10 ms·
A WWII Vet Was Docked Pay for Escaping His German Captors
- epx 9y agoA millennial would demand 13 billions
- esturk 9y ago13$ in 1944 adjusted for inflations would be 180.38$ in 2017. Still a small payment for the DoD.
- Digit-Al 9y agoHow about the 73 years interest? :-)
- pimmen 9y agoWith the somewhat generous annual interest of 6%, it would be around $1000. Not exactly back breaking for the DoD (or the VA, for that matter, whatever department has this issue on their table).
- foota 9y agoYou're off by a factor of ten. Assuming monthly compounding: (1 + .06/12)^(12 * (2017-1944)) = 78.97 78.97 * 180 = 14214 However the final amount is highly sensitive to interest rate assumed, for different interest rates: .02 774.13 .04 3,321.26 .06 14,214.86 .08 60,692.55 .10 258,514.77 .12 1,098,489.57 However it's unlikely that the money would have been invested anyways.
- thomasz 9y agoYou are wrongly calculating with $180 instead of $13. The $180 figure is $13 adjusted by inflation.
- Retric 9y agoWhile true using 6% during periods where inflation was > 6% is a poor interest rate. IMO, inflation +4% is reasonable.
- ars 9y agoCan't include both interest and inflation. It's one or the other, not both.
- Sumaso 9y agoYou can certainly include both interest and inflation.
- libeclipse 9y agoHow so?
- LyndsySimon 9y agoI'm not a mathematician by any means, but I would think that (interest rate) - (rate of inflation) = (effective interest rate)
- pc86 9y agoNo
- smallnamespace 9y agoYou've just defined the real interest rate, as opposed to the nominal rate
- oliwarner 9y agoSay you put £100 in the bank 50 years ago. Compound interest tells us how much money we have. If we assume an improbably static 2% every year, today we have ~£270 in our account. Inflation doesn't work on top of that because £270 is what it's already worth today. Inflation tells us what our original £100 is worth in terms of buying power. If a loaf of bread cost £0.10 in 1967 but costs £1.50 today, we can say over 50 years there has been 150% inflation. These sorts of price index comparisons allow us to compare worth back then. Or in reverse, you can see this in very real terms. You could look at your £270 and see that would only buy you 180 loaves of bread. In 1967, your £100 would have garnered 1000 loaves. Interest has not kept up with inflation. You have lost money —in this example— by "saving" it. On a shorter timescale, RPI and CPI allow central banks to see inflation and —to a point— alter their base rates to help influence the balance of savers-vs-spenders, lessening the popular disposable cash, and lessening inflation. That's the theory, anyway.
- emn13 9y agoHe might have spent the money in ways that later benefited him - even if he bought a house that was 13$ more expensive, given the housing boom during his lifetime in many locations he would have made more than a 6% return. You're never going to be able to really figure that what-if game anyhow... I think interest is an appropriate simplification (certainly more appropriate than inflation).
- kobeya 9y agoPlus all the other cases that would now have to be granted based on precedent.
- emn13 9y agoAll those other cases of escaped prisoners of war?
- kobeya 9y agoFrom WW2? Probably quite a few.
- emn13 9y agoThat were captured and escaped? In which pay actually was docked? In which they can remember and document this? That are still alive today? That can't be more than a handful.
- pimmen 9y agoIf they're not alive today, I believe their families will get the money. The Baby Boomers came to be immediately after WW2, so that will be quite the collection of families waiting for their money.
- rosser 9y agoMy paternal grandfather was a B-25 navigator/bombardier. His plane was shot down over the Battle of the Bulge, and he spent the rest of the war in a PoW camp. The quality of the treatment (and particularly the nutrition) he received during his imprisonment compromised his health, and he died during my father's childhood. I have no idea if he received this benefit, or if he even knew about it. Dad's dead (motorcycle accident); I'll have to reach out to my aunt to see if she knows. It's more the curiosity than the money. If he hadn't received it, and survivors can claim it, I'd just donate it to some veteran's organization, anyway.
- fapjacks 9y agoThe thing about benefits (and receiving them) is that the more people that file for them, the more paperwork it creates, and the more time until the people that deserve the benefits receive them. People applying for benefits that "do not deserve them" are partially the cause of the "delay" part of the old VA mantra "delay and deny until they die". I'm not saying it's right, or that it should be one way or another. I'm just explaining how the VA universe works.
- jxramos 9y agoIf you make the time for carrying it all out, please blog about it and post it back to HN. Should be very interesting. Thank you for sharing.
- yitchelle 9y agoIf you are captured by the enemy and held in prison, your pay is docked? It is probably my ignorance of the military payment structure, but what the reasoning is behind this?
- sbisker 9y agoIt sounded like if you are captured you are paid a dollar a day until you are released or can escape - but can't collect pay while "running away". It seemed unclear whether that was in lieu of normal pay or in addition to it. I imagine it was worded this way so someone couldn't just be "escaping" for an unknown length of time and just disappear - removes the incentive to not return right away. Still, I'm not how anyone would be able to prove or disprove which day he escaped in the first place - not like his captors gave him a receipt - so the whole thing is pretty goofy.
