5 ms·
Atheism and agnosticism are orthogonal: 1. If you believe in a god but don't claim to have knowledge, you are a theist agnostic. (This is not that silly. Many
by philwelch 16y ago
Atheism and agnosticism are orthogonal:
1. If you believe in a god but don't claim to have knowledge, you are a theist agnostic. (This is not that silly. Many people believe things they do not claim to know. For instance, you can believe that P != NP while acknowledging the question as unproven and unknown.)
2. If you don't believe in a god but don't claim to have knowledge, you are an atheist agnostic.
3. If you claim to know, not just believe, that a god exists, you're a theist (but not an agnostic).
4. If you claim to know there are no gods, you're an atheist (but not an agnostic).
- alanh 16y agoFor strict definitions of these words, you are right. In practice I find the following equivalent list of terms more common: 1. Deism 2. Atheism 3. Theism 4. Strong atheism
- philwelch 16y agoDuring the Enlightenment, which was the heyday of deism, philosophical proofs of God's existence were still taken seriously by most deists. So they weren't agnostic at all--they claimed to know, based upon reason, that God existed. A perfectly consistent Enlightenment-era viewpoint. However, since they only go as far as "God exists" and never get to the more exotic beliefs, namely the beliefs which always were and always will be taken on faith (God had a human son, who was also God, died, and was resurrected; God chose a Middle Eastern ethnic group for a special purpose; God revealed prophecies to certain people; God is from outer space) they weren't religious.
- klodolph 16y ago5. If you claim that the question, "does a god exist?" cannot be meaningfully answered due to flaws in the nature of the question, then you are a theological noncognitivist. 6. If you claim that the question, "does a god exist?" cannot be answered before defining "god", then you are an ignosticist. An ignosticist who claims that "god" cannot be defined is therefore also claiming that "does a god exist?" can never be answered. 7. If you claim that the question, "does a god exist?" is not worth answering, then you are apatheistic. 8. Alternatively, if you choose to assume that the answer to the question, "does a god exist?" is "no", but do not consider it worth the effort to attempt to answer the question conclusively, then you are apatheistic. 9. If you claim that the question, "does a god exist?" cannot be answered because the question cannot be correctly communicated due to differences in the definition of "god" and/or "exist" between the idiolects of the persons attempting to communicate the question to each other, then you are a philosophy major. 9b. If (9) above applies but you manage to work the word "qualia" into the discussion, then you are a philosophy major and I'm changing the subject.
- igravious 16y ago10. If God exists but denies your existence then what does that make you? A stance of mine is: try not to talk to people who believe that they have a "rational" or "empirical" proof of God's existence for no bigger fool will you find.
- Gormo 16y agoI think a lot of the arguments that conclude that believing in God is irrational are actually prevaricating on the word "believe". You qualified definition '1' with "this is not silly" - on the contrary, I think it is in many cases the most reasonable option.