3 ms·
Much of what is written here is reasonable, but there seems to be places where the argument is overstated - for example, this statement is repeatedly used as a
by mannykannot 9y ago
Much of what is written here is reasonable, but there seems to be places where the argument is overstated - for example, this statement is repeatedly used as a justification for the claim that the so-called Basic Property must be simple:
"That leads us to expect that the faculty of language emerged along with modern humans or not long after, a very brief moment in evolutionary time. It follows, then, that the Basic Property should indeed be very simple."
This argument does not take into account the possibility (a very strong one, IMHO, FWIW) that the facility for language is an emergent property of the human brain, in which case language may have become possible as a result of one or more factors crossing a threshold, in a manner analogous to how a smoothly varying physical property can lead to discontinuous phase changes in matter. While there might have been one last change that took us across that threshold, it does not follow that language would be explained by that last step. In fact, it is not beyond the bounds of possibility that the final step was not directly related to language: for example, that an improvement in nutrition alone had the side-effect that properties already present became powerful enough for language to emerge.
I feel that Chomsky is arguing for the necessity of some basic properties, while seemingly suggesting that the reasonableness of these arguments extends to the proposition that these properties alone will provide a full explanation of language, once the details have been worked out.
- secstate 9y agoThese comments are why I love HNews. Thank you for your reasoned refutation of Noam Chomsky :) I especially appreciate your example of phase changes in matter which I think perfectly illuminates the limits of Chomsky's logic.