties? Musicians and artists can claim IP when their works are shared, but what about mathematicians, architects? Do I owe Pythagoras' estate every time I compute A^2 + B^2 = C^2? I want to put French doors in my pantry, who do I make the check out to in order to legally use the design? This man lives comfortably, I'm sure he's not living paycheck to paycheck. He deserves credit for creating the work, but the implication is that he's somehow suffering based on the 'trading'. Life sucks, I'd be pissed too but it's the way things work. Grayson Chance was an internet sensation not too long ago for performing Lady Gaga's music. She didn't try to burn him for most likely stealing the sheet music, she applauded the kid and wished him luck. Relevant, NSFW audio: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cvq3Pf3j61c http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cvq3Pf3j61c
- shrikant 16y agoOT: Thanks for making me re-visit The Wire. I've uploaded a clip from it (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_BxRDmu6NBM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_BxRDmu6NBM - the chess scene) - which was flagged by ContentID, incidentally - that puts forth some killer ideas. That show was awesome, and totally deserves every penny it gets from folks buying the box-set :)
- moe 16y agoWho the fuck will spend their life writing music or books or movies if we don't leave them a way to monetize it? That's a very narrow, brainwashed view. Many people will continue to spend their lives on it. Remember music has been around long before there were ways to "monetize" it. Moreover please realize that your HipHop millionaire and Britney Spears are anomalies in first place. For every Britney Spears you'll find ten thousands of underdog musicians who stay (often barely) afloat not by having their videos on TRL, but by playing small gigs in front of people. That kind of making a living with music is not going anywhere and will, in fact, greatly benefit when the "Great wall of EMI" (or Universal, or Sony, or what not..) comes down.
- seertaak 16y ago> Remember music has been around long before there were ways to "monetize" it. No halfway sane person will pursue music fulltime if he cannot earn a living off it. This is true and has been true throughout history. Where there previously was no revenue through the sale of recorded or sheet music, there was patronage. If the patronage system had not existed, do you really think Leopold Mozart would have devoted his efforts at training Wolfgang Amadeus from the age of 3 to pursue music, as opposed to a (fee-earning) trade or craft? I don't deny that there will always be hobbyists. But the world will be a much poorer place, musically, if we don't allow music as a fulltime career. > That kind of making a living with music is not going anywhere and will, in fact, greatly benefit when the "Great wall of EMI" (or Universal, or Sony, or what not..) comes down. First, let me point out that I am one of the "underdog musicians" you speak of. You can see my band at http://www.thesignalsofficial.com http://www.thesignalsofficial.com, and you can hear my music at http://www.myspace.com/thesignalsproject http://www.myspace.com/thesignalsproject . I'm not signed to a label, let alone a major label. I finance everything related to band out of my own pocket, and my girlfriend takes our band pictures. However, I will quit my efforts making music, at least with a band, if I don't manage to get some kind revenue off of it. To not do so would be idiotic. Second, it appears to me that you, as many others in the Hacker News community, are imbued with an inflated sense of romanticism of the small gig as opposed to financing via recorded music or proxies thereof. I understand that there is something intimate, raw, and beautiful in witnessing a musician play one of those shows, and I can assure that as I musician, those kind of gigs are really fun to play. But what's so wrong about putting vast hours of work into lovingly recording a record, so that anyone (who pays for it) can have the benefit of enjoying well composed, arranged, produced, mixed, and mastered music from, say, his car? Why should that be valued at zero, even if the product can be copied at virtually zero cost? Why do you see it as obvious that one should pay for small gigs (and, by the way, in many cases one doesn't pay for small gigs, the best the musician has to hope for is to make a cut of the bar draw), and yet not for recorded music? Scarcity, I presume you'll say. But that argument doesn't really hold water. Consider a music festival: my ability to enjoy the music at the festival doesn't (unless massive amounts of people are involved) deprive another person of the ability to enjoy the music. So by the scarcity argument, it should be morally ok to just jump over the fence without paying. (You wouldn't have paid for the gig otherwise, right? So no harm done.) But, of course, if everyone were to do that, the musician wouldn't be left with any money to get paid with. Nobody argues that bouncers, the "authority" that forces you to pay, are repressive, anti free-speech and authoritarian. And yet if they weren't there, do you really think people would pay to see gigs? And the functional equivalent of the bouncer in the digital domain is copyright law and enforcement thereof. I'd like to make this last point more explicit. One method that is very effective in determining whether an argument boils down to sophistry is reductio ad absurdum. In the context filesharing, it goes like this: if filesharing is a good thing, then surely more of it is an even better thing. And the limit of that process is that all music is obtained through filesharing, and in this situation, no musician will ever obtain money from recorded music. Fine, you say: make money through other means -- play gigs! But if the same free-for-all mentality you seem to espouse is valid in the digital domain, why not in the physical? Why not loudly demand an end to bouncers at clubs? After all, as I've pointed out, if it is an injustice to limit the digital distribution of music, then surely it is equally an injustice to limit physical presence at a gig by the imposition of entry fee. And if the end-the-bouncer-movement ever did manage to get political traction, then there can be no doubt that no one would pay for gigs either.
- pyre 16y agoThe Library of Alexandria didn't have a copyright division.
- goodside 16y agoThe immorality of copyright infringement is not contingent on whether the industry can survive in spite of it any more than the immorality of traditional theft is contingent on whether the victim can afford to suffer the loss. The fact I have an Ikea-style ball pit in my basement filled with money doesn't entitle you to come in and grab a handful. Even if you're only just borrowing it, even if you do actually give it back later, and even if I don't even notice you took it, it's wrong.
- loup-vaillant 16y agoAnd may I know why copyright infringement is bad? Don't say "because it's illegal", that would be begging the question. What I mean is, copyrighted work is an abundant good. I just can't steal it from you. I can just make a copy. Is that bad? Why?
- tomjen3 16y agoThere is more book on project Gutenberg than you can read in the rest of your life. You can't even read the entire _catalog_ of the library of congress, because they add books faster than you can read them. So what if no new books were created from now on? No new music, video, anything? You still wouldn't run out of books, music, etc. Ever.