13 ms·
> It seems inconsistent that ICOs are seen as securities whereas the underlying asset isn't. I'm not sure why this would be inconsistent. I admit there's some
by amluto 9y ago
> It seems inconsistent that ICOs are seen as securities whereas the underlying asset isn't.
I'm not sure why this would be inconsistent. I admit there's some confusion in the boundary between securities and commodities, but one can certainly have a hedge fund made up from currency or gold futures (neither of which is a security) and have ownership interest in the fund be a security.
(IANAL, none of this is intended to be advice or taken as authoritative.)
> But many ICO won't have to be ... issued by humans
If AIs are issuing ICOs, then I would imagine they would have to obey the law just like anyone else. Heck, very few if any securities are issued by humans -- they're mostly issued by corporations.
- smokeyj 9y ago> I'm not sure why this would be inconsistent You could also think of bitcoin as an ICO. There's 21 million tokens that Satoshi sold, that people purchased with the expectation of profiting from. Boom, it's a security. If the financing model of a traditional blockchain is okay, but issuing tokens are not.. then programmers are about to get very creative with how get around loopholes. > But many ICO won't have to be ... issued by humans I mean the contract will be written by a person. But instead of having a central "issuer" (like a core team) the issuing mechanism is automated via the contract on the blockchain.