- rosser 9y agoI think your comment's parent was asking about what happens to your regular military pay, during your time as a PoW. That's what I read, anyway.
- dogma1138 9y agoYou keep getting it (at a different rate), you also keep getting it when you are declared MIA. You only stop getting paid when you are declared dead (or discharged), the former awards survivor benefits to your next of kin and or dependents. http://myarmybenefits.us.army.mil/Home/Benefit_Library/Federal_Benefits_Page/Captive__POW__MIA_Entitlements.html?serv=147 http://myarmybenefits.us.army.mil/Home/Benefit_Library/Feder...
- jrimbault 9y agoIt would make for a good Monty Python skit. A calm German officer behind a desk giving "escape receipt" to a giddy British soldier.
- 9y ago
- phillc73 9y agoThey tried again, and in April 1944, pulled off the same stunt, ducking their captors on an unguarded forced march. This time, Ramotnik and his brother-in-arms got away. A few days later, they heard the news: The Allies had won. Surely they mean April 1945 if "a few days later" they heard the Allies had won.
- metalliqaz 9y agoYeah, probably a typo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victory_in_Europe_Day https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victory_in_Europe_Day
- micael_dias 9y agoUnrelated but: that's how you should design your mobile website sharing plugin if you must do it. Small size, light color, 0 distractions.
- tedunangst 9y agoWhy now?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TallGuyShort 9y agoI doubt he's suddenly pursuing this himself. Neither this article nor the source it cites documents any action he's taking. In fact, the source even says he had to dig through piles of documents during the interview to find the details of the specific mission on which he was captured. That sounds more like someone heard about the story and approached him to do an interview, adding a Click-Baity headline.
- SeanDav 9y agoOT: A bit of fun: In 1626, Manhattan was supposedly bought for equivalent of $24 (in beads). If invested at 5% Annual interest, compounded monthly, it would now be worth around $7 billion (assuming my online calculator is working correctly). So our man should bequeath his $13 + interest and ensure the terms of the will state the the capital + interest is maintained for at least 400 years and someone will be able to inherit a nice tidy sum!
- morganvachon 9y agoFour hundred years from now, if humans even still exist and we're still under a scarcity based economy, those billions of dollars will likely not be worth much.
- SketchySeaBeast 9y agoShould make a nice nest to put your bottlecaps in.
- delinka 9y agoNot to mention the number of heirs one might expect to divide the inheritance amongst. Might just end up a pittance per person after all.
- spqr0a1 9y agoExpanding on this tangent, it was closer to $300 in goods (as well as indefinite food and lodging for anyone in the tribe and a tacit assumption of military aid). Assuming just the tangible assets were invested in the most obvious way at the time, (dutch east india company being the most notable publicly traded company.) the dividend rate averaged 18% until 1796. If you compound with 18% for the first 170 years then 5% after, it would be more than enough to buy back Manhattan at it's current property value!
- barking 9y agoThe members of the merchant navy were the most ill-treated group of service people in Britain during the war. These were the seamen who crewed the cargo ships transporting food, munitions and fuel across the Atlantic, and e.g. to Murmansk in Northern Russia, etc. Their casaulty rates were higher than any branch of the armed forces except bomber command. As civilians, on shore leave it was common for them to be abused for not being in uniform. After the war they were given no recognition and did not have any official representation at commemorations. But one of the most unfair aspects of their treatment was the fact that the day their ship was sunk was the day their pay stopped.
- justadeveloper2 9y agoPutting it all in perspective: If you lived through the 1940s at all you won the freaking lottery.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoWhen more than half the population wins it it's a bad lottery. Times may have sucked but you don't need to exaggerate by an order of magnitude.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- justadeveloper2 9y ago50 million dead attributed to that war.
- DamnYuppie 9y agoYes that is a lot but it is no where near 1/2 of the worlds population.
- mikeash 9y agoThe world population in 1940 was about 2.3 billion, so WWII killed around 2% of everyone alive. Compare with the An Lushan Rebellion, which killed somewhere between 13-36 million people at a time when the world population was only about 200-300 million, killing 4-18% of everyone alive.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- libeclipse 9y agoTo be honest, bigger injustices happened during the war. I honestly cannot find it within myself to care about one man's $13.
- Pica_soO 9y agoI honestly find it interesting. After all- it depicts how completely alien and far-away the idea of war is to this generation. Everyone in this discussion has lost money due to a contractor or buisness partner not paying, but nobody in the room can imagine the real world atrocities of WW2 or WW1. Imagine, if LA was besieged and starved for 3 years like St.Petersburg was. This generation cant even imagine how it is to run hungry- for a day. That people can scrap tapestry from the wall, eat there pets, burn there furniture - and finally eat other people, all that, is so far away by now- it does not even appear in war and horror movies.
- gcb0 9y agoyou don't even have to besiege LA. just close I-5. done.
- mattnewton 9y agoUnrelated but that site was unreadable for me on mobile, repeatedly redirected me to ad pages that tried to look like Facebook. What's up with that?
- squozzer 9y agoHaving done a few years for uncle slam, this doesn't surprise me much. Still, would love to read the regulation justifying the docked pay. HNers seem a pretty well-read bunch, but you might want to read Catch-22 between TED talks.