4 ms·
I agree with this entirely. Coinbase isn't just "one of the more prominent voices", they're also one of the more respectable voices. They come across as the bri
by JoshTriplett 9y ago
I agree with this entirely. Coinbase isn't just "one of the more prominent voices", they're also one of the more respectable voices. They come across as the bridge to more traditional systems (like banks and simplified consumer transactions), filtering out some of the more "radical" elements of the Bitcoin community, and a statement like this from them may well have a material effect on the efficacy of a fork.
They might well decide, afterward, to provide a means of cashing out the "alternate" currency after all. But even if they do, and even if they plan to at this point, there's PR value in them not saying that.
- sowbug 9y agoThere is also a Machiavellian path where an exchange executes a devastatingly well-timed series of sales of its customers' holdings of the alternate version of the currency, thereby tanking the value and ensuring that its preferred outcome comes to pass. What it does with the minuscule revenue from that is probably irrelevant, but it'd make sense to credit to its customers' accounts as BTC. As you say, Coinbase is a respectable firm, and it seems unlikely it would choose this tactic. But it would be consistent with a strategy to ensure the fork fails to thrive.
- runeks 9y agoSimple solution: Coinbase adds "convert BCC to BTC" button, which does exactly what you say, but charges a fee for this service. I can't see how the BCC price can go anywhere but down if all Coinbase customers suddenly gain this ability ("Do you want extra BTC. Yes/no?").
- JoshTriplett 9y ago> Simple solution: Coinbase adds "convert BCC to BTC" button, which does exactly what you say, but charges a fee for this service. That's exactly what I want. (That or a "convert BCC to cash" button, they're equivalent.) They already charge transactions fees. Just write a careful announcement saying something like "due to the nature of the fork, anyone with 1 BTC at time X is entitled to 1 BCC as well, and we're providing a service to cash in that BCC for you".
- mirimir 9y agoSeveral exchanges are auto-converting their users' BCC to BTC, I've read.[0] 0) https://steemit.com/bitcoin/@kingscrown/if-you-were-not-aware-in-4-days-you-can-have-14-more-of-btc-for-free https://steemit.com/bitcoin/@kingscrown/if-you-were-not-awar...
- Double_a_92 9y agoYou can't just "convert" them. You still have to sell them to someone, can't force that. Even if you could that would pull the price down extremely. Easiest thing is to just give the user access to the new chain and it's "parallel"-coins. Then he can decide when and how to sell them.
- cma 9y ago> Even if you could that would pull the price down extremely. That was the point.
- 27182818284 9y ago>I agree with this entirely. Coinbase isn't just "one of the more prominent voices", they're also one of the more respectable voices. Yeah, wasn't their original pitch to be the "Gmail of the Bitcoin world" or something like that. The warm blues, friendly emails, YC backing, etc all point in that direction.
- fragmede 9y ago> one of the more respectable voices This cannot be underscored enough if BitC* is to be used for anything more than modern day drug dealing. The paper trail is important for things like paying taxes, and obeying sanctions[0] that businesses follow. [0] https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/sanctions/SDN-List/Pages/default.aspx https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/sanctions/SDN-List/...