5 ms·
$ host -t aaaa news.ycombinator.com.cdn.cloudflare.net. news.ycombinator.com.cdn.cloudflare.net has no AAAA record But there's an option to turn it on, docum
by Symbiote 9y ago
$ host -t aaaa news.ycombinator.com.cdn.cloudflare.net.
news.ycombinator.com.cdn.cloudflare.net has no AAAA record
But there's an option to turn it on, documented here: https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/200168746-How-do-I-turn-the-Cloudflare-IPv6-gateway-on-or-off- https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/200168746-H...
- mrkrabo 9y agoProbably the software requires an update to support IPv6 addresses and they simply know it's not worth the hassle.
- 3pt14159 9y agoCan you explain to me what will happen if I don't turn on the AAAA record? Like in theory of course I want to support IPv6, but in practice I've got a huge TODO list, and if there are present work-arounds that are doing good enough for now, I'd like to prioritise it correctly.
- andruby 9y agoThis is why IPv6 adoption is slow. There are always more pressing issues.
- ancarda 9y agoThe two biggest arguments are Carrier Grade NAT and dodgy transitional stacks. 1) ISPs are increasingly deploying Carrier Grade NAT, which puts several people behind a single IP. This completely breaks end-to-end as you can't port forward but if you're running a website, the worst issue is if you ban an IP address, you could be cutting off several legitimate users to get rid of 1 person. It's like banning a whole country because of a few people which Wikipedia has done in the past by mistake: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:82.148.97.69 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:82.148.97.69 see https://techcrunch.com/2007/01/01/wikipedia-bans-qatar/ https://techcrunch.com/2007/01/01/wikipedia-bans-qatar/ This problem will only get worse as time goes on. The Internet is starting to feel broken when an entire country shares a single IP address. 2) In some cases, ISPs might address the shortage slightly differently, by serving up an IPv6 address that proxies back to your website over IPv4. To you it looks like Carrier Grade NAT, but you can actually do this yourself if you have an IPv6 enabled server (Linode, DigitalOcean work) and use nginx to reverse proxy. That way you can at-least set an X-Forwarded-For header that will give you better analytics and more precise blocking. Either you do it or the ISP will do it for you but give absolutely no data.
- danieldk 9y ago1) ISPs are increasingly deploying Carrier Grade NAT, which puts several people behind a single IP. This completely breaks end-to-end as you can't port forward Carrier grade NAT breaks a lot of things in subtle ways. E.g. our ISP does DS-Lite to encapsulate IPv4 in IPv6. For months, our internet connection would sometimes seem dead for a couple of minutes. The router was fine and had uplink. At some point I figured out that it often happened after a device woke from sleep and that IPv6 continued to work fine. It turns out that Bittorrent Sync was culprit. When a device woke up, BTSync syncs any changes and opens a boatload of connections through different ports. Apparently, the ISP's carrier grade NAT has some QoS where it starts dropping connections if too many ports are opened at the same time. We shut down BTSync on all devices and never encountered the problem again [1]. At the time Bittorrent Inc. and later Resilio did not really seem interested to add IPv6 support. [1] Of course, another theory is that they intentionally throttle Bittorrent traffic, but that doesn't explain why no IPv4 connections could be made while IPv6 worked fine.
- ancarda 9y agoI'm absolutely fucking amazed BitTorrent Sync, recently created peer to peer software, didn't have IPv6 since day one? IPv6 just makes P2P easier and more reliable as there's no NAT anymore. Why wouldn't you want that?
- mavendependency 9y agoMobile carriers here are bringing back NAT on ipv6 now. Wannacry fears? NAT for the sake of firewalling? Phones still seem to get individual addresses.
- fulafel 9y agoIf anyone sees a mobile provider does this, please complain loudly.
- betaby 9y agoWhich one? Really curious. Another point to mention, that I've seen mobile operators sends you multiple /64s, thus if you run in adnroid shell 'ip addr' you see one /64 while if you connect say to ripe.net it shows completely different IPv6 address from different range, while still no NAT. Perhaps that was your case, perhaps not. Details would be very interesting.
- ancarda 9y agoHacker News used to have a GitHub repo somewhere on https://github.com/HackerNews/ https://github.com/HackerNews/ where they hosted an issue tracker - several people raised this and their response was something along the lines of "we can't yet as our anti-spam code relies on accurate geolocation and some other things easier/possible in IPv4". Unfortunately I can't find a link - I think they closed the issue tracker. Perhaps dang can comment? I'm typing from memory so it might be remembering incorrectly.
- zubspace 9y agoDoes someone know how to ban single users based on IPv6? Is this even possible? What is the alternative?
- EwanToo 9y agoIt's not possible on IPv4 either, your IP is one of the easiest thing for you to change... Browser/device finger printing is probably the best option at the moment, but you'll get plenty of false positives amongst privacy aware users who block fingerprinting.
- admiun 9y agoI think the rough IPv6 equivalent of a single IPv4 ban would be to ban a /64 subnet. This bans all users in that subnet which is the same as banning an IPv4 subnet hiding behind a single NAT address.
- kuschku 9y agoThis would be the case, except home users can often get a /56 or /48.
- mrkrabo 9y agoIt's the same as in IPv4. If the user has a static IP address, in IPv4 you ban a /32 (i.e., one address, his own). In IPv6 you'd have to ban the entire range allocated to the user, usually a /64. (edited) If the user has a dynamic IP address, well, you're on your own. :D