6 ms·
Look at the actual charges in the indictment. All the BTC-e stuff is not what he's charged with. He's charged with transferring stolen Mt Gox Bitcoins to Tradeh
by modeless 9y ago
Look at the actual charges in the indictment. All the BTC-e stuff is not what he's charged with. He's charged with transferring stolen Mt Gox Bitcoins to Tradehill, a San Francisco based exchange (now defunct). That's the US connection that will seal his extradition.
They also allege that BTC-e is (at least partially) hosted in the US and does business with many US companies, which is likely true. But that's not what they charged him with. Maybe that will come later after he's extradited and they have a chance to go through the evidence they no doubt collected when they arrested him.
On an unrelated note, it looks like the traceability of Bitcoin transactions played a major role in this. It turns out that Bitcoin is really not a great way to launder money, unless you want a record of your money laundering archived forever, redundantly, on a distributed system of computers around the world! I expect future crypto-locker viruses to switch to Monero instead of Bitcoin now that they can no longer cash out through BTC-e. Subsequently I expect to see Monero delisted from any exchange that follows KYC after some pressure from law enforcement.
- khuey 9y agoYes, the blockchain is a fantastic resource for Feds prosecuting financial crimes. In order to get away with these things you need to have flawless opsec, because the moment they can connect one thing to you everything quickly unravels.
- vocatus_gate 9y agoFor me it's now Monero or nothing.
- mahyarm 9y agoI would treat Monero & Zcash as the beta software it is. I wouldn't rely on it for anything for years.
- Taek 9y agoYeah new research is coming out frequently enough that reveals new and previously unknown weaknesses and patterns in the mixing strategies. The teams do a good job of responding quickly to address new issues, but previous trades that leaked information can't be fixed. The information is out there forever. If you are trying to stay out of jail, I'd consider Monero a good mid-term strategy. Anything else (including Zcash) of probably not even that great in the short term. (So few people use the anonymous part of Zcash that you have a terrible anonymity set). Dash, pivx , etcetera are just plain insecure.
- comex 9y agoFor one of charges in the indictment, "Operation of an Unlicensed Money Transmitting Business" (18 USC § 1960), they allege that BTC-e satisfied two conditions, either of which alone would have been sufficient to prove the charge. One of the conditions is knowingly transmitting funds derived from a criminal offense, but the other one is just "fail[ing] to comply with the money transmitting business registration requirements set forth in [31 USC § 5330]". So I'd say the BTC-e stuff is indeed part of "what he's charged with", albeit not the main focus.
- modeless 9y agoYou're absolutely right. I missed that.
- kadavero 9y agoThis is ridiculous overreach. It sets a dangerous precedent where any online trader must be mindful of all legislation of all possible jurisdictions on the world. Otherwise, sell porn, have one customer from Saudi Arabia, go for a vacation in Turkey, and here comes your flogging extradition trip. At the same time, US has a "Hague invasion act" authorizing military action against international prosecution of their officials.
- modeless 9y agoYou missed the part where he personally transferred stolen money into the US, and hosted his service in the US.
- kobeya 9y agoAs an actual cryptographer who has looked into it, I wouldn't put too much faith in Monero's fungibiliry. The story is not as good as the PR would have you believe, and is really not all that different from Bitcoin with CoinJoin.
- nubela 9y agoElaborate. Your statement says nothing but "I'm a software engineer so believe me what I say Slack app sucks'
- wbl 9y agoAnalysing monero traceability is hard. Early wallets picked addresses to use in bad ways. A lot of academic work us needed. Luckily ZeroCoin exists.
- kobeya 9y agoI don't know why you are being down voted, since you said exactly what I was alluding to. Monero's ring signature traceability is very hard to analyze. Even if the ring signature is not broken in a cryptographic sense, transactions can still be linked by the other fingerprints they leave, or by wide spectrum analysis. It's a bit like a game of sudoku. A mixin input could have 4 different coins, and technically you can't be certain from the signature which is the real input. But in reality you can do downstream or source analysis and come up with probabilities for whether the prior transactions were authored by the same wallet, or associate with other keys used by other mixin inputs. Every little bit adds to the probability of two addresses being linked, and it really doesn't take many bits of information to confirm or eliminate mixin inputs as being real or fake. This is notably different from how ZeroCoin operates, where the anonymity set is everyone and it is fully untraceable. However ZeroCoin has problems with respect to performance and deployment :\
- kbody 9y agoYou also forget Confidential Transactions. How can you do any kind of useful downstream or source analysis when you don't know the amounts and you have stealth addresses? Also you can have huge amount of mixins which use the total pool of TXs ever done. It's the same as RSA4096, in theory you could bruteforce eventually crack a key, but in reality it's not a viable attack. You're just saying abstract things without backing them up with details. Also Zcoin has scaling issues with TXs being 50x of Zcash (another Zerocoin-based implementation)
- simias 9y agoWe don't really know what steps they took to launder the money though, do we? Maybe they were dumb and directly moved the coins from a known hack address to Tradehill. If you're a bit patient and are willing to get your money only a small amount at a time I don't see why you wouldn't be able to launder even a significant amount of bitcoins. Use coin mixers, convert back and forth with other crypto-currencies (including Monero if you want), split and merge the coins, mix that with actual transactions to 3rd party accounts (gambling sites, donations, whatever)... Eventually people will lose track, or at the very least you'll have plausible deniability that the coins changed hands at some point.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoOnly way to launder BTC - break the history chain, so to speak - is to first pull it out of the network - which requires either an exchange, or like a street deal (cash for BTC). Exchanges require identification so either there's a dodgy one that doesn't ask for that, or you get a mule. Anyway, then you have cash money, you buy BTC back. Or keep the cash, I mean I wouldn't want to keep BTC if I had stolen it. It's pretty much worthless on its own - as proven by pretty much all media always going about $4 billion instead of 600K+ BTC.
- celticninja 9y agoActually you don't need to get it to cash, change it to another crypto such as LTC or ether on an exchange, send it off exchange to another exchange and buy back btc to have unlinked coins. You could also use a mixer for the alt coin as you move it between exchanges for further obfuscation. Most exchanges that deal in alt coins only require ID/verification if you want to exchange to fiat, so crypto to crypto can be done on anonymous accounts.
- venantius 9y agoSure, except that exchange will have a record of the transaction. So as long as they're still in business, the authorities can go to them and request them to provide a record of the transaction, and you have both wallet IDs.
- joosters 9y agoAnd this might be one reason why the US went after this guy - the BTC-e exchange was extremely popular for laundering criminal money. A google research talk showed over 95% of bitcoin ransoms were cashed out via BTC-e. Once the US have this guy in custody, they can then get their hands on the server transaction records, and chase down the criminals who extorted money from people and companies in the US.
- EGreg 9y agoIf you think about it, we are one step away from tracking everyone's crypto transactions. That step is putting pressure on exchanges to blacklist coins that have been through a mixer. Cash is the ultimate mixer because of lack of technology. But it's not hard to put pressure on exchanges. This is why digital money is ultimately traceable. And the most tracdabke money is one that has a global, distributed ledger :) Far better to have trustlines. You would have to track down friends of friends, and deanonymize people's public keys. Unlike Bitcoin, anyone can start a trustline with anyone else without authorization from the government :)
- Jabanga 9y ago>Subsequently I expect to see Monero delisted from any exchange that follows KYC after some pressure from law enforcement. This would be a very dangerous precedent for the cause of privacy. It's the financial equivalent of banning encrypted communication.
- joosters 9y agoBullshit. Every other bank and (non-crypto) exchange in existence requires some form of KYC, and they will want to know the source of larger funds. And isn't this an admission that Monero is of no real legal use? Otherwise, why would you care about cashing it out at an exchange? You could spend it on goods and services instead.
- Jabanga 9y agoThis is not a bank or cryptoexchange. It's an electronic currency. Your equating of banks/cryptoexchange, which are subject to FinCen regulations on currency conversion, with electronic currency is intellectually dishonest. It's a barely concealed rhetorical sleight of hand. You know very well that the corollary here would be banning cash deposits. A private electronic currency is the electronic equivalent of cash. >And isn't this an admission that Monero is of no real legal use? What kind of absurd conclusion is that? There are infinite number of possible non-criminal reasons why one would want to convert one currency to another. In fact, the currency having the property of not leaking private information has no bearing on that. >Otherwise, why would you care about cashing it out at an exchange? You could spend it on goods and services instead. This is absolute nonsense. Why do we have USD-YEN exchanges?
- PeterisP 9y agoThere's no dangerous precedent/slippery slope - in the financial world offering a money transfer service to anonymous customers is already banned, that's what KYC/AML laws are intended to do. There's no right to trade anonymously and for large transactions legitimate businesses are required to identify you and not accept anonymous customers (KYC requirement). It doesn't necessarily mean prohibiting anonymous instruments like physical cash or Monero, but it means that any non-small use of such instruments is required to be accompanied with documents about the transaction. E.g. you can legally sell stuff for a briefcase of cash, but you're required to declare the transaction, including the identity of that person (e.g., in USA, IRS form 8300 for cash amounts exceeding $10000; you can legally sell stuff online for Monero or whatever other consideration, but if it's a significant amount, then you are required to identify the person even if the payment instrument is anonymous.
- zeven7 9y ago> Subsequently I expect to see Monero delisted from any exchange that follows KYC after some pressure from law enforcement. This won't happen. KYC will still remain, but privacy is an important feature that many legitimate businesses want in crypto for completely legal and good reasons. Many of the businesses in the EEA are interested in Ethereum gaining privacy features, and Ethereum plans to add zkSNARKS. At that point it's not just Monereo, ZCash, etc that the exchanges would have to ban but Ethereum as well. It'll be a losing battle for law enforcement.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